Ex-refs predict trouble if VAR used at World Cup

2018-01-21 16:50
Goal decision system (Getty Images)

Berlin - Whether the video assistant referee (VAR) will feature at the World Cup finals is yet to be decided, but there are fears the system could spell trouble for Russia 2018.

The fate of the VAR in Russia this June will be debated at a key meeting of the International Football Association Board (IFAB) in Zurich on Monday.

A final decision is expected to be made by FIFA in March.

The aim of the VAR system is to eradicate blatant refereeing errors -- for example, Diego Maradona's infamous 'Hand of God' goal at the 1986 World Cup finals.

The system is being tested in Germany's Bundesliga and Italy's Serie A this season.

Fans complain about long delays leading to confusing -- and in same cases, plain wrong -- decisions made by the VAR during league games.

The system has just started being used in some cup games in England and the Spanish league will follow suit for 2018/19.

- PR disaster -

The system suffered a public relations disaster in Germany last November when Hellmut Krug, the VAR project manager for the German FA, was removed as supervisor.

His demotion came immediately after German daily Bild alleged he had influenced the VAR to intervene to the benefit of Schalke, his home town club.

The technology also regularly broke down in the opening weeks, which dented further confidence in the system with one eye on the World Cup.

"We are going to send referees to Russia who have never worked with the VAR before," former Swiss referee Urs Meier, who officiated at the 1998 and 2002 World Cup finals, told German magazine Kicker.

"It is impossible to prepare with just a few trial exercises, because they in no way account for the speed and real-time pressure of a World Cup match.

"The VAR is like an airbag: it can help in an emergency, but only in case of a real emergency."

Mistakes have been made even though referees in Italy and Germany trained with the system for a year before using the VAR during league matches.

Just like in Germany, there have be complaints and controversial scenes in Serie A, but the idea of using the VAR at Russia 2018 has won support in Italy.

A national training unit is about to open in Coverciano, Florence, where FIFA will send referees will learn how to use the VAR system.

"FIFA has selected Coverciano as the pilot centre and World Cup referees will come here to get ready to use this new technology," said Carlo Tavecchio, the outgoing president of the Italian FA, proudly.

The feeling in Italy is that the VAR has passed the point of no return.

"Those who have not yet taken to VAR will do eventually - we can not go back," said Marcello Nicchi, president of Italy's union of referees.

"Out of 900 incidents (in Serie A), five mistakes have been made."

Yet many top players are unimpressed.

Germany international Sami Khedira gave the VAR system a clear 'thumbs down' last November.

"The players do not know anymore whether or not to celebrate after a goal," said the Juventus midfielder.

"A lot of emotion and passion has been lost."

Italy's legendary goalkeeper Gianluigi Buffon echoed the comments of his Juventus team-mate.

"You told us that VAR would be used in clear-cut incidents where there were mistakes, but now you are even checking the replays for a trodden toe or a finger in an ear," Buffon told reporters.

"It's no longer football... it's turning into water polo."

FIFA president Gianni Infantino has said he wants VAR technology at 2018 World Cup

"We can't imagine a World Cup in 2018 being decided by a referee's error," Infantino said last October.

Many feel FIFA will not back down.

"I can't imagine that the people who have implemented this project will suddenly say 'no'," predicts Germany's Markus Merk, who refereed the finals of the 2003 Champions League and Euro 2004.

"That's why I'm convinced the VAR will be used at the World Cup in Russia, but I don't think it will give a satisfactory result."

Read more on:    swc 2018  |  soccer


Read News24’s Comments Policy

Love 2 Meet
English Premiership flutter

Take Sport24's "expert" tips at your peril...

Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter


The 2019/20 Absa Premiership season is in full swing. Will Mamelodi Sundowns retain their title? Or can one of Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates, Wits, SuperSport United - or another team perhaps - snatch glory from the Brazilians? Be sure to visit Sport24 for all the latest news!

Latest blogs

After Stuart Baxter stepped down as Bafana Bafana head coach, who would you like to see take over?

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.