Lions in SA

Lions' Shaw cited

2009-07-04 21:23
Email | Print
Cited (File)

Johannesburg - Lock Simon Shaw has been cited for dangerous play in the British and Irish Lions' 28-9 victory over South Africa on Saturday after striking Springbok scrumhalf Fourie du Preez with his knee.

Shaw was shown the yellow card and sent to the sinbin by Australian referee Stuart Dickinson in the 37th minute of the game at Coca-Cola Park. He will appear before judicial officer Alan Hudson of Canada at a hearing at the offices of the Golden Lions Rugby Union in Johannesburg on Sunday at 12:00 on Sunday.

The lock challenged Du Preez while chasing a kick ahead and fell on top of the Springbok, who was left dazed and lying on the turf. Du Preez was able to continue, but was later replaced by Ruan Pienaar.

Although the Lions won the game, South Africa won the series 2-1 after victories in Durban and Pretoria.

Shaw's citing comes a week after two South African forwards, Schalk Burger and Bakkies Botha, were cited and later banned for dangerous play.

Burger received an eight-week suspension for making contact with his hands around Luke Fitzgerald's eye, although he was cleared of the more serious charge of eye-gouging.

Botha was banned for two weeks after being found guilty of dangerously charging Lions prop Adam Jones, who left the field at Loftus Versfeld with a dislocated shoulder. The South Africans lost an appeal against the ruling, and protested against the ban by wearing white armbands carrying the word "Justice 4 all" during Saturday's game.

The Englishman was the second Lion to be cited on the 10-match tour after Scot Nathan Hines, who received a one-week ban for a dangerous tackle during the 13-13 draw against the Emerging Springboks.

 

