I agree with Cullinan on the following points.
Robbie P is not up to International Test playing standard (this is glaringly obvious)
AB should bat 4
Thami is a better batsman than McLaren or Robbie P
But I would still put De Kock ahead as he is much younger and recently has had great INTERNATIONAL batting success with 3 consecutive back to back centuries against India. Not bad for a 20 year old.
Robbie P is not up to International Test playing standard (this is glaringly obvious)
AB should bat 4
Thami is a better batsman than McLaren or Robbie P
But I would still put De Kock ahead as he is much younger and recently has had great INTERNATIONAL batting success with 3 consecutive back to back centuries against India. Not bad for a 20 year old.