Botha: Stormers too ‘charitable’?

2015-11-23 19:25
Ruan Botha (Gallo Images)

Cape Town – By letting Ruan Botha go to the Sharks, the Stormers have dangerously depleted their stocks at No 5 lock ... and simultaneously enhanced the prospect that their coastal arch-rivals assemble a formidable starting second row.

It might be argued that the lanky 23-year-old going the other way in the last few days is simply a “trade” for Springbok Pieter-Steph du Toit – a title-winning colleague of Botha’s at the home-staged 2012 IRB Junior World Championship -- heading back to the Cape after some four years at Kings Park, a switch that has already been known about for some time.

There are often good reasons for sporting transfers that don’t always escape into the public space, so that possibly shouldn’t be discounted in Botha’s instance. It may well have been “mutually beneficial” for Botha to move on from Newlands before reaching his likely maximum potential.

But Stormers enthusiasts would nevertheless be entitled to feel both a semblance of regret and concern that the No 5 specialist has gone to a Sharks franchise desperate to rise anew from their relative doldrums.

Already boasting such second-row characters as the mountainous Giant Mtyanda and similarly robust utility forward Etienne Oosthuizen, Botha deepens their stocks considerably and may well find himself, all going well, invitingly paired in their Super Rugby starting XV with Stephan Lewies once the last-named player has recovered fully from a knee injury – the word from Durban is that he is on track to begin the campaign in late February.

Lewies was just beginning to make a major name for himself before he dislocated a knee cap against the Reds in May last season, including having earned a maiden Bok cap as a substitute against Scotland in a 55-6 victory in Port Elizabeth less than a year earlier.

When the Sharks first tackle the Stormers in 2016 (Newlands, March 12), there could be a serious showcasing of four of the best lock talents in the country assuming that Lewies and Botha get to grips with Du Toit and Eben Etzebeth.

The Pretoria-born Lewies was initially schooled as a “five” lock given his rangy athleticism, but when paired with veteran Marco Wentzel (now released by the Sharks) and asked to do duty at No 4 for part of last season, he showed the necessary grunt – added to his other skills -- to suggest he could blossom in that role going forward.

But the other thing the Botha exit last week did was leave the Stormers arguably with a lopsided look to their lock cupboard – well-stocked at No 4 but more vulnerable at five if new signing Du Toit (already victim of two serious knee injuries, remember) were to suffer further medical mishap.

Botha would have competed spiritedly with Du Toit next season for the No 5 shirt, but right now the Stormers seem better-equipped for any injury-related problems in the traditional No 4 “enforcer” role than for the other locking berth.

Should Bok gem Etzebeth get injured or have the benefit of a rotational break from time to time in a long, remodelled Super Rugby season, sprightly Jean Kleyn, 22, is the perfect fit for his shoes.

As a third option as “front” lock, there are always the claims of versatile hard man Rynhardt Elstadt: not too many years ago the flanker teamed up effectively with Andries Bekker in the Stormers second row.

But it is at five that the franchise could suddenly be sweating a bit if they cannot call on Du Toit for any reason.

Before releasing Botha to the Sharks, the Stormers had also surrendered the services of Manuel Carizza, the 31-year-old Argentinean journeyman who at least offered abundant first-class experience in the jersey, and another useful utility pack member in Michael Rhodes.

Now Saracens-based, Rhodes has previously operated for the Stormers/WP with some aplomb in both second-row positions, apart from his more traditional spot at blindside flank.

There may just be the off-chance, bearing in mind the No 5 limitations if Du Toit were to be absent, that they will have to contemplate switching the magnificent specimen that is Etzebeth – brawny, but also blessed with fine mobility – to that responsibility.

He has worn the five jersey previously at age-group level, and there is widespread acknowledgement that he possesses the attributes to be more versatile; his fierce All Black rival Brodie Retallick is just one No 4 beast able to make the transition pretty seamlessly.

The No 5-wearer is most commonly entrusted with the lineout management, and after five seasons now at first-class level, maybe the time has come anyway to begin empowering Etzebeth with those calls when the need may arise?

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: @RobHouwing

Read more on:    sharks  |  stormers  |  pieter-steph du toit  |  rugby

What To Read Next


Read News24’s Comments Policy

Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

Love 2 Meet
Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter


With the Absa Premiership in full swing, who will be crowned champions when all is said and done? Will Mamelodi Sundowns defend their title? Or can Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates or Bidvest Wits mount a serious challenge? Stay glued to Sport24 to find out!

Latest blogs

Did Stormers and Springboks lock Pieter-Steph du Toit deserve to be named SA Rugby Player of the Year?

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.