MTN8: Pick a winner!

No PSL this weekend, but Kaizer Chiefs and Orlando Pirates will do battle in the MTN8 final. Have your say on our Forum!

LIVE

    Fans vote against S15 change

    2014-05-16 08:44
    Jamie Hosie
    Cape Town - Plans were recently unveiled by SANZAR bosses for an expansion to Super Rugby, from the current 15 team format to a competition comprising 18 teams. The new format is due to come into effect in 2016.

    It is not just the number of teams that is set to change. The conference structure will be completely revamped, with four conferences split into two zones. There will be two five team conferences in the Australasian zone, to include all the Australian and New Zealand franchises, who will play two fewer derby matches against teams from the same nation, but an extra game apiece against their Anzac neighbours.

    In South Africa the changes are even more radical. There will be the introduction of a sixth franchise, the Eastern Province Kings, and the six will be split into two conferences. Each conference will contain another side, one likely from Argentina and one from elsewhere, possibly the Asian market.

    Each African franchise will only play teams from one ANZAC conference, thereby reducing the amount of travel each side has to do.

    With the help of our friends over at SuperBru, we ran a little survey to see what Super Rugby fans thought of the expansion - the results are below.

    Question:

    Which do you prefer, the current 15-team Super Rugby format, or the proposed new 18-team format coming in 2016?

    Possible answers:

    I prefer the current 15-team format
    I prefer the proposed 18-team format

    South Africa  
    Current format - 70.29% 
    Proposed format - 29.71% 

    Australia    
    Current format - 62.56%
    Proposed format - 37.44% 

    New Zealand
    Current format - 73.31%
    Proposed format - 26.69%

    It is immediately obvious that, at the moment, fans are opposed to the change. And while that will likely soften with time, especially as more details emerge, it has to be questioned whether it is worth changing the format in a negative way, according to the fans, for essentially political reasons.

    The addition of another South African franchise has long been a bone of contention in Super Rugby, and the new plans are obviously designed to address that. Right now, though, it has to be asked if South Africa deserve another team in the competition – they currently sit bottom of every attacking stat (points scored, tries scored, games won) despite having played more matches than any other conference. Four of their five teams sit in the bottom half of the table.

    The Australians seem most in favour of the change, although this could be because they are the only nation not to have its own separate domestic competition on the side. Their ‘National Rugby Championship’ will begin next season, however, so it would be interesting to see if that opinion has changed in a couple of years’ time.

    Of course there are plenty of positives about the change, too - the opening of rugby’s borders to include the Argentinians and possibly the Japanese/South Sea Islanders, and the reduction of travel for all sides, to name but a couple.

    Nevertheless, you do get the sense that the competition is being watered down a bit.

    Click HERE to follow Jamie Hosie on Twitter

    Read News24’s Comments Policy

    24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

    Comment on this story
    7 comments
    Add your comment
    Comment 0 characters remaining
    Live Video Streaming
    Video Highlights
    Sport Talk
    Most Read
    Commented

    Fixtures

    13 February 2015
    • Crusaders v Melbourne Rebels, Christchurch 08:35
    • Brumbies v Reds, Canberra 10:40
    • Lions v Hurricanes, Johannesburg 19:10
    14 February 2015
    • Blues v Chiefs, Albany 08:35
    • Sharks v Cheetahs, Durban 17:05
    • Bulls v Stormers, Pretoria 19:10
    15 February 2015
    • Waratahs v Western Force, Sydney 07:05

    Results

    24 April 2015
    02 August 2014
    26 July 2014
    19 July 2014
    12 July 2014
    11 July 2014
    06 July 2014
    05 July 2014
    04 July 2014
    28 June 2014
    27 June 2014
    31 May 2014
    30 May 2014
    24 May 2014
    23 May 2014
    18 May 2014
    17 May 2014
    16 May 2014
    11 May 2014
    10 May 2014
    09 May 2014
    03 May 2014
    02 May 2014
    26 April 2014
    25 April 2014
    19 April 2014
    18 April 2014
    12 April 2014
    11 April 2014
    05 April 2014
    04 April 2014
    29 March 2014
    28 March 2014
    22 March 2014
    21 March 2014
    15 March 2014
    14 March 2014
    08 March 2014
    07 March 2014
    01 March 2014
    28 February 2014
    23 February 2014
    22 February 2014
    21 February 2014
    15 February 2014

    Logs

    Rank Team P W Pts

    Opinion Poll

    Does the Waratahs' Super Rugby victory give the Wallabies an edge heading into the Rugby Championship?

    Monday Quiz Madness!

    TAKE THE QUIZ
    There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.