Your Comments

Tim7/6/2009 9:59 AM
Ian I would rather be a Scotsman than a 'rose' (wilting flower)... The reason the english have such a problem with the Scots is because they stood up to them! Just like here in SA, the Zulu's and the Boers klapped the poms, if it wasn't for the scorched earth policy and concentration camps (invented by the english) they would never have gained control of anything. The english have a control problem and if anyone dares challenge their disillusioned belief that they gods gift then they relegated to has beens and what not’s. If you going to support the BIL go to a UK rugby site rather, we really don't need the arrogance here.
Ian7/5/2009 4:04 PM
Mike B the only thing to come out of scotland in the last twenty years was when you changed your anthem to flower of scotland 10 out 10 for that your rugby is improving but beware of italy they are chasing you lot for the wood en spoon
Tom7/5/2009 2:58 PM
Well done Bokke well done ...We wanted a 3 - 0 Series win but have at least run 10 new players 2 lucky tries for the lions and we did not take our chances Roll on the tri nations
Molefe7/5/2009 1:47 PM
For a team who lost the series the Lions supporters really are big mouthed aren't they. Where now the advice about accepting victory graciously? So Poms, keep wondering why you are so universally disliked. Rollie Pollie, Ballet Fan.. I am talking specifically to you!
Michael7/5/2009 1:38 PM
He should get 2 week ban like Bakkies. Same dirty play. Then Lions can wear arm bands next game protesting the ban. Pathetic. Boks were out played and out though by Lins the whole tour. get rid of Smit, Div and Zane.
Bok Supporter7/5/2009 1:27 PM
I'm sorry to have to admit this but the Bok's played like a gang of thugs. I give credit to the Lions for playing good rugby and resisting the urge to retaliate.
Chris Lang7/5/2009 1:14 PM
Dickinson could not be blamed for the Boks defeat yesterday. The Boks were outplayed and outmanoevered. Everyone, it seems, is content to pat ourselves on the backs for 'winning' the series. It was not a very convincing win at that, whilst the Lions victory yesterday was. Bok supporter
Chris Lang7/5/2009 1:09 PM
I am surprised that John Smit is purported to have said that the series win against the Lions feels every bit as good as winning the world cup! The Boks were lucky, at best, to win the series. I believe another five minutes of play in Durban may well have yielded a different result, and the 2nd test was, well, contentious.
Ian7/5/2009 12:57 PM
rugbyfan get a life he did the same as bakkies did if you cant stand heat stay out kitchen your alaways looking for some one to blame when you loose you blame every body but the pope and if you found out he did not pray for you you blame him to you lost accept it
Ian7/5/2009 12:55 PM
rugbyfan get a life he did the same as bakkies did if you cant stand heat stay out kitchen your alaways looking for some one to blame when you loose you blame every body but the pope and if you found out he did not pray for you you blame him to you lost accept it
Dries7/5/2009 12:07 PM
And what about Heaslip that apparantly did the same charge into a ruck than Bakkies? Does anayone have footage of hat? I do not think we will ever get consistency with the current system of citing ... It just seems that our players get the worst decisions most of the time. Maybe the system should change, I am sure a public debate on this can get the message across?
ROLLIE POLLIE7/5/2009 11:55 AM
The Boks played a filthy dirty game.How disgusting.They won the series 2 1 and should have displayed a show game of tactical and clean running rugby as it should be played.We as your Bok supporters,we pay you to play first class RUGBY and not WRESTLING or STREET FIGHTING.
Mr Drew7/5/2009 11:10 AM
Guys, we can't have it both ways by cheering on our enforcer and complaining about our opponents' enforcer playing hard. Are we not being hypocritical?
JohnC7/5/2009 10:54 AM
Jeeze! you lot are a bunch of one eyed bok "supporters". I am a bok supporter too, but don't see things like you do. GET A LIFE
Cambo7/5/2009 10:33 AM
Shaw has "form" in terms of this offence. In 2004, he was sent off in the 11th minute of England's Test against NZ in Auckland for dropping a knee into an All Black forward at a ruck. As he's getting on in years, and may well be considering retirement, I don't think he should be suspended for what he did to Fourie du Preez. Instead he should be fined 10,000 pounds.
Cliff Bradley7/5/2009 10:25 AM
I ( i'm Not A Medical Doctor ) just think that jumping on someones back is mutch worse that the mistake Schaik made
ballet fan7/5/2009 9:12 AM
oh please.. this is not ballet remember... maybe Fourie should go buy a tutu and go do ballet ..!! this is a contact sport so expect a little contact on the ground.. whtas all the fuss about.. mofo's!
Bugger7/5/2009 9:06 AM
If he DOESN'T get at least 4-6 weeks,then the proof is plain for all to see that the citing commissions are AGAINST South African players.Shaw's act was MORE deliberate than anything I have seen for a while.I,for one,am glad these whinging freaking islanders have gone home,from the day they set foot in South Africa,they have moaned and groaned,either about the field,the lines not being white enough,the posts being too thin,whatever they can.Good riddance,glad the tour is over,bring on the proper rugby players from New Zealand and Australia,at least they admit when they are beaten by a better side.
