The Springboks simply weren’t at the races
against Italy and produced an error-ridden performance.
It was very disappointing that the Bok attack - which is not good enough at present - was unable to prosper against a side I
would be unsurprised to see finish at the foot of the 2015 Six Nations table.
I don’t wish to detract from the Italian
effort in Padova, but the bottom line is that the Springboks’ lack of
penetration on attack was not down to Italy’s defence. The Springboks shot
themselves in the foot by making too many mistakes.
Much like the Test against Ireland, South
Africa battled at the breakdown and struggled to generate quick, front-foot ruck
ball. As such, they weren’t able to evolve their attack as I’d expected – in
spite of the fact that they had retained the 9-10-12-13 axis and the weather
conditions were favourable.
It therefore underlines the notion that if
a side is not effective at the breakdown, it has a knock-on effect in terms of
their attacking game. It’s imperative to dominate the collision, and if that happens
then it becomes that much easier for the players cleaning out.
The ability to get quick, front-foot ball
is part of the secret of both the All Blacks and Wallabies’ attacking success.
Ask any referee and they will attest to the
fact that the tackle contest is one of the most difficult areas of the oval
game to officiate, because the action transpires within a split-second.
As such, I believe World Rugby’s technical
committee – of which Nick Mallett is a member – have to sit around a table and
look at ways in which to simplify the laws pertaining to the breakdown.
Casting an eye to Saturday’s Test, Wales
represent a tough proposition and it must be said that they played
outstandingly against the All Blacks for 69 minutes. Their defence was
brilliant against New Zealand – Shaun Edwards is an excellent defence coach –
and their line speed afforded the All Blacks limited time on the ball and thus
made it was very difficult for them to play.
While Wales are without their England-based
players for the South African Test, the fact that they have their France-based
players to call upon – unlike the Springboks – will offer them a real lift and
advantage. In particular, the triumvirate of Jamie Roberts, Jonathan Davies and
Leigh Halfpenny are huge players for the home side and part and parcel of the
danger Wales pose in the back division.
Warren Gatland has come in for some criticism
in the press of late for his record against the top three southern hemisphere
sides, but I’m of the view that it is unwarranted.
I believe that Gatland has done a great job
as Welsh head coach and boasts an exceptional record in terms of the RBS Six
No matter who has been at the coaching
helm, the Dragons have rarely beaten the top three southern hemisphere sides.
And if you go back in history, the fact of the matter is that Wales had never previously
beaten the Springboks until that one-off Test match in 1999 which they won
While the current Welsh side need to get that monkey off their back, having last beaten the
Boks 15 years ago, they see a real opportunity on Saturday against a starting
XV that shows five changes.
The home side will be fired up and will
come out all guns blazing in what will be something of a cauldron at the
However, having flattered to deceive
against Italy, the visitors will be equally determined to put everything into
their final 80-minute performance of 2014.
Alan Solomons was assistant coach to Nick Mallett when the Springboks
went 17 Tests unbeaten. Having served as Kings’ director of rugby, he is now
head coach of Edinburgh.
Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse
views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their
own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.