Acid test for SA’s batsmen

2014-03-02 22:03

Cape Town - Over to you now to salvage a Test series stalemate, Proteas batsmen!

Barring a near-miracle, Australia’s first-innings ruthlessness -- coupled with the loss of up to 50 overs of play to rain on day two of the final Test at Newlands here on Sunday -- has taken victory out of the equation for the No 1-ranked South Africans.

There seemed little point in Michael Clarke building much (or any?) further on Monday to his team’s brawny total of 494 for seven, despite his own ongoing occupation of the crease for 161 not out, an event signalling a laudable return to personal form and a triumph for gutsy resilience under physical bombardment at times.

So it is really all about whether his attack – a specialist five-man one for the first time in the series given the presence here of Shane Watson – can complete the necessary 20-wickets job on the home side over the remaining three days, expected to be contested in considerably better weather.

South Africa’s first knock will be the really vital one; if they fluff their lines with the pitch still behaving pretty decently (and possibly even fail to fend off the follow-on) they would face a genuine white-knuckle ride to avoid a first series loss since 2008/09 when the very same foes won 2-1 on our soil.

What makes the challenge particularly interesting is that Graeme Smith mentioned at the toss that his team intend putting out a greatly re-jigged batting order, with Dean Elgar – successful as an opener in the Port Elizabeth victory a few days ago – coming in at No 3, established dominator Hashim Amla thus taking the reasonably unfamiliar role for him of four, and Faf du Plessis dropping two slots to six.

The shake-up, if they stick to their stated script, is presumably largely based around the belief that Elgar can do a better job in a more natural upper-order position than somewhere in the middle where he is not the ideal player to “push things on” if a good foundation has already been laid.

A counter argument might be that in accommodating the diminutive Knights left-hander at important No 3, the furniture is being shifted a little more than it needs to be.

Personally, I have felt for a while that Amla, soon to turn 31, eventually dropping one berth isn’t the worst call in the world – possibly for the remainder of his Test career – provided that things can be made to work successfully above him.

Yes, he has been wonderfully productive thus far at No 3, where he averages 56.40, whilst in sporadic appearances at No 4 thus far his figure drops to 23.88.

But his innings at four have largely been due to situations where a night-watchman has preceded him; you have to go as far back as 2006 to find his last predetermined stationing there.

It was for the two-Test series in Sri Lanka, won 2-0 by the host nation, when Ashwell Prince led the side and Smith did not tour through injury: the Proteas went in with a top four comprising, in order, Herschelle Gibbs, Andrew Hall, Jacques Rudolph and then Amla.

For the last several years, taking “The Mighty Hash” out of the No 3 spot would have made no sense.

But as his years advance, maybe it actually does add up for him to emulate Jacques Kallis, who played some six years of Test cricket as No 3 for South Africa before opting to move down one position and be a little less exposed to the new ball.

Remember that No 4 is often considered the glamour berth in many Test teams’ armoury, and if a future Proteas side is able to establish good stability up front, a middle order made up of Amla, AB de Villiers, Faf du Plessis and JP Duminy between slots four to seven has a notably formidable look to it.

Having Amla bat at four more regularly might be particularly advisable on livelier tracks as he gets on a bit and his eyes and reaction times will inevitably start to deteriorate just a little; admittedly he still seems such a sound option at No 3 on more benign, Subcontinent-type tracks.

Why switching Amla to No 4 more permanently is anything but a fait accompli yet – and it will be interesting to learn his own views on the subject – is down to the fact that Alviro Petersen is well less than assured of one of the opening berths, given his ongoing patchy form, and it also remains to be seen whether Elgar can find a solid home for himself at three.

At least as things are planned for the current Test, then, the vastly experienced Smith, 33, is the only truly “embedded” presence among the crucial top three.

And even his future remains shrouded in some doubt after 12 gruelling years in the worldwide trenches at this level.

At his captain’s press conference on Friday ahead of the third Test, several questioners tried to get an idea from him of just how long he plans to keep going; he fielded the inquiries with customary skill while deftly dodging any specifics as to his intentions.

There are members of the media, and I am among them, who suspect his retirement may be considerably closer than some think.

Should he step down sooner rather than later, South Africa will be weighing up their “cream” batting options all over again.

For the time being, the new pecking order in the top six will be interesting enough to assess over the next few days at Newlands: it is under pressure to deliver fairly smartly to help save a series.

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: @RobHouwing


  • Ken Alles - 2014-03-02 22:31

    Acid Test... If we can't knock at least 250 plus tomorrow then i don't know. Can't see Pup batting anymore as they have so to say 500 on the board... Good luck to the batting hope they can proof to us that the pitch is really just flat...

      JohnnyDee68 - 2014-03-03 08:40


      Ken Alles - 2014-03-03 23:36

      point proven...

  • UNITY - 2014-03-02 22:56

    This game is poised for a draw..and good batting averages..forget bout the newlands ghost..its bEen put to bed by clarke.. Now we wait and see how well..our batting line up fairs..on this good batting track...yawn...why this pitch for a last test?