Mike Blair7/5/2009 5:05 AM
(A scot) Boks Rock(ed) Fact is, Lions were very poor. Agression was poor, 1-8 were poor. Shame Murray got knocked out - he actually did manage a good show against Beast in Nov 08. Shame Hines was banned - he is awesome. Shame Evans wasn't running it. Geech is the equivalent of a banker. Decisions based on performance in the good times. No thought for development. The Bakkies Ban? WTF - if not careful, we will turn this game into Pansie Soccer. Sin Bin for spilling tea etc. Screw Lions.....Lets get Scots vs. Boks. Proper match. Girls get left at home. Williams IRB player of the year? Twat. Bakkies better. {Geech should pick Scots Committee}
Adriaan7/5/2009 4:27 AM
Ban him. You banned Bakkies and Schalk. Don`t be unfair in this manner. B&L slowed the game with dirty play.
Adriaan7/5/2009 4:26 AM
Ban him. You banned Bakkies and Schalk. Don`t be unfair in this manner. B&L slowed the game with dirty play.
owen7/5/2009 4:07 AM
All is true and well regarding fairness of punishment, but lets look at a fact of the last two games: disgustingly poor sportsmanship from both teams, why do they not just take up boxing. Rugby is a contact sport and is not for the faint hearted, but when they say we are playing for our country and jersy and pride........? were is the pride in fighting on the field infront of the world to see. That is not pride, thats pathetic. Our kids look up to our supposed springbok heros, guys stop sending the message that it is okay to fight and play the game of rugby the way our forfarthers ment it to be played, clean, hard and fun. I believe Bakkies was punished unfairly, but Skalk and hopefully Shaw deserve the ban.
A Joke7/5/2009 3:51 AM
Let's see what happens to Mr. Shaw. Probably not much. This citing business is a joke and the competence of the citing officials an even bigger joke. THey should have a single citing commission with a representative of each test nation. Somehow the clear vitimization of SA players must be stopped immediately. It is turning into a circus. I would love to see Bakkies Botha taking the IRB or the previous citing officer to court on the grounds of a loss of income. I think players from all over the world should take a firm stance of these jokers spoiling the game. The fact that the Lion's management, Lion's players and players from around the world expressed their "full" support for Bakkies Botha is a clear message that this circus must be stopped immediately.
Roberto7/5/2009 1:25 AM
.....we won the series..and changing ten players...to rest them was a god move..we had already won the series.....remember the british always put a spin on things....the reatlity is they are returning defeated, yes defeated by the Springboks.......
Keith7/5/2009 12:50 AM
Stop whining boys! He deserves what he got- a yellow card and that's all. Although it's a pity if he gets a ban coz there's no games left for the lions team to scribble on so e sticky tape lime a bunch of whiny schoolkids haha!! Cue whiny responses.........
Swart7/4/2009 10:26 PM
I am desperate to find out which 3 tests did the Springboks win with Dickinson as the ref??
Manie7/4/2009 10:14 PM
If the IRB wants to be consistent Shaw should be banned from playing for at least 20 weeks as his tackle was 10 times more dangerous than Bakkies Botha's cleaning the Lions last week.
RugbyFan7/4/2009 9:52 PM
He was out to hurt Fourie. I am sure the tactic was to get Fourie off the field. It was a worse offence than what Schalk did, let's see if the same rules apply to another player. Players that are out to hurt another should be ban from playing ever again. They do not deserve to be called a sportsmen.
tutu finalist7/4/2009 9:48 PM
....and the Boks are the so called bad boys(barring the SB case) go home scum bag and take the ref Dick-in-son with you
Poacher7/4/2009 9:38 PM
He's a ozzie ain't he? No wonder, bunch of offspring of ex-cons!
Your Name
*
Email
*
Comment
*
 
Please enter the text below:

*
 
 

Anton van Zyl's message to WP fans

Tyson hates my guts - Bolt

Victoria Azarenka collapses

 Front Row Grunt - Tank's blog

It's monstrous! It's the Leopards vs Pumas!

Featured Blog

John Mitchell, a world class, former All Black coach, has been released from his contract by the Western Force to coach the Lions. If there's one coach that can restore the Lion's roar it is John Mitchell, so says Lobo...

Latest blogs

Greatest Goal Celebrations... 9/3/2010 12:31:41 PM

1963 Wallabies against South Africa 9/3/2010 12:13:53 PM

MOVING FORWARD - PART 2 9/3/2010 12:02:42 PM

Vote

What will be your lasting memory of the 2009 British and Irish Lions' tour of South Africa?

Who is your Hero?

Nominate your hero and win R10 000!

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Newsletters Sign up for Sport24's Morning Glory newsletter

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

iPhone Latest Sport24 news on your iPhone

Free email Get a free 24.com e-mail account and stay in touch

TV schedule Plan your couch time with our searchable sport TV guide

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.