Cricket World Cup 2011

SA: The horror, the horror

2011-03-25 22:21
Graeme Smith (File)

Rob Houwing, Sport24 chief writer

Cape Town – The short - to medium - term future seems so bright for the South African cricket team, whether you are talking the limited-overs formats or Tests.

Video: Smith faces the press

But I imagine a very solid chunk of the Proteas’ support base won’t give the proverbial continental about that right now, either burying their heads in their hands in misery or in more strident cases spewing out a stream of unflattering mantles - yes, some of them will begin with the inevitable “c”, I’m sure - for Graeme Smith and his stunned troops.

As a forlorn outgoing captain Smith himself conceded after the World Cup quarter-final defeat to unfancied New Zealand at Mirpur on Friday, they will simply have to “take it on the chin”. Again.

It will be little consolation, too, that a limited yet gritty, hang-in-there outfit like the Kiwis are increasingly regarded as good “tournament” material, with South Africa somehow more accomplished by a mile as a bilateral “series” team.

Yet this particular Proteas squad had seemed to have just about everything at the ready in the quest to knock that theory for six; seemed to have covered so many crucial bases for the task of excelling at a World Cup on the Subcontinent.

And for a few weeks, just for mundane record purposes now, they pretty much did.

Even as he accepted the player-of-the-match award, veteran Black Caps all-rounder Jacob Oram described the Proteas as “a damn good side”.

Much, much earlier in the trial-by-patience contest at the Shere Bangla National Stadium, Cricinfo’s sharp-minded UK editor Andrew Miller had tweeted: “A bit of mystery in the spin department is what SA have been crying out for since readmission. They look frighteningly complete now.”

Just not quite complete enough, alas, to go all the way to World Cup glory at long last.

Why, even a maiden appearance in the final would have represented progress: instead the abject curse continues - this was its fifth ruinous visit - of the Proteas never having won even a sole fixture at the CWC knockout phase.

“Your guess is as good as mine,” said poor “Biff” as Mark Nicholas, handling the televised post-match presentation ceremony, asked him (not the most opportune moment, though it was always coming, eh?) for possible reasons for this stark failure.

In a valiant attempt to be upbeat, Smith suggested that “in future (the team) might challenge the perception (of frailty) and get over the line”.

Sooner or later, it will ... you would think it has to!

The country has bright prospects in abundance to accompany its established, indisputable pool of world-class players ... Imran Tahir has been such a breath of fresh air, whilst we probably have not yet have seen the very best of Lonwabo Tsotsobe, JP Duminy, Faf du Plessis, Morne

Morkel, Colin Ingram, David Miller and others, generally boasting ample time on their side.

But for the moment the post-mortem period, something Proteas’ CWC critics and observers are so used to grappling with since the bogey first reared its head in 1992, cannot be avoided.

How ironic that this South African team, so much more harmonious, I believe, and so much more dynamic, daring and versatile than the class of 2007, actually tripped up one hurdle earlier than the side who turned out in the Caribbean.

That’s cricket? Phew, she’s a tough old cookie, in that case.

Smith led South Africa well in his ODI captaincy swansong here - sometimes outstandingly, many of sober mind will concur.

The man has a phalanx of detractors (and it was forever thus) yet he won plaudits from all sorts of people, not least several of the star-studded international TV commentary team, for the new spirit in which he, and by extension his men, mostly kept the opposition guessing through flexibility, enterprise and courage of conviction.

I am pleased for him, in many ways, that he is gradually unbundling the cares of leadership, which may mean he can address more studiously the gremlins that wriggle up to an irksome degree in his own game.

For in truth, perhaps in the underperformance at the crease of senior statesman Smith (particularly) and Jacques Kallis lay at least one notable cause - not a whole lot else went wrong, when you think about it - of the Proteas’ exit at the last-eight juncture.

On the pitches of Asia, these were the sort of men, sporting so much street-wisdom between them, who needed to “bat through” as often as possible, just making it that much easier for a team tally of 240 to become a 290, a 285 a 325 ... or even, ahem, a 172 to turn to the altogether more blissful sanctuary of 222.

And yet it never happened, in seven appearances apiece, even if Kallis had a better excuse as he fought cobwebs from a relatively long-term injury preceding the tournament.

Smith struggled palpably for rhythm in his opening slot throughout the tournament, averaging 26 and never exceeding 45 in a single knock.

He may have a fight on to keep his ODI berth as a rank-and-filer.

Kallis averaged 32, but only flickered as the merciless accumulator everyone knows he can be, and his best innings was 69.

Oh yes, and both “got in and got out” on the grim day they ran into New Zealand.

Doubts about the “bottle” of the national team when the chips are really down will be aired anew, like the forest fire that suddenly earns fresh lustre with the changing of a wind.

The sniggerers will stay all a-titter.

Still, I don’t believe this Proteas group, who overwhelmingly gave it their all and then some, deserve a rotten-tomato welcome home.

Let’s be gentlemen, and ladies. Let’s all take it on the conk, just as GC Smith and company are having to.

And move on.

Or at least bloody try to.




Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk
Cricket World Cup 2011

The day Aussies went 'soft'?

2011-04-01 07:37

Newly appointed Michael Clarke seems to represent a seismic change to Australian cricket captaincy characteristics. Read More


Who would you like to see named as the next Proteas' coach?


Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.