NZ 'risk disaster' in SA

2012-12-12 12:05

Cape Town – Well-founded concern about the Black Caps’ ability to be competitive in the Test series against No 1-ranked South Africa shortly only gathers steam in New Zealand.

Columnist Chris Rattue, writing in major national daily The New Zealand Herald on Wednesday, suggests the tourists are risking “one almighty disaster” in the two-Test venture and that “cricket stands on the brink” in that nation.

The writer also rues once more the absence of the Black Caps’ best batsman, Ross Taylor, saying that he is “starting to come across as a prima donna”.

Taylor is in dispute with coach Mike Hesson after being dumped as captain, and declared himself unavailable for the tour.

It is bad news as much for South African Test enthusiasts, who at least want worthy contests in the two-Test series beginning at Newlands on January 2: Taylor is easily New Zealand’s best current batsman statistically with a Test average of 43.57.

Rattue added: “For sure, (Taylor) is a terrific cricketer who has been wronged by Hesson’s methods, but he doesn’t have a right to the national captaincy and there won’t be contract clauses saying he only plays if everything is hunky-dory.

“He’s been let down, but in turn he is letting the game, fans and teammates down – big time.”

The eighth-ranked Black Caps, who have also not selected the domestically in-form but personal problem-plagued Jesse Ryder, look especially vulnerable with the bat for the task of taking on Dale Steyn and company.

They will place heavily reliance on the likes of new captain Brendon McCullum (at least a combative character, but Test average a moderate 35), Martin Guptill (average 32) and 22-year-old Kane Williamson (also average 32) for their runs.

It is a formidable responsibility when you weigh such players up against Proteas crease heavyweights Graeme Smith (average 49.53), Hashim Amla (50.69), Jacques Kallis (56.92) and AB de Villiers (49.11).

On New Zealand’s last Test tour to these shores, in 2007/08, they were clobbered 2-0 with defeats at the Wanderers (by 358 runs) and Centurion (by an innings and 59 runs) despite fielding an altogether more street-wise line-up then.

The Proteas’ attack has probably only got friskier since then, whilst the Black Caps have subsequently shed such experienced names from their midst as Stephen Fleming, Scott Styris, Jacob Oram, Dan Vettori (injured), Shane Bond, Lou Vincent ... and now also Taylor.

Vincent and Styris, in fact, played their last Test matches in the Centurion humiliation.

It is not hard to deduce why the portents look so bleak for them in 2012/13.

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: @RobHouwing


  • unclejb.vansiths - 2012-12-12 12:15

    Its going to be a Massacre!! We can even rest some key players and give some of the youngsters a go.

      squeegee.pilot - 2012-12-12 12:37

      Smacking my lips... cannot wait.

      wesley.rousseau.58 - 2012-12-12 12:43

      You don't rest players!! not in test cricket!! respect test cricket!

      david.s.duncan.1 - 2012-12-12 13:45

      Agree Wesley, except for Kallis, He's the only guy I would rest

      tinotenda.panashe - 2012-12-12 16:56

      Have you heard the word complacency? Proteas should take the out of sorts Black Caps lightly at their own peril. They would get a rude awakening if ever they approach these games as a foregone conclusion. But knowing how professional they are they won't be that stupid and suicidal.

  • francois.dupreez.39 - 2012-12-12 12:35

    Surely they will remember Mr. Kyle Mills's arrogance in the WC...PUNISH them Biff and the boys. Payback time.

      boom.afridi.56 - 2012-12-12 15:57

      LOL don't underestimate the kiwi. although this is a series and you guys should win hands down. if it was a WC that actually mattered then I'd worry, but this.... a walk in the park :P lol

  • wesley.rousseau.58 - 2012-12-12 12:42

    We going to slaughter them

  • - 2012-12-12 12:50

    its always better being the underdog team. hoping we keep our standards at #1

  • Ntutu Dlova - 2012-12-12 13:51

    Remember they knocked us out of the world cup and they have nothing to loose, so lets respect the Kiwis. just to mention: Ross Taylor did not send SMS s to the Proteas

      gary.verster.33 - 2012-12-12 20:39

      U r clueless....

      sivuyile.baleni - 2012-12-13 10:13

      Realy please follow the sport you making comments on, this is not soccer. SA by a huge margin are better than NZ when it comes to test cricket, maybe NZ stand a chance in one dayers

  • sivuyile.baleni - 2012-12-13 10:17

    With the selected squad, they don't stand a chance, Yes I know miracles do happen but realy NZ are more competative against the likes of Bangledash, Windies and Sri Lanka. With Ross Taylor, Daniel Vittori and Jesse Ryder they would have been more competative but they would still remain undergogs

  • dave.rigby.16 - 2012-12-13 11:31

    Never underestimate the Kiwi's - they are tough nuts and have a never say die attitude. Cricket is a funny game - anything could happen.

  • pages:
  • 1