Cape Town – There were several candidates
for top dog in a rugged, united and passionate Springbok performance where they
admirably skirted the “one foot on the plane” syndrome during the European tour
finisher against France in Paris.
As it happened: France v SABut even if blindside flank destroyer
Willem Alberts won the official player-of-the-match mantle, my own choice –
considering the huge pre-match hype and pressure surrounding his contentious
selection at tighthead prop -- would have been Coenie Oosthuizen.
The Cheetahs man, making a maiden start on
what is still his “wrong” side of the scrum, was a juggernaut under the
circumstances, and not just because of his already known, considerable physical
Oosthuizen easily eclipsed expectations at
scrum-time (even given the grotesque, crumbling playing surface) but the
massive responsibility he carried in that department also did not prevent him
from fulfilling a busy, assertive role in general play.
Here’s how I rated the Boks out of 10:
Willie le Roux 7.5
Revelation on this tour: again here he
combined inventiveness on attack – both with hand and footwork – with defensive
solidity and conviction in receiving high balls. Who said this guy could be a
bit flaky at times?
JP Pietersen 7.5
That old lustre fast returning: magnificent
charge-down swoop for early Bok try, and worked demonically all night as a
Jaque Fourie 7
Best game of the tour yet, even if clean
breaks continued to elude him. Massively alert and involved defensively and
properly ticked the box for stamina in this one.
Jean de Villiers 6.5
Was starting to show signs of inevitable
fatigue as the tour ground its way onward. Errors crept in here, but still some
magic moments – like his set-up of Fourie for a try that probably should have
Bryan Habana 6.5
Some of his in-field kicks were a little
misdirected, which led to surrender of key ground at times. But always a
willing and courageous chaser, and constantly sought half-gaps.
Morne Steyn 6
Place-kicking of loftiest personal
standards, and mostly gutsy on defence. But his tactical kicking came up a
little short for consistency in this fixture. One or two ropey collections and
Ruan Pienaar 5.5
There will be a lobby who consider this
rating a tad generous; he did battle once again to truly impose himself and
some of his clearing was again unacceptably tardy. But some effective tactical
kicks -- and also occasional crucial tackles.
Duane Vermeulen 7.5
Excellent on defence throughout and kept
dangerous French scrumhalf Morgan Parra particularly well policed. Also one of
the most assertive Bok forwards with ball in hand.
Willem Alberts 7.5
Few opportunities to demonstrate his power
as a ball-carrier, but when he tackled unsuspecting French foes, boy, did they
stay tackled! Heyneke Meyer later revealed that Alberts probably shouldn’t have
played ... only underlined his commitment to the cause here.
Francois Louw 6.5
Surrenders a full point on my card for
another unusual lapse of discipline that caused potentially perilous late
sin-binning -- even if his latest “facial contact” incident was really in
response to a team-mate being wronged seconds earlier in that way. Otherwise,
terrific once again in pilfering department.
Flip van der Merwe 7
Stepped up as senior lineout customer after
early loss of his starting partner, but this was also one of his most
industrious Tests generally since his conversion to the No 5 role. Mobility as
well as strength is needed in that role, and he gave it.
Eben Etzebeth 6.5
Was piling into collisions promisingly and
showing usual strong leg drive before his ankle injury in first quarter. Boks
lost their most athletic lineout lock, though his veteran replacement (see
below!) played admirably.
Coenie Oosthuizen 8
The most influential eight-man shoves were
all South African, including one or two bonus heels against the head, and the
first-time starter at No 3 played his part enormously. For his size, he also
charged around determinedly and made a couple of track-back tackles or
ankle-taps on flying Frenchmen.
Bismarck du Plessis 6
Not his best Test, by any means, though his
mere, muscular presence is always worth its weight in gold and he got a couple
of trademark, stand-up turnovers. Gave away a penalty and, like last week as a
sub at Murrayfield, battled too often to find his targets at the lineout.
Tendai Mtawarira 6.5
One of the busiest Bok forwards defensively
as pumped-up France tried to mount a head of steam early on, and suitably
resilient against formidable Nicholas Mas in the scrums.
Bakkies Botha 7
The old warhorse is back: Botha was both
physical and provocative in his extended game-time against some foes he’ll know
well from the French Top 14, and when called upon for clean lineout takes (not
always a collective hallmark) he delivered too.
*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: