Champions League

Don’t let tech kick football joy into touch

2017-04-23 06:18
Bayern Munich’s Arjen Robben gestures as referee Viktor Kassai shows a contentious red card to team-mate Arturo Vidal during their Champions League loss to Real Madrid. (Francisco Seco, AP)

Johannesburg - You can either treat the incredible story of Hiroo Onoda as one of foolishness or as a testimony to sticking to one’s principles.

Don’t remember Onoda? He was the Japanese soldier who hunkered down in the jungle for nearly 30 years, refusing to accept that World War 2 was over. It was not until 1974, when the handful of his comrades who had also held out succumbed to the elements and old age, that he came out of hiding.

As the use of technology in football gains acceptance, I cannot help but feel like Onoda. You see, I am one of the dwindling number of Neanderthals who believe that the purity of the beautiful game will be compromised if there is too much technological intrusion into the natural flow of things.

The apostles of video-assisted refereeing (VAR) bellow every time there are controversial decisions in big games. You will hear them moaning about how bad refereeing cost the “deserving” side glory.

Inexperienced amateur

They were singing their song a few days ago, following Real Madrid’s much-debated victory over Bayern Munich in the Champions League quarterfinal.

They attributed the 6-3 aggregate score to what they believed were two offside goals by Real’s Cristiano Ronaldo and a “dubious” second yellow card given to Bayern’s Arturo Vidal. Had the referee and his assistants been up to scratch, they argued, the outcome would have been very different. Just like Khanyi Mbau would still be black if skin lighteners had not been invented.

Carlo Ancelotti, the well-travelled Bayern coach, took the defeat like an inexperienced amateur, moaning as if he had not once benefited from borderline decisions during his long career.

“I know it’s football and it happens sometimes, but not this serious of a mistake. I believe we played very well. I thought we deserved more,” he said.

Then he reached for the technology panacea, saying that “perhaps it is time to have video”.

“You have to have a referee with more quality in a quarterfinal. Or have video. There are too many errors,” Ancelotti ranted.

Given the backing from commentators and pundits around the world, the outcome of Tuesday’s game will become the new rallying point for VAR campaigners.

Better eyesight

A voice of reason came from one of Ancelotti’s charges.

A heartbroken Thiago Alcántara said: “We have been completely screwed over, but we can not change anything in the past.”

The midfielder was, however, against the dilution of the human element in the sport. He said that while VAR might help ensure more accurate decision-making, “it takes away the essence ... we just need officials to be competent enough to control these games”.

That is exactly the point. What sets football apart from the sanitised versions of other major sporting codes is that it has retained its essence. It is a 90-minute game played by 22 people, officiated by a referee and assistants. During those 90 minutes, the referee is the final arbiter. He or she is more powerful than the megacorporations that sponsor the game, the magnates who own the clubs, the millionaire sports-car driving celebrity players and the ferocious, emotionally charged fans who believe they know the rule book and have better eyesight than the officials on the field.

Referees also have the power to determine the quality of a game – they can make or break games with bad decisions, authoritarian handling or lax officiating.

But, over the past decade, there has been a movement seeking to wrestle this power away from referees and give it over to machines. For all his sins, greasy former Fifa boss Sepp Blatter used his enormous power to resist this movement. But even he could not stop the tide, eventually allowing for experimentation with goal-line technology. Today, this technology is the norm in major leagues around the world.

The victors now boast that it has removed the controversies around scoring goals. Gone are the heated “it was a goal, it was not a goal” debates that enlivened the existences of millions.

Human officiating

Thus emboldened, the killjoys are turning their attention to other aspects of the officials’ duties. They now want technology to rule on close offside decisions, a move that will strip the highly trained professional assistants of their roles.

Sensing an imminent breakthrough on the offside decision front, there are murmurs of a move on to the rest of the pitch. For the advocates of technology, the addition of a goal-post assistant is not enough. This too must be monitored by technology, as must some upfield touch-line calls. Talk has begun of technology assisting in foul and handball decisions.

The VAR evangelists say that football cannot stand in the way of progress and modernity. They also argue that with football being a multitrillion-dollar industry, the outcome cannot be left to chance – intimating that this is exactly what unassisted human officiating entails.

The purists must counter by saying that euphoria – football has the power to deliver one of the highest doses of this precious commodity – cannot be left in the hands of machines.

