Why Boks and Proteas will probably fail in World Cup quest

2019-02-27 13:13
Rassie Erasmus
Rassie Erasmus (Getty Images)

Cape Town - It is indeed with great sadness that I write this piece as it smacks of negativity and pessimism.

However, there seem to be far too many alarm bells and warning signs in the lead-up to two events that the nation so dearly looks forward to, both occurring only once every four years.

The Cricket and Rugby World Cups excitingly take place in the same year. Add to this the Africa Cup of Nations (let’s all pray that Bafana Bafana do qualify) and you already have a jam-packed sporting year in the making.

However, what are the chances of us really doing well at these events and landing the coveted dream of winning two world titles in the same year?

As a die-hard, lifelong fan, who has witnessed it all, this is probably the first time that I expect absolutely nothing from either of our flagship teams.

It is not without serious thought, common sense, logic and damning evidence (detailed below) that this will not be our year.

Poor support staff

Both Ottis Gibson and Rassie Erasmus come with a fair amount of pedigree and even success at the highest of levels. Gibson led a weak West Indies team to ICC silverware (a World T20 title) while Erasmus has also won titles and accumulated valuable experience along his journey, most notably at the Cheetahs, Munster and in his role of technical advisor at the successful 2007 World Cup. Both are former players in their sport, which augurs well for their futures as head coaches.

However, their support staff leaves much to be desired!

Defensive guru Jacques Nienaber is probably the only stand-out, but seems to have lost some his mojo under Erasmus as the team has leaked tries. Swys de Bruin has one eye elsewhere with the Lions. Why not hire someone who will solely focus in the Boks? There are many candidates. A Kiwi won’t hurt either. Matt Proudfoot didn’t exactly cover himself in glory during the doomed Allister Coetzee era and nobody knows what Mzwandile Stick’s role actually is. A man who was fired under the Coetzee regime but suddenly brought back. Strange, considering the wide range of alternative candidates with far more experience.

The Proteas are no better. Hiring a school-level batting coach (Dale Benkenstein) who never played at the highest level was always going to come back to bite the team. All one has to do is think about the numerous batting collapses of late, game after game. How many of our players have scored centuries lately across the formats? Again, so many far better qualified coaches to choose from across the globe. Since Justin Ontong joined the team as fielding coach, there has been a serious dip in standards and multiple dropped catches. Assistant coach Malibongwe Maketa also lacks the credentials of other seasoned coaches and one wonders what value he actually brings to proceedings at only 38 years of age. Where are the Geoffrey Toyanas, Shaun Pollocks and Jacques Kallis’ of the world?


We all know about the strict transformation policies forced onto our teams, but let’s not delve too much into this sensitive topic as it has been done to death. Government’s 50% target for the Boks' World Cup squad are far from being realised, but let’s hope this is not a mandatory requirement come September. The Proteas also have a strict target to meet albeit a ‘seasonal average’ one (a minimum of 6 non-white players in every XI across all formats, including 3 Africans). I can’t help but wonder if this is the reason for our best player Kagiso Rabada being overplayed, so that this number is met (especially with Lungi Ngidi out injured). However, all players do seem to be there on merit.

Also, when we won the rugby showpiece in 2007, it was on the back of four years of continuity and a building up of caps from a core squad of 20 layers or so. Due to the disastrous Coetzee era and Rassie doing an ambulance job, we had to start from scratch last year and this derailed any momentum that we hoped to have had compared to 2007. There are far too many spots and combinations that are uncertain.

The Proteas have also failed to settle on a starting XI and have only the five Sri Lankan One-Day Internationals to decide on a squad of 15. Poor planning indeed. During the recent Pakistan series, we selected players who are never going to make the squad (Dane Paterson, Beuran Hendricks). Also, why are bowlers such as Dale Steyn and Rabada coming in at No 8 in the batting line-up? That is far too high. We need a second all-rounder to partner Andile Phehlukwayo and this should have been planned two years in advance!


The above-mentioned two key aspects are just the tip of the iceberg and there are other damning facts that need to be looked at - fast. The Proteas have many old players who are off-form (Hashim Amla, Imran Tahir) while a stalwart like JP Duminy is still injured and talisman AB de Villiers is no longer with us. Are we going to persist with them in the name of experience? The number of top rugby players who have left our shores is yet another dent in our chances.

Yes there are positives such as the captaincy of both teams, the Boks' series win against England and beating the All Blacks away last year, but these are far outweighed by all the question marks.

My message to the men in green and gold would be to prove me wrong and pleasantly surprise us (seeing Faf and Siya lift those cups will be the ultimate panacea for our country) as early exits or ‘par-for-the-course knockout-round eliminations’ would hardly be surprising at all.

Dhirshan Gobind is a respected freelance sports columnist and is a writer for the South African Football Association (SAFA).

Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

Read more on:    proteas  |  springbok  |  cwc 2019  |  rwc 2019  |  cricket  |  rugby


Read News24’s Comments Policy

Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights

Love 2 Meet
English Premiership flutter

Take Sport24's "expert" tips at your peril...

Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter


The 2018/19 Absa Premiership season is in full swing. Will Mamelodi Sundowns retain their title? Or can one of Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates, Wits, SuperSport United - or another team perhaps - snatch glory from the Brazilians? Be sure to visit Sport24 for all the latest news!

Latest blogs

Which of the 4 South African team will finish with the fewest Super Rugby SA Conference points?

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.