Dick Muir chats to Sport24

2014-07-25 15:14

Cape Town - Former Sharks coach and Springbok centre DICK MUIR talks new ventures, the 2007 Super Rugby final and offers a prediction ahead of the Sharks’ semi-final clash against the Crusaders in Christchurch on Saturday.

Grant Thusi asked: What are your future plans and which team are you planning to coach next?

Dick Muir: Believe it or not, I’m now in the vegetable-processing business. My company has been open and effective for just over a year. My only current involvement with rugby is through my Investec International Rugby Academy. Our aim is to fast-track players and coaches with potential. As far as coaching at the top-level again, I believe I’ve travelled that road and done my bit.

Steven Scott Green asked: Three South African sides finished in the bottom six of Super Rugby this season. What’s your expert opinion from the outside looking in?

Dick Muir: It’s most definitely a concern, and two of those sides – the Cheetahs and Lions – were playing a global brand of rugby rather than a South African style. While both sides really allowed their players to express themselves on attack, at times, they appeared caught between game plans. While playing with freedom is important and something which I advocate, the aforementioned sides were hamstrung by high error-counts.

Katelyn Owen asked: Having previously coached the Sharks, what have you made of the team’s development under Jake White’s tutelage?

Dick Muir: While the Sharks have done exceptionally well this season, it’s all good and well reaching the playoffs, but the reality is that no one ever remembers the team that comes second or third. I don’t necessarily believe that the Sharks’ current style is altogether conducive to winning the competition. The Durban-based side have most definitely failed to maximise their attacking backs’ full potential. White’s philosophy is not to make mistakes in your own half, and although largely successful this season, said approach has certain limitations which the top sides tend to expose.

Wade Pretorius asked: You’re a firm believer in introducing fresh legs in the second half of matches. Have the Sharks and South Africans sides, in general, made the most of impact players this season?

Dick Muir: This topic is such a bone of contention. Rugby is no longer a 15-man game – it’s now a 23-man sport. Therefore, what coaches want to do is make use of their entire squad through a rotation system. Take the analogy of three people teaming up to compete in a marathon rather than a solitary runner completing the entire race on his own. Sharing the workload is crucial in a competition as stifling as Super Rugby.

Tashreeq Vardien asked: In his book, John Smit was quite critical of your substitutions in the 2007 final defeat to the Bulls. What really happened towards the end of that match?

Dick Muir: As far as I’m aware, Smit’s gripe was primarily about Percy Montgomery being substituted. However, the fact of the matter is that I pulled him off as he was carrying an injury. Winning Super Rugby that season was obviously just not meant to be, but maybe from a philosophy perspective I was too hell-bent on not kicking the ball out, which had worked well for us up until that point. Ultimately, I believe it was unfortunate that the wrong team, in my opinion, won on the day.  

Raymond Silinga asked: Pat Lambie has returned to No 10. What dimension will he add, and is Frans Steyn most effective at inside centre?

Dick Muir: In the injury-enforced absence of Lambie, the Sharks’ backline failed to operate as efficiently. Thus, I believe that his return to the starting line-up will make a significant difference. The whole Sharks team has so much confidence in and respect for Lambie. He is a really classy performer and I thoroughly enjoy his game-management ability. As far as Steyn is concerned, he is so talented that I would just want him in my starting side irrespective of the number he wears on his back.

Maano Nekhavhambe asked: Glen Jackson is the man in the middle for the Sharks versus Crusaders clash. Do you believe that more former players should pick up the whistle?

Dick Muir: Absolutely. I feel more ex-players need to be fast-tracked. What I really enjoy about Jackson is his feel for the game and I love his style of officiating. That said, I must admit that I am somewhat surprised that a New Zealand referee was selected for the clash in question. While you always want the best officials refereeing the top games, you will probably find that Jackson will be a little harder on the home side to prove a point that he is no way biased towards his countryman.

Adele Hamilton asked: Super Rugby expands to 18 teams in 2016. Would a team from Japan or Singapore justify a spot?

Dick Muir: To be blunt, I think it’s because of poor administration that the competition has reached the over-grown size that it has. I feel the tournament has become too drawn out and has lost a lot of its appeal. Adding a team from Japan or Singapore would be highly questionable. And in spite of South Africa’s player depth, I don’t believe a sixth South African franchise will prove strong enough.

Earl Haupt asked: Outline what it will take for the Sharks to beat the Crusaders and please give us your prediction.

Dick Muir: I believe it will require a complete performance from the Durban side in order to achieve back-to-back wins over the Crusaders this season. The Sharks are playing against an extremely astute side that has proved successful over a long period of time. Todd Blackadder’s philosophy is all about ball-retention and exploiting attacking opportunities when presented. While they’re an average-to-good defensive side, they are very strong attackers. If the Sharks deny the home team ball possession, they have a good chance of beating them. However, I believe the Sharks will be matched upfront and won’t pose enough threats out-wide. I predict the Crusaders will win by a close margin.


Alan Solomons

Callie Visagie

Raymond Rhule

Frans Ludeke

Demetri Catrakilis

Warren Whiteley

Naka Drotske

Michael Cheika

Francois Hougaard

Andre Watson

Chester Williams

Jono Ross

Johan Ackermann

Japie Mulder

Makhaya Ntini

Andre Joubert

James Dalton

Shaun Pollock

Jonathan Kaplan

James Small

Pat Symcox

Joe van Niekerk

Nick Mallett

Heyneke Meyer

Tiaan Strauss

John Mitchell

David Campese

Dean Furman


  • Piet Swart - 2014-07-25 16:46

    Nou kom ons staan almal saam en ondersteun ons manne: Go Crusaders GO GO GO!!

      Djousif Faksmy - 2014-07-25 22:01

      fAKE GRENSVEGTER ... regte p0ephol-joller ... CRUSADERS BY 35

      Piet Swart - 2014-07-26 00:43

      Rocky, your brainless drivel put me to sleep before I got to the second sentence. I'd rather listen to the sounds of crickets for a week than read the kuk you write.

      Piet Swart - 2014-07-26 01:10


      Piet Swart - 2014-07-26 03:12


      Piet Swart - 2014-07-26 06:02

      Idiotitis is a disease causing the brain to shut down and the mouth to keep talking.

      Piet Swart - 2014-07-26 06:20

      It takes patience to listen.. it takes skill to pretend you’re listening.

  • pages:
  • 1