Share

Brazil's exit: Worse than 1950?

Belo Horizonte - Brazil's humiliating exit from the Soccer World Cup is as close as it gets to a national trauma in a football-mad nation whose identity is closely associated with its team.

As it happened: Germany v Brazil

The country of 200 million people had hoped to win the title at home and erase memories of its 1950 World Cup defeat to Uruguay in Rio de Janeiro, the notorious "Maracanazo" at the Maracana Stadium.

But instead Brazil suffered the worst defeat in its 100-year footballing history, falling 7-1 to Germany at the Mineirao Stadium in the southeastern city of Belo Horizonte - now the infamous "Mineirazo."

"It looked like a game between adults and children," wrote the prominent sports analyst Juca Kfouri on his blog. "Brazilian football has never experienced such humiliation."

The country's newspapers called it the biggest disgrace in the team's history, with globoesporte.com dubbing it the "Shame of Shames."

But other analysts said the Mineirazo could not compare to the Maracanazo.

"In 1950 we felt we had an unbeatable team and losing at the Maracana was unthinkable," Michel Castellar, an analyst at the sports daily Lance, told AFP.

"This time, we knew that we had a team with a lot of flaws and that maybe they would not reach the final. Was it a national humiliation? Yes, because of the number of goals. But it wasn't a new Maracanazo," he said.

In 1950, Brazil had yet to win the World Cup and getting the title would have put the developing country on the map.

Since then, the Selecao has won a record five World Cup titles, gave the world the "jogo bonito" (beautiful game) and produced football giants as Pele, Garrincha, Zico and Ronaldo, winning over fans among the rich and the poor, white or black.

Today's superstar Neymar was unable to play the semi-final after suffering a broken vertebrae in the previous game.

The power of football put a lid on protests that had marked the run-up to the tournament.

Hundreds of thousands of people had held protests last year during the Confederations Cup, denouncing the record $11bn spent on the World Cup and demanding the money be spent on better hospitals and schools instead.

There were a few protests that attracted small crowds during the World Cup, though after Tuesday's defeat some fans wondered whether hosting the tournament had been worth the cost.

Although the Selecao lost, the tournament itself can be considered a success, with fears of chaos never materialising despite delays in the construction of stadiums, experts said. And the games were full of surprises, upsets and goals.

"This World Cup has been a real gift for Brazil," said Pedro Trengrouse, a United Nations consultant for the tournament.

While the low point for fans was seeing the Selecao's horrific defeat, experts say Brazilians now know how to cope with both triumphs and disappointments.

"There have been many cups since 1950. There were victories and defeats. Everybody is used to this," said Lamartine da Costa, a sports management expert at Rio de Janeiro State University.

"The Maracanazo was something that was never repeated. It was unprecedented," he said.

Costa said the continent-sized country was much more isolated in 1950.

"This isolation created an inward-looking culture. Brazilians don't understand others very well. The same thing happens with other large countries like the United States, Russia or China.

"There is an unrealistic feeling of power and surprises come when things you expect don't happen. One of the theories is that's what happened in 1950," he said.

Today, Brazil is the world's seventh biggest economy and 40 million of its people were lifted out of poverty in the past decade.

They demand more prosperity and better quality of life, but football is no longer their only passion.

And Brazilians relate less with their millionaire stars, who play mostly across the world in Europe.

"Before, the players represented a football closer to amateurism," Costa said. "Their behavior was exemplary, representing the values of the homeland and the love of football."

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Join News24 today
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Voting Booth
How much would you be prepared to pay for a ticket to watch the Springboks play against the All Blacks at Ellis Park or Cape Town Stadium this year?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
R0 - R200
32% - 1839 votes
R200 - R500
32% - 1807 votes
R500 - R800
19% - 1100 votes
R800 - R1500
8% - 468 votes
R1500 - R2500
3% - 193 votes
I'd pay anything! It's the Boks v All Blacks!
5% - 258 votes
Vote
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.

LEARN MORE