      JohnnyDee68 - 2014-03-03 08:41

      To neutralise Johnson

  • Johnny Axe - 2014-03-03 00:14

    44 years and counting.

  • Zee Komani - 2014-03-03 00:56

    Best comment Stephen. There's someone who understands cricket

  • Wayne Hambides - 2014-03-03 03:19

    And the cry babies will say we lost stern. hoo

      Jon Low - 2014-03-03 04:11

      Steyn lost himself in a huge cloud of ego.

  • Johnny Axe - 2014-03-03 05:25

    I thought Warner's comments would lift the Proteas' motivation by 10%. Wow imagine he hadn't said anything - we would have 540 on the board already.

  • Edward Pretorius - 2014-03-03 06:36

    Graeme should come in at 1st drop.

      Rob Tab - 2014-03-03 11:33

      no I think he should come in at no.14

  • Sean Tearnan - 2014-03-03 07:16

    The amount of Trolls on this site is unreal. People who have a axe to grind over the colour if players, and these Trolls more than likely don't even know what the sport is about have probadly never ever held a bat, ball or played a game of cricket.

  • Geoffrey Walker - 2014-03-03 07:23

    Remember Jaques Rudolph? Played so many tests and failed batting high in the order. Then was all of a sudden accommodated lower down and still failed. So I say what is good for the goose is good for the gander.

  • Frankysmashcake - 2014-03-03 07:34

    12/1 ...(Smith) . . ... . ..18/2 ...(Ek waai nou,sorry I mean Alviro) .......etc etc etc

  • Piet Genade - 2014-03-03 07:38

    We'll still be number 1 no matter what happens here and we will still be that for a rather long time. What the Aussies should remember is that they lost 7 test matches in a row not too long ago and have only recently managed to turn the boat it seems. They will have to be consistent now for a long time like we have been to get close to us. A probable 2 - 1 win for them in the test series is not going to make much of a difference in the rankings but I suppose it will be a pat on their shoulders for beating the number 1 test side. Still have to do it though.

  • Piet Genade - 2014-03-03 07:45

    Seriously, why did they select Alviro again? Could have selected another in form middle order batsman or even an allrounder like Albie/McLaren (we have seen now that 4 seamers may not be enough if one breaks down).

  • Pap Snoek - 2014-03-03 08:16

    Two things in favour of Elgar at 3: Hash has the potential to be a brilliant no 4 with his strokeplay. And our 2 openers are cannon fodder anyway, so Elgar will help blunt their opening attack in a country where it is notoriously difficult to open the batting.

  • Baainaar Hofman - 2014-03-03 10:31

    Whole weekend u whites never mentioned anything about quota morkel that went wicketless now u wana blame the pitch but if Rory played on the same pitch u wouldv blamed him and thats jus another reason y this country is in the safe hands of the anc

      Hansie Crook - 2014-03-03 12:04

      Baainaar there is no need for racist tones.

      Edward Pretorius - 2014-03-03 12:37

      True bru!

      Johan Brand - 2014-03-03 18:28

      Reminder. You are on the topic of cricket. Australia against South Africa. Bad luck for Rory, maybe you are right that he should have played. We'll never know, would we. You should seriously consider to join the clowns (read politicians) that wants our votes. You most probably won't find space on the gravy train though. Now put on your nappy and go to bed.

  • Rob Tab - 2014-03-03 11:32

    no excuses Smith can no longer be accomodated, you have to score runs to keep your place-not one big innings every 6-7 times you go out to bat

      David Anthony Logan - 2014-03-03 11:47

      send him back to domestic cricket for a season and reconsider his place thereafter

      Luvuyo Ntitsolo - 2014-03-03 11:52

      Averaging 47.7 in you last 10 test innings (including the 5 he got today) hardly says the player is only accommodated in a team, especially for a test opener. Yes he could have done more and yes its mostly 3 innings that he got those runs from, but having scored 477 runs in your last 10 competed innings is decent thou. Just lay of him for a while until he scores under 300 runs in his last 10 innings then he should definitely be dropped if there’s someone challenging his spot.

      Luvuyo Ntitsolo - 2014-03-03 12:21

      Sorry about that, Its Monday Morning...... last 10 test innings 462 runs at 51.33 Avarage... he made 27 not out against India in Durban

  • Philip Schalkwyk - 2014-03-03 11:35

    Graham Smith should bat at number 10!!

  • Johan Brand - 2014-03-03 18:19

    Is Vernon injured? His record with the new ball is on record as top class. Graeme is clutching at straws by giving Mornè the new ball. Warner will most probably request his management to buy Mornè a ticket to Australia to help him keep his form. Hope the batsmen is prepared to bat before lunch tomorrow with Mornè going for 6 an over. Captain owes his side and himself some runs. Maybe tomorrow he will start to pay back.

  • pages:
  • 1