Mallett: Cheetahs deserved a penalty try

    2016-07-11 07:00

    Cape Town - Former Springbok coach Nick Mallett has criticised referee Stuart Berry’s officiating of the scrums during the Sharks v Cheetahs Super Rugby match in Durban at the weekend.

    The men from Bloemfontein had the upper hand in the scrums and in one particular moment in the first half they had the Sharks on the ropes on their own goal-line.

    The Cheetahs were leading 7-3 in the 24th minute when they put severe pressure on the Sharks scrum.

    The Cheetahs looked set to score, but the buckling Sharks scrum kept collapsing. Sharks tighthead prop Coenie Oosthuizen, in particular, had a torrid time of things.

    Despite protests from Cheetahs captain Francois Venter, Berry decided a penalty try was not warranted.

    The Sharks emerged from that particular passage of play unscathed and went on to win 26-10.

    Mallett, though, felt Berry was wrong not to award a penalty try to the Sharks and shared his thoughts in the SuperSport studio:

    “Referee Stuart Berry saw a different picture to me. Coenie Oosthuizen was under tremendous pressure at the scrum, going sideways and backwards. His knees were on the ground, the Cheetahs were going forward and the only reason they didn't score is because the Sharks collapsed the scrum,” said Mallett.

    “There was no reason to go back for another (third) penalty for the Cheetahs, it should have been a penalty try. Berry said there was no possibility of a penalty try because the Cheetahs weren’t going forward, but you cannot go forward if the opposition front row is lying on the ground.”

    According to Mallett, the Sharks’ first try by JP Pietersen was a result of another error from Berry at scrum time, when the official gave a free kick to the Sharks after he deemed the Cheetahs had pushed early.

    "The dominance of the Cheetahs scrum was such that Sharks scrumhalf Michael Claassens took forever to put the ball in and then Berry decided to penalise the Cheetahs for pushing early and from there the Sharks scored. Berry’s handling of the scrums, in my view, was not right. I’m really confused with Oosthuizen at tighthead. He was clearly scrumming inwards in front of the referee and yet the Sharks got away without a penalty being given against them and they got a penalty from which they scored.

    According to Mallett, Oosthuizen should not play at tighthead.

    “Coenie is a very good player with ball in hand, a good tackler and he turns ball over, but he is not a good tighthead prop and we’ve seen that for the last three seasons. I don’t know why the Sharks didn’t start Lourens Adriaanse, they may have a rotation policy. But it’s far better to get a good scrummager for the first half and the next 10 minutes after the break and get Coenie on for the last 30 minutes when everyone is tired.”

    Read News24’s Comments Policy

    Live Video Streaming
    Video Highlights


    Friday, 22 March 2019
    • Blues v Highlanders, Eden Park 08:35
    Saturday, 23 March 2019
    • Hurricanes v Stormers, Westpac Stadium 08:35
    • Waratahs v Crusaders, Sydney Cricket Ground 10:45
    • Sunwolves v Lions, Singapore National Stadium 12:55
    • Bulls v Chiefs, Loftus Versfeld 15:05
    • Sharks v Rebels, Jonsson Kings Park Stadium 17:15
    Sunday, 24 March 2019
    • Reds v Brumbies, Suncorp Stadium 07:05


    Rank Team P W Pts
    • Bulls (Q)
    • Lions (wc)
    • Stormers (wc)
    • Sharks (wc)
    • Jaguares

    Opinion Poll

    Which of the 4 South African team will finish with the fewest Super Rugby SA Conference points?

    Can you name the top Super Rugby tryscorers of all-time?

    There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.