Proteas in England

SA shouldn’t shelve spinner

2012-07-18 10:18
Imran Tahir (Gallo)

Cape Town – The strong success at The Oval in recent years of England’s off-spinner Graeme Swann is just one key reason why South Africa would probably be ill-advised to fall into the “all-seam” trap in terms of the composition of their team for the first Test at the venue from Thursday.

Considering the eternally wet English weather this season, it is probably not out of the question that the Proteas will at least contemplate omitting attacking leg-spinner Imran Tahir and even fast-tracking Albie Morkel – the all-rounder who only joined the squad a few days ago after Marchant de Lange’s withdrawal – to a spot in the XI.

Admittedly such a prospect seems a long shot, but if the meteorological outlook remains suitably grim (rain is predicted on all of the first three days at least) South Africa would not be the first team in Test history, nor be the last, to belatedly sacrifice their spinner with a view to shoring up other departments.

The older of the Morkel brothers may have only ever played one prior Test match – the dead-rubber victory by South Africa over Australia at Newlands in March 2009 – but he scored a half-century in the Proteas’ lone, juggernaut innings of 651.

It is the extra security he offers in batting depth, as well as his ability to contribute with the ball as a potential fifth seamer, that may tempt the brains trust to prefer him to Tahir if it looks as though spinners’ roles will be curtailed in this contest.

Under those circumstances, South Africa would still have the reasonably useful fare of middle-order batsman JP Duminy by way of part-time off-spin ... not to mention a healthily shrinking tail with Morkel stationed at No 8, probably immediately beneath the little Cape Cobras left-hander in the order.

Listen to Kallis speak here:

It is the kind of team which, on paper at any rate, would look reasonably well equipped to do a first-Test “holding” kind of job.

There is a case for saying, after all, that the tourists may be most vulnerable to defeat in the first encounter, given their less than prolific lead-up programme, and only get better as the infuriatingly short series progresses – so a stalemate in the first Test might represent a decent enough start in bigger-picture terms.

Fielding a batting-heavy kind of XI like the one suggested would go a fair way, it could be argued, to securing at least a draw at The Oval, while still not being notably short on bowling resources.

There is no guarantee, of course, that the Proteas are even chewing on such a course of action, although it may be significant that the option has not wholly escaped the eyes of the British media.

The Daily Mail’s astute cricket scribe Lawrence Booth, perhaps with an inkling of something, saw fit to write this week: “(The Proteas) must avoid the mistake of replacing Imran Tahir with Albie Morkel at The Oval in the event of more wet weather.”

But he does make a valid point in his suggestion, considering that England’s own spinning specialist, Swann, has enjoyed some near-riotous success at this very venue in recent Test matches and the pitch, no longer as fast as it used to be, has always tended to favour the trade the longer matches grind on.

Swann has bagged no fewer than 24 wickets in his – and England’s – last three Tests at The Oval, including a haul of six for 106 in India’s followed-on second innings in the 2011 match there (nine in the match), when England won to secure a 4-0 series sweep.

The larger-than-life character got seven wickets in the previous game against Pakistan (2010), as well as four scalps in each innings of the Ashes Test at the ground in 2009.

So any thought of leaving out Tahir needs to be thoroughly weighed against that backdrop; the Pakistan-born leggie tends to be especially good at winkling out tail-enders and although England’s lower order is notably strong, his unorthodoxy could come in very handy in dislodging the last few batsmen.

The other point of interest surrounding the Proteas’ strategy will be whether AB de Villiers, now burdened with the cares of wicketkeeping as well, will remain in his favoured No 5 slot in the batting order or be given more of an “Adam Gilchrist” sort of character at No 6 or 7.

There may be a case for at least contemplating splitting up the two middle-order left-handers, Duminy and Jacques Rudolph, by getting De Villiers to bat between them, at six.

But it is also an issue they may simply play by ear, depending on scoreboard circumstance.

The Proteas, if they stick to a likely, sensible Plan A, ought then to enter the first Test with the following XI: Graeme Smith (capt), Alviro Petersen, Hashim Amla, Jacques Kallis, AB de Villiers, Jacques Rudolph, JP Duminy, Dale Steyn, Vernon Philander, Morne Morkel, Imran Tahir.

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter (@RobHouwing) and also his daily takes on the Test matches on

Read more on:    proteas in england  |  imran tahir  |  cricket


Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk
Breaking News

Previous Results

Date Match Result

The Proteas' three-Test tour of Australia is:

Love 2 Meet
English Premiership flutter

Take Sport24's "expert" tips at your peril...


The 2018/19 Absa Premiership season is in full swing. Will Mamelodi Sundowns retain their title? Or can one of Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates, Wits, SuperSport United - or another team perhaps - snatch glory from the Brazilians? Be sure to visit Sport24 for all the latest news!

Latest blogs

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.