On the 'stand-off' between Nick Mallett and Ashwin Willemse

    2018-05-22 08:25

    *** This column was originally published in 2016 on the News24 Voices platform following a previous on-air incident between Nick Mallett and Ashwin Willemse ***

    Some among us refer to Saturday night’s standoff between SuperSport commentators Nick Mallett and Ashwin Willemse after the Springbok victory over Ireland as a “mini-rant” - others, using Afrikaans, calls it an “onderonsie”.

    WATCH: Not the first time Nick Mallett and Ashwin Willemse have clashed live on air

    Briefly, this is what happened: Mallett made a remark in which he implicated the whole panel, consisting also of Naas Botha and Hanyani Shimange, as purportedly having predicted in the 55th minute of the Test match that the Boks were heading for a second loss against the Irish visitors.

    Willemse then interjected, calling Mallett’s bluff: “No, Nick, you said it; not we.” But Mallett, always allowed the space to dominate the pre-match build-up, half-time, and post-match discussions simply continued. Willemse, however, wouldn’t budge and repeated his viewpoint until the camera moved to him. Apart from setting the record straight he also reminded Mallett - and informed viewers - that he, Willemse, had a different view: He believed the Boks could pull it through.

    On, seasoned sports writer Kevin McCallum records the incident as follows:

    “After the analysis had turned back to the bad, Willemse stuck his hand up and went on a mini rant. No one in the SuperSport studio could get a word in. ‘We need to support the Boks… We can’t slag them off so much. They deserve more from ‘us’.’ […] Mallett looked suitably cowed by Willemse. He agreed the Boks needed support, but …

    “And it is the but … that must be remembered,” continues McCallum. “Saturday was one of the great Springbok escapes, a turnaround to remember and inspire.”

    Mallett, a former Springbok player and coach, and Willemse also differed on what caused the “turnaround”: to the former it had much to do with the impact made by the (Lions) substitutions, in particular Lions players like Warren Whiteley, Ruan Combrinck and Julian Redelinghuys; to the latter, credit was due to new Bok coach Allister Coetzee’s timing with the substitutions. Realising his team was in trouble he acted at the right time.

    Yet, almost in disbelief, Herman Mostert noted on Sport24: “Luckily coach Allister Coetzee was bold enough to make the changes […]”

    Now, what happened between Mallett and Willemse may only have lasted for as long as a “mini-rant” normally does, but to some among us it was - similar to the Boks’ great escape - an incident “to remember and inspire”.

    When Willemse, a former SA Rugby Player of the Year, decided he won’t allow Mallett’s misrepresentation of what transpired off-air passes unchallenged, a few things happened:

    1. A sporting hero from a disadvantaged background spoke power to one from a privileged background;

    2. The “generational gap” on the panel of rugby commentators, where the “elders” like Mallet and Botha are generally allowed to speak their minds and the “youngsters” simply let it be, were challenged;

    3. Willemse, intentionally or not, became a champion for transformation, appealing that the “new” Bok team must be supported (beyond the 55th minute of a Test match) and that coach Coetzee is given a fair opportunity to make his mark;

    4. The power dynamics on the panel were shaken/shifted; and

    5. Even if this might appear a bit far-fetched, the spirit of the youth of 1976 and boxing legend Muhammad Ali was kept alive.

    It was, therefore, not merely a “mini-rant” or an “onderonsie”. It heralded the end of the age of innocence on a panel of South African rugby commentators.

    Fast forward to the 20:30 minute mark to view the incident in question

    Heindrich Wyngaard is a broadcast journalist and co-author of the book, Rugby Changed My World: The Ashwin Willemse story.

    Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

    Read News24’s Comments Policy

    Live Video Streaming
    Video Highlights
    Sport Talk
    Breaking News


    Saturday, 29 June 2019
    • Jaguares v Brumbies, Estadio Jose Amalfitani 01:05
    • Crusaders v Hurricanes, Orangetheory Stadium 09:35
    Saturday, 06 July 2019
    • TBC v TBC, TBC 14:00


    22 June 2019
    21 June 2019
    15 June 2019
    14 June 2019
    08 June 2019
    07 June 2019
    01 June 2019
    31 May 2019
    25 May 2019
    24 May 2019
    18 May 2019
    17 May 2019
    12 May 2019
    11 May 2019
    10 May 2019
    04 May 2019
    03 May 2019
    27 April 2019
    26 April 2019
    20 April 2019
    19 April 2019
    13 April 2019
    12 April 2019
    06 April 2019
    05 April 2019
    30 March 2019
    29 March 2019
    24 March 2019
    23 March 2019
    22 March 2019
    16 March 2019
    15 March 2019
    09 March 2019
    08 March 2019
    02 March 2019
    01 March 2019
    23 February 2019
    22 February 2019
    16 February 2019
    15 February 2019


    Rank Team P W Pts
    • Jaguares (Q)
    • Bulls (wc)
    • Sharks (wc)
    • Lions
    • Stormers

    Opinion Poll

    The winners of this weekend's Super Rugby semi-finals will be ...

    Can you name the top Super Rugby tryscorers of all-time?

    There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.