English Premiership

Player ratings: City vs United

2014-11-03 11:22
Sergio Aguero (AFP)
Cape Town - Sport24's soccer expert, Wade Pretorius, rates the performances of both sides following the playing of the 168th Manchester Derby.

Manchester United manager Louis van Gaal has said that Chris Smalling's "stupid" dismissal had fatally undermined his side's chances in their 1-0 Premier League defeat at Manchester City on Sunday.

Smalling was sent off in the 38th minute at the Etihad Stadium after receiving quick-fire yellow cards for trying to block a clearance by City goalkeeper Joe Hart and then bringing down James Milner.

The blue half of Manchester eventually prevailed through a 63rd minute Sergio Aguero strike, leaving the champions six points behind leaders Chelsea and seven points above United and Van Gaal said Smalling's red card was the turning point.

Player ratings: Manchester City 

1. Joe Hart - 5

Lucky not to have been dismissed for intimidating the referee. Made some vital saves on the day.

2. Pablo Zabaleta - 6

Did his job well and turned in another decent performance.

3. Gael Clichy - 7.5

Best thing that could've happen to City was Kolarov being injured in the warm up. Clichy is class.

4. Martin Demichelis - 6.5

United were unable to make Demichelis like a 33-year-old defender and credit to the Argentine for that.

5. Vincent Kompany - 7.5

Hardly ever puts a foot wrong. Just another game for Big V!

6. Fernandinho - 7

Flew beneath the radar but Fernandinho can be proud of doing his job well.

7. James Milner - 8

With contract negotiations on-going between Milner and City, the English midfielder now holds the upper hand.

8. Yaya Toure - 8

The Ivorian star is now getting back to his best. It's a joy to watch him in full flight.

9. Stevan Jovetic - 6

Quiet birthday afternoon for Jovetic but at least he could celebrate a win.

10. Sergio Aguero - 9

Aguero was brilliant from start to finish. Scored a goal and should've earned his side two clear penalties.

11. Jesus Navas - 6.5

Unable to make any of his "half-breaks" from Shaw really count. He showed glimpses of brilliance.

12. Samir Nasri - 5

Nothing to write home about the Frenchman's afternoon at the Etihad.

Player ratings: Manchester United

1. David De Gea - 7.5

United's best player on the day and turning into one of the world's very best between the sticks.

2. Antonio Valencia - 4.5

Breaking news: Valencia is not a specialist right back. Would someone please deliver this message to Louis van Gaal.

3. Luke Shaw - 6

Not sure if this lad has a fifth gear? Did his job relatively well especially when you consider he gets little support from Di Maria on defense.

4. Marcos Rojo - 5

Lucky to not have given away a penalty when he lunged at Yaya in the box. Out for a substantial period now with a shoulder injury.

5. Chris Smalling - 1

Stupid! Only player in the league to make James Milner look like Cristiano Ronaldo!

6. Daley Blind - 6

"Dependable" and "reliable" are two words most used to describe the holding midfielder and are perfect adjectives for his performance. 

7. Angel Di Maria - 6

The Argentine was well marked throughout the contest. Good effort saved by Hart in the second half. Di Maria needs to work on his crossing from corners.

8. Marouane Felliani - 6.5

Another good outing from the man with the hair. Missed a golden chance to equalise when he lost his marker but miscued his header.

9. Wayne Rooney - 7

Wayne Rooney is a world-class footballer and he gave his all for his side's cause. Probably should've made more of his weaving run in the second half.

10. Robin Van Persie - 4

A pretty unremarkable performance from Van Persie. His performance is making me believe the other fans calling him out for being too old and too slow for these types of games.

11. Adnan Januzaj - 5

Not quite up to it before being taken off after Smalling's red. Van Gaal has shown faith in the youngster and time is running out to repay his manager.

12. Michael Carrick - 5

Lucky not to have been called on his foul of Aguero, Carrick was another thrust into an unfamiliar playing position. Good effort after being out of the game for so long.

13. Paddy McNair - 6

Definitely one for the future, McNair dealt with the intensity of the derby far better than most of his more illustrous colleagues.

14. James Wilson - 6

Not given enough time too make a difference but probably played better than RVP.


What To Read Next


Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

29 October 2016
Sunderland v Arsenal, Stadium of Light 13:30
Manchester United v Burnley, Old Trafford 16:00
Middlesbrough v Bournemouth, Riverside Stadium 16:00
West Bromwich Albion v Manchester City, The Hawthorns 16:00
Watford v Hull City, Vicarage Road 16:00
Tottenham Hotspur v Leicester City, White Hart Lane 16:00
Crystal Palace v Liverpool, Selhurst Park 18:30
30 October 2016
Everton v West Ham United, Goodison Park 15:30
Southampton v Chelsea, St. Mary's Stadium 18:00
31 October 2016
Stoke City v Swansea City, Britannia Stadium 22:00
Team P W PTS
Previous Results

Date Home Team Result Away Team

Who will claim the Premier League title at the end of the 2016/17 season?

Love 2 Meet
Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter


With the Absa Premiership in full swing, who will be crowned champions when all is said and done? Will Mamelodi Sundowns defend their title? Or can Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates or Bidvest Wits mount a serious challenge? Stay glued to Sport24 to find out!

Latest blogs

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.