Read more on:    johannesburg  |  soccer
NEXT ON SPORT24X

What To Read Next

 

Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
0 comments
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining
Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

Fixtures
Tuesday, 17 October 2017
Real Madrid v Tottenham Hotspur, Estadio Santiago Bernabeu 20:45
Manchester City v Napoli, Etihad Stadium 20:45
Maribor v Liverpool, Ljudski vrt 20:45
APOEL v Borussia Dortmund, Neo GSP 20:45
Spartak Moskva v Sevilla, Otkrytiye Arena 20:45
RB Leipzig v Porto, Red Bull Arena 20:45
Monaco v Besiktas, Stade Louis II. 20:45
Feyenoord v Shakhtar Donetsk, Stadion Feijenoord 20:45
Wednesday, 18 October 2017
Qarabag v Atletico Madrid, Bakı Olimpiya Stadionu 18:00
Juventus v Sporting CP, Allianz Stadium 20:45
Bayern Munchen v Celtic, Allianz-Arena 20:45
Barcelona v Olympiakos Piraeus, Camp Nou 20:45
Benfica v Manchester United, Estadio do Sport Lisboa e Benfica (da Luz) 20:45
Anderlecht v PSG, Stade Constant Vanden Stock 20:45
Chelsea v Roma, Stamford Bridge 20:45
CSKA Moskva v Basel, VEB Arena 20:45
Tuesday, 31 October 2017
Celtic v Bayern Munchen, Celtic Park 21:45
Sporting CP v Juventus, Estadio Jose Alvalade 21:45
Atletico Madrid v Qarabag, Estadio Wanda Metropolitano 21:45
Manchester United v Benfica, Old Trafford 21:45
PSG v Anderlecht, Parc des Princes 21:45
Basel v CSKA Moskva, St. Jakob-Park 21:45
Olympiakos Piraeus v Barcelona, Stadio Georgios Karaiskaki 21:45
Roma v Chelsea, Stadio Olimpico 21:45
Wednesday, 01 November 2017
Besiktas v Monaco, Vodafone Stadyumu 19:00
Liverpool v Maribor, Anfield 21:45
Porto v RB Leipzig, Estadio Do Dragao 21:45
Sevilla v Spartak Moskva, Estadio Ramon Sanchez Pizjuan 21:45
Shakhtar Donetsk v Feyenoord, Oblasny SportKomplex Metalist 21:45
Borussia Dortmund v APOEL, Signal-Iduna-Park 21:45
Napoli v Manchester City, Stadio San Paolo 21:45
Tottenham Hotspur v Real Madrid, Wembley Stadium 21:45
Tuesday, 21 November 2017
Spartak Moskva v Maribor, Otkrytiye Arena 19:00
Besiktas v Porto, Vodafone Stadyumu 19:00
Sevilla v Liverpool, Estadio Ramon Sanchez Pizjuan 21:45
Manchester City v Feyenoord, Etihad Stadium 21:45
APOEL v Real Madrid, Neo GSP 21:45
Borussia Dortmund v Tottenham Hotspur, Signal-Iduna-Park 21:45
Monaco v RB Leipzig, Stade Louis II. 21:45
Napoli v Shakhtar Donetsk, Stadio San Paolo 21:45
Wednesday, 22 November 2017
Qarabag v Chelsea, Bakı Olimpiya Stadionu 19:00
CSKA Moskva v Benfica, VEB Arena 19:00
Juventus v Barcelona, Allianz Stadium 21:45
Sporting CP v Olympiakos Piraeus, Estadio Jose Alvalade 21:45
Atletico Madrid v Roma, Estadio Wanda Metropolitano 21:45
PSG v Celtic, Parc des Princes 21:45
Basel v Manchester United, St. Jakob-Park 21:45
Anderlecht v Bayern Munchen, Stade Constant Vanden Stock 21:45
Logs
Team P W PTS
Team P W PTS
Team P W PTS
Team P W PTS
Team P W PTS
Team P W PTS
Team P W PTS
Team P W PTS
Previous Results

Date Home Team Result Away Team
Vote

Which English Premier League club will progress furthest in this season's Champions League?

 
 
Men
Women
Love 2 Meet
Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter

Featured

The 2017/18 PSL season is under way. Can Bidvest Wits defend their title? Will Soweto giants Kaizer Chiefs or Orlando Pirates emerge victorious? Or will the bookies' favourites, Mamelodi Sundowns, taste success for a record eighth time? Stay glued to Sport24 to find out!

Latest blogs
 

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

 
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.