Kaplan questions yellow cards

2014-11-11 09:31
Jonathan Kaplan (Leon Hugo)
Cape Town - Retired South African referee Jonathan Kaplan has questioned the yellow cards awarded to South Africa's Adriaan Strauss and New Zealand's Dane Coles in international rugby matches at the weekend.

Strauss was sent to the sin-bin by French referee Romain Poite for tackling Ireland fullback Rob Kearney in the air, while Wales' Nigel Owens showed Coles a yellow for lashing out with his foot in his side's clash against England at Twickenham.

Kaplan, commenting via his website, www.ratetheref.co.za, said both yellow cards could have been avoided if the referees had chosen common sense over the letter of the law.

Kaplan wrote: "In the second minute of the Test at Lansdowne Road Rob Kearney clearly took Willie le Roux out and the sanction was upgraded from a free kick to a penalty with the player hardly receiving even a warning.

"Then 60 minutes later Kearney was taken out by Strauss just before he landed in a fairly innocuousway without any malicious intent. It was almost as if Strauss had tried to put him off catching the ball and then touched him. That is literally all it is.

"If you are going on the argument that we need the players to understand what is going to happen to them before they run onto the field then it must be done across the board and there should be a lot more yellow cards than they are giving.

"I am not arguing that it should not have been a penalty, it should have. But certainly if you are refereeing at this level I would expect that there needs to be more common sense in a game that is a contact sport. I think netball has more contact in an aerial sense than what was allowed in that particular case.

"If the referee had used common sense he could have just as easily have managed that situation by saying that although a player was taken out in the air in this particular case it falls at the lower end of the scale and we are going to give a penalty and a caution.

"It would have been in line with what he had done in the second minute of the game and I cannot agree with the decision because it is a contact sport and they are over-sanitising that arena because they happen to be concerned about injuries of players who are exposed in the air, which is a knee-jerk reaction to something that could just as easily be managed with the right amount of law application and common sense."

Commenting on the decision to sin-bin Coles, Kaplan wrote:

"At Twickenham Nigel Owens did not deal with the perpetrator Dylan Hartley who started the whole thing by pulling Coles.

"Coles’ reaction was worse, but for me it could just as easily have been managed. It was not a yellow card offence and the guy who started it should have been included in the discussion.

"My feeling was that a penalty should have gone in favour of England because the reaction of Coles was worse than Hartley’s, he should not have lashed out, but certainly both should have been put on notice.

"Even though the reaction is wrong you cannot ignore the original action, you have got to take both into account.

"In this case it wasn’t that he kicked somebody, he was frustrated so he lashed out with his foot and happened to make contact.

"Whilst you can argue that Owens was not wrong in the strictest sense, there are a whole bunch of better outcomes that could have been obtained through better management of that situation."

French referee Romain Poite sends Adriaan Strauss to the sin-bin... (Getty Images)


What To Read Next


Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

05 November 2016
Barbarians v South Africa, London 17:00
12 November 2016
England v South Africa, Twickenham 16:30
19 November 2016
Italy v South Africa, Stadio Artemio Franchi 16:00
26 November 2016
Wales v South Africa, Principality Stadium 19:30

SA Rugby's coaching indaba is set to take place this week. Do you think the two-day think-tank will make any difference?

Love 2 Meet
Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter


With the Absa Premiership in full swing, who will be crowned champions when all is said and done? Will Mamelodi Sundowns defend their title? Or can Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates or Bidvest Wits mount a serious challenge? Stay glued to Sport24 to find out!

Latest blogs

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.