Kaplan highlights ref errors

2014-11-18 14:15
Jonathan Kaplan (Gallo Images)
Cape Town - Retired South African referee Jonathan Kaplan says there were errors made by the officials during the England v South Africa Test at Twickenham at the weekend that need to be highlighted.

The Boks won the Test 31-28 to record their 11th win in 12 matches over England.

England's only recent 'positive' was a 14-all draw in Port Elizabeth two years ago, while their last win over South Africa came in November 2006.

Kaplan commented on the game via his website, www.ratetheref.co.za.

While Kaplan admitted that referee Steve Walsh was correct in sending Springbok lock Victor Matfield to the sin-bin for pulling an England maul down, he said the referee was inconsistent with the manner in which he officiated the driving mauls.

Kaplan wrote: "He (Walsh) refereed parts of the game really well. He may well be coming to the end of the road, but is still well thought of by the selectors. However some errors need discussion for the purpose of giving the public access to accurate information.

"A warning was issued to both teams late in the first half regarding maul offences after both had committed regular offences. I don’t really know if there is a perfect time to issue this type of warning as it often comes when one team has transgressed.

"Also, one team may have committed more offences than the other. The reality was that Victor Matfield clearly infringed and was given his marching orders. This seemed fair, South Africa were vulnerable all of a sudden and allowed England to squeeze in a couple of tries to draw level.

"Later on Courtney Lawes went right round the side of a dominant Bok maul, and was only penalised. I battled with this decision, as it was a deliberate offence as any of the others, yet it didn’t get the requisite card it deserved after the warning that England also received. This would seem to be inconsistent with the sanction South Africa received.

"Also, the second try that England scored came from a lineout drive by their whole team almost. The problem was that the lineout had not moved and therefore these backline players were not entitled to join.

"They should ideally have been waved back to their positions, and if not complying then penalised. Instead, South Africa conceded another try. The referee was standing at the front of the lineout and hence was in a perfect position to see the events unfolding."

Kaplan also admitted that a blunder was made when England were rewarded a lineout in the second half, which led to their second try. The assistant referee wrongly determined that Springbok wing Bryan Habana had carried the ball into touch, despite replays clearly showing the Bok wing's foot was grounded. What should have been a Springbok lineout up-field, turned into an attacking lineout for the home side within striking range, from which they eventually scored.

"Another hot talking point was the assistant referee who raised his flag when Habana caught the ball, one foot in, one out. This is out on the full. It doesn’t matter whether the ball has crossed the plain of the touch line or not,” Kaplan wrote.

“It was a poor decision by the assistant referee, no excuses. At this level, one can easily see the consequences of this error. Instead of South Africa having an attacking lineout, they were then having to defend one man down and the English marched them over the line for a defining score."

Kaplan though insisted Walsh was right in not going upstairs with the decision.

“Many have asked whether the referee could have referred it - not to my mind. The referral can only happen for foul play or when points are scored. This is correct protocol, as the game would be ruined if everything was referred. It would become stop-start and what we gain in respect of accuracy would be offset with the boredom of waiting," he wrote.

CLICK HERE to read Kaplan's full column

Read more on:    england  |  springboks  |  steve walsh  |  jonathan kaplan  |  rugby

What To Read Next


Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

05 November 2016
Barbarians v South Africa, London 17:00
12 November 2016
England v South Africa, Twickenham 16:30
19 November 2016
Italy v South Africa, Stadio Artemio Franchi 16:00
26 November 2016
Wales v South Africa, Principality Stadium 19:30

How will the Springboks fare in their three end of year tour Tests against England, Italy and Wales?

Love 2 Meet
English Premiership flutter

Take Sport24's "expert" tips at your peril...


With the Absa Premiership in full swing, who will be crowned champions when all is said and done? Will Mamelodi Sundowns defend their title? Or can Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates or Bidvest Wits mount a serious challenge? Stay glued to Sport24 to find out!

Latest blogs

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.