Proteas’ spin spot still volatile

2016-12-20 10:46
Keshav Maharaj (Getty Images)

Cape Town – Keshav Maharaj’s maiden home Test match for South Africa against Sri Lanka at St George’s Park from Boxing Day should tell us a lot more about his long-term potential for a regular place in the side.

The willowy left-arm spinner, almost certain to play in the opening contest in Port Elizabeth -- unless there is highly unlikely, justifiable reason for a four-pronged Proteas pace attack – will be in the slightly strange position of being a “recall” despite doing all that could have been asked of him in the first two Tests in Australia recently and then being demoted for the dead-rubber encounter at Adelaide Oval.

Instead the team’s brains trust took the opportunity, in a slightly less pressured situation with the series already in the bag, to blood the less orthodox Tabraiz Shamsi in the surrendered final clash.

But with the left-arm chinaman bowler failing to entirely convince there, he has been ditched altogether for the first two Tests (PE and Cape Town) of the Sri Lankan series, clearing the way for Maharaj to probably play another brace of matches, at least, at this level.

The relative rollercoaster ride experienced over a short period Down Under by both Maharaj and Shamsi, only serves to remind starkly that a permanent solution remains largely elusive to the Proteas’ main spinning berth in five-day combat.

Indeed, if you cast your mind a little further back to the short home series against New Zealand in August, a certain Dane Piedt remained the incumbent at that point, although he did not get to bowl in the weather-ravaged Durban Test and then lost his place due to an erratic personal showing in the Centurion series-clincher.

The little off-spinner has had a seriously forgettable summer subsequently, averaging a bloated 63.18 (11 wickets) from five Sunfoil Series matches for the Cobras, and then being loaned out to the Titans for T20 purposes.

After seven Tests, which had included that heartening debut match haul of 8/152 against Zimbabwe at Harare in mid-2014, it can pretty safely be said that further appearances at the premier level for his country in the immediate future are unlikely at this point.

Focusing on the St George’s Park venue of the looming first Test, it is also educative to note that it is the place where Imran Tahir, so enduringly forceful a factor at limited-overs level, played his last home Test for the Proteas.

The demonstrative leg-spinner picked up 3/108 in the West Indies’ first innings of the significantly rain-affected stalemate in late December 2014, although he travelled at above four runs to the over and it was really the beginning of the end of his role for South Africa in the extended format; he did play later in the ill-fated series in India.

At a ripe old 37 – he clicks over to 38 in March – Tahir is also surplus to Test requirements now after 20 appearances in which he averaged a damaging touch over 40 despite fitful brilliance.

So the focus falls fairly squarely once more on Maharaj, 26, to convince long-suffering spin-watchers in this country that he is the man to grab the Test baton and run purposefully with it.

At least the portents from Australia are healthy: you can hardly judge him on the second Test there, as he got a miserly seven overs in soggy Hobart where seam reigned supreme, but on earlier debut at the WACA he bowled with an agreeable combination of wiles, control and sound temperament.

Maharaj, who had earned a fairly sudden elevation to the Test scene after little hyping of his credentials in the lead-up to the Oz trek, didn’t look nearly as callow as he obviously still is beneath the sparkling Perth sun, showing endurance and tenacity with his economy rate a particularly pleasing feature of each Aussie innings in the 177-run SA triumph.

He did get in the wickets column four times too – three in the first knock, one in the second – although thus far he has only snared one specialist batsman in his infant Test career, the Baggy Greens’ captain Steve Smith for a duck in his first turn at the crease.

So it’s an additional reason for reminding that the jury is still out on his future security in the Proteas side, especially given the extra pressures associated with them so often entering Tests with only four dedicated bowlers.

Being a breezy tail-end batsman with some crisp and audacious strokes in his repertoire is a help to his cause, yet really little more than a bonus: his primary job will be to prove that he warrants a berth based on his core trade and in that respect St George’s Park certainly isn’t the worst place from a conditions point of view for him to kick off his home-based Test career.

That said, his expected direct rival as main spinner there, Sri Lanka’s stocky fellow left-armer Rangana Herath, boasts immeasurably greater experience at this level, with his 75 caps and 351 wickets at 27.97.

Herath also comes off a riotously successful short series in Zimbabwe, where he bagged 19 wickets over the course of the two contests against the minnows.

It was interesting hearing Robin Peterson, the just-retired former Proteas left-arm spinner, say in a television interview this week that Maharaj was a “fighter”, while qualifying his views by saying that the Dolphins player had much yet to learn.

That education will be under harsh scrutiny again in Port Elizabeth from Boxing Day, given the unsettled history of South African Test spinners since the retirement of that metronomic but under-appreciated pressure-builder Paul Harris in 2011 …

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: @RobHouwing

Read more on:    proteas  |  keshav maharaj  |  cricket


Read News24’s Comments Policy

Wednesday, 18 September 2019
India v South Africa, , Mohali, Chandigarh 15:30
Sunday, 22 September 2019
India v South Africa, , Bangalore 15:30
Wednesday, 02 October 2019
India v South Africa, , Visakhapatnam 06:00
Previous Results

Date Match Result

Following Ottis Gibson's firing, who would you like to see handed the new Team Manager role?

Love 2 Meet
Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter


The 2018/19 Absa Premiership season is in full swing. Will Mamelodi Sundowns retain their title? Or can one of Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates, Wits, SuperSport United - or another team perhaps - snatch glory from the Brazilians? Be sure to visit Sport24 for all the latest news!

Latest blogs

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.