Get the Sport24 daily newsletter delivered to your Inbox!

ABs v Boks: 4 solo scraps

2013-09-13 09:48
Cape Town - Although you might hear the odd protest from north of the equator whenever Lions tours are assembled, “All Blacks v Springboks” is widely regarded as rugby’s ultimate international showdown.

GALLERY: Four key match-ups

As these old foes go into battle at Eden Park on Saturday (09:35 SA time) as unbeaten, almost certainly only contenders for the Castle Rugby Championship title this year, all sorts of spicy individual duels on the night are worthy of scrutiny.

In pinpointing just four, I have gone for some blindingly obvious ones, but also one or two that may seem potentially less decisive, in advance, yet could prove critical if things are desperately tight ...

Julian Savea v Willie le Roux

Is this game between the world’s No 1 and No 2-ranked outfits going to be swung by a lone moment of genius or explosive athletic prowess? If so, then the source could very well be one of these two X-factor characters, invitingly up against each other on the All Black left and Springbok right wing respectively. Powerful, 108kg Savea is the likelier, destructive “bullet” if he suddenly breaks a couple of tackles or is unleashed into space, but the more subtle, silkier Le Roux – renowned for his peripheral vision – is just as capable of turning nothing into ... well, something. The Stellenbosch product’s defence will be put to an acid test if Savea heads toward him at speed, but his own advantage is a stronger ability to put a team-mate in his proximity away with a deft grubber or unorthodox little off-load.

Ma’a Nonu v Jean de Villiers

Yes, just to the inside of each man lurks another pivotal one-on-one as Messrs Carter and Steyn lock horns yet again in flyhalf combat, with the multitude of responsibilities that chore so often entails. But the inside centre channel is a big ‘un, too, and two seasoned No 12s of the Test cauldron eyeball each other. Both are major figures in every respect in their backlines, with 32-year-old, 103kg De Villiers thriving consistently in own-game terms on the responsibilities of captaincy. As for the moving tree trunk who is Nonu, he is a year younger and just a couple of kilograms more muscular, so you could say they more or less neutralise each other – and they must know each others’ strengths and minor vulnerabilities so well through both Test and Super Rugby. Psst, if one of the “twelves” is to poach an alert, vital intercept try, I’m tipping De Villiers by a whisker ...

Kieran Read v Duane Vermeulen

Is this perhaps the premier match-up of the lot? A neutral, Australian rugby writer for a major paper I read in the wake of the Brisbane game last weekend was just one to passionately believe so and I’m tempted to concur. Let’s not kid ourselves as South Africans: Read, the Crusaders icon and acting All Blacks skipper on Saturday, is just about as complete a No 8 as you will see on the international stage. He matches his excellence at all the “basics” in the position with a constant knack of featuring forcefully in ball-in-hand initiatives; he is certainly no personal stranger to the try-line. Meanwhile, though, the uncompromising Vermeulen – by the way, same height (1.93m), same age (27) – offers just a tad more grunt physically and is making serious strides now at this level: he was my own Bok standout against the Wallabies last Saturday. If this game is decided in the trenches and in inches painstakingly ground out, he is not incapable of matching, or even eclipsing, Read for usefulness on the day.

Sam Whitelock v Flip van der Merwe

Still no ideal No 5, where mobility and banker status as a lineout factor tend to be hallowed attributes, Van der Merwe is a strategic pick in the slot at present by Bok coach Heyneke Meyer as part of his plan for his pack to collectively out-muscle their counterparts. But will the behemoth be exposed in the middle of the lineout by known spring-heeled master of that department Whitelock? At least the Boks have Juandre Kruger lurking on the bench, in case things are going notably pear-shaped there. Still, it needs to be remembered that a certain Eben Etzebeth, aided at the back by the likes of Vermeulen, is capable of ensuring at least parity in the skies anyway. There’s another challenge for Van der Merwe though: can he keep his questionable discipline? He has a bit of a reputation for conceding daft penalties so yes, there’s some risk associated with this selection. But it could also pay tidy dividends in bigger-picture terms in the boiler room.

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: @RobHouwing

Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
  • Blitz
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @00:00
  • SS1
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @01:00
  • SS2
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @02:00
  • SS3
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @03:00
Video Highlights
Sport Talk
Most Read


20 August 2016
  • South Africa v Argentina, Nelspruit 17:00
27 August 2016
  • Argentina v South Africa, TBA 00:00
10 September 2016
  • Australia v South Africa, Brisbane 00:00


Rank Team P W Pts


08 August 2015
26 July 2015
25 July 2015
18 July 2015
17 July 2015

Opinion Poll

Which of the four SA franchises in contention for the Super Rugby quarter-finals will miss out?

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.