Rugby World Cup 2011

Neutrals call for Smit's head

2011-09-13 22:32
John Smit (File)

John Bishop

Durban - The parrot-cry for Bismarck du Plessis to replace John Smit at hooker in the Springbok World Cup team has become deafening and now even the neutrals are joining in the chorus.

Click to BUY the new Drifta Mobile USB Decoder

Click to BUY the Rugby World Cup 2011 Game for Xbox

The impact which Du Plessis made in the final quarter against Wales, and his powerful influence for the first hour against the All Blacks in the Port Elizabeth Test last month, have underlined his reputation as the most effective hooker in world rugby.

But Bok coach Peter de Villiers has attached that label to Smit and embarrassed his captain by declaring him the “best hooker in the world” at a media briefing last week.

Smit, fitter, lighter, motivated and more physically involved than he has been since 2009, is not playing badly. But the bottom line is simply that a younger, stronger and more dynamic player has more to offer and deserves to start.

Even those watching from a distance are now having their tuppence worth.

Stuart Barnes, the former England flyhalf and respected television commentator, said he was mightily impressed with Du Plessis’ efforts against the All Blacks astonished that Smit was preferred to him against Wales.

And on Tuesday, writing in the London Telegraph, the ex-England lock Paul Ackford clambered aboard the bandwagon.

Ackford described Smit as the rock on which the current Bok team has been built but says that coach Peter de Villiers has to pension him off or pay a heavy price.

“Smit, in his pomp, was a mobile rallying point. His work at the lineout and in the scrummage was first rate. His power on those short charging bursts often attracted two or three defenders. His hands were good, but more than all of this, he was the public face of Springbok rugby as well as the man inside the camp who held it all together.

“And now Smit is finished, even if he appears reluctant to acknowledge the fact himself. The thing with great players is that they never fall off the cliff altogether.”

Ackford writes that Smit, as a once great player, knows the shortcuts and has masked his decline.

“Coaches, either for sentimental reasons or because they cannot identify the moment when a legend finally becomes a liability, instinctively hang on to the guys who have served them so well."

Smit’s place in history is assured after he led the Springboks to victory in the 2007 World Cup and against the 2009 British Lions.

“But history may also record that it was against Wales in South Africa’s opening encounter of the 2011 World Cup that Smit finally lost his grip on Test rugby,” says Ackford.

“De Villiers has to ask himself whether Smit or du Plessis is the best hooker in the party. Not the best leader. Not the most articulate, nor the most trusted, nor the most inspirational. Just the best hooker. My bet is deep down he knows the answer.”

Ackford might well be right but with De Villiers you never quite know and he has now further muddied the waters by telling the media that selection would be on a horses for courses basis and that the three hookers in the squad - Smit, Du Plessis and Chiliboy Ralepelle - all provided something different.

He said the bench “made a hell of a difference” against the Welsh on Sunday.

“I think that is the way to go, to keep something up your sleeve.”

“We look at it holistically and then we make our decisions there, because definitely there are some attributes that Bizzy (Du Plessis) has that John doesn’t have, and there are some that Chilli (Ralepelle) has that the other two don’t have.”

Could De Villiers still seriously be contemplating overlooking Du Plessis again in the interests of keeping something up his sleeve?

Or is he just reluctant to grasp the nettle?


Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
  • Blitz
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @00:00
  • SS1
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @01:00
  • SS2
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @02:00
  • SS3
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @03:00
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

Pool A


Pool B


Pool C


Pool D

Previous Results

Date Home Team Result Away Team
Tank Lanning

Lessons learnt from RWC 2011

2011-10-26 16:45

A few vital life lessons from Tank Lanning's recent trip to New Zealand for the Rugby World Cup quarter and semi-finals. Read More

Rugby World Cup Wallpapers

Download your favourite RWC wallpaper here



Current Conditions

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.