Lions in SA

Giving the Lions a chance

2009-07-03 14:00
Email | Print
Peter de Villiers (File)

Gavin Rich

Johannesburg - Springbok coach Peter de Villiers explained his selection for Saturday’s third test against the British and Irish Lions by saying that he wanted to give all his players a chance to play against the tourists, but it could turn out that it is the Lions that he is giving a chance.

While the ten changes to the team that beat the Lions 28-25 in Pretoria last Saturday to secure the series have strengthened one notable area in the Bok side, there is another where they look decidedly vulnerable for the Coca-Cola Park battle.

Fourie du Preez, Morne Steyn, Wynand Olivier and Jaque Fourie look a more solid and inform backline combination from scrumhalf to outside centre than the Du Preez, Ruan Pienaar, Jean de Villiers and Adrian Jacobs one that started the previous two Tests. Steyn and Fourie have the advantage of having played an entire Super 14 together, and Olivier played with them.

De Villiers is a great player and there should be no talk of him being thrown away, but he did not play in the closing stages of the Super 14 and he was not quite as sharp and as incisive in either Durban or Pretoria that he was last year. Jacobs is not only out of form, there is also talk that he is carrying a shoulder injury that requires an operation.

Fourie showed last week, when he scored the stupendous try that put the Boks into the lead for the first time, just how forceful he can be as a runner.

Coca-Cola Park has played host to some great games from the World Cup winner this season, and along with Olivier he was the form SA centre in the Super 14.

But these players can only be effective as a unit if they are presented with ball to play with, and that may be where the problem comes in.

The return to the starting unit of Heinrich Brussow should at least ensure that the Boks get it together at the breakdowns this time, and don’t take 60 minutes to get into the game in this important phase like they did last week.

It is the tight five though that could be problematic for the Boks. The suspension of Bakkies Botha has robbed them of their enforcer, the man you could in many ways describe as their tight five talisman.

When John Smit’s suitability for prop was discussed prior to the series, we were told by the management that Botha packing down behind him would ensure that Smit did not go backwards.

Well, Botha was there last week, and the Boks still went backwards for much of the game, with Simon Shaw, Botha’s opposite number, showing up just what a massive mistake Lions coach Ian McGeechan made in selecting his team for the first Test.

With Botha absent, Johann Muller, a man that coach Peter de Villiers showed no interest in last year, comes into the side at lock. Muller is an honest leader of the Sharks, and a player who may be underrated for the work he gets through in the tight-loose, but he is not a Bakkies Botha and is arguably not really in the mould of the man he replaces.

Indeed, you would fancy that had he not been concussed last week, Danie Rossouw would have ben the man slotting into the No 4 lock position for this game.

But the change to the second row is only part of the reason that Bok fans should be concerned that the tight five might be the Achilles heel. For Botha was not the best Bok tight forward last week, and neither was Matfield - Bismarck du Plessis was.

The hooker was initially going to be omitted from the entire squad, but mercifully De Villiers changed his mind about that - he told a press conference on Friday that he changed his mind five times during the week - and Du Plessis is at least on the bench.

Omitting him from the starting team may prove a costly mistake, however, particularly on a day when the forward pack, with Brussow at openside flank, does look more lightweight than in the past.

The Lions are a considerably weakened team from the one that lost the first two Tests, chiefly because of the injuries that have cut through their squad.

Yet while two of those injuries have been to props, the tight five is the one area where they still look formidable, and if you consider Andrew Sheridan played much of the game last week as a replacement and the experienced Phil Vickery was there for the first test, it is one of the areas where they boast continuity.

Should they dominate the Bok unit, flyhalf Stephen Jones would be well advised this time to make greater use of the boot to test wing Jongi Nokwe, who is vulnerable when fielding kicks, and newcomer Zane Kirchner.

The Boks may be playing at Coca-Cola Park, the Lions may be demoralised after their defeat last weeks, but there are ways where it is possible for them to win this game.

Teams Springboks: Zane Kirchner, Odwa Ndungane, Jaques Fourie, Wynand Olivier, Jongi Nokwe, Morne Steyn, Fourie du Preez, Ryan Kankowski, Juan Smith, Heinrich Brussow, Victor Matfield, Johann Muller, John Smit (captain), Chiliboy Ralepelle, Beast Mtwarira.

Replacements: Bismarck du Plessis, Gurthro Steenkamp, Deon Carstens, Steven Sykes, Pierre Spies, Ruan Pienaar, Frans Steyn.

British and Irish Lions: Rob Kearney (Ireland), Ugo Monye (England), Tommy Bowe (Ireland), Riki Flutey (England), Shane Williams (Wales), Stephen Jones (Wales), Mike Phillips (Wales), Jamie Heaslip (Ireland), Martyn Williams (Wales), Joe Worsley (England), Paul O’Connell (Ireland), Simon Shaw (England), Phil Vickery (England), Matthew Rees (Wales), Andrew Sheridan (England).

Reserves: Ross Ford (Scotland), John Hayes (Ireland), Alun-Wyn Jones (Wales), David Wallace (Ireland), Tom Croft (England), Harry Ellis (England), James Hook (Wales).

Referee: Stuart Dickinson (Australia).

Kick-off: 15:00

 

Your Comments

neil7/6/2009 12:37 PM
My point proven. Wynand Olivier does not hack it on international level. He conceded 2 tries and discipline was terrible. Useless. Please send him to where he belongs. The Currie Cup.
PatWar7/4/2009 8:21 AM
I have to agree with PdV, this is a great opportunity to test the young Boks. Glad to see the back line change, hell this is going to be impressive (and I think Boks is going to wipe the floor with BIL - faster and stronger back line with better defense strategies). Although the series is in the bag I am sure Boks want to make this one 3-0. Go Bulls (sorry, go Boks hehehe)
Bou7/3/2009 11:58 PM
Please God give us a real trainer! Eventually he got it right maybe by "n gat gevoel". We cannot go on like this.
Jody 'the toss' Watson7/3/2009 5:48 PM
plaese lurn how to spel properlee jody, befour readin just the titel and comenting in this colim. Div is not the week link, he is the main manne what counts if you ask me. He's won a BIL tour...and he'll win the threee nashins trofee as well.
Alpert7/3/2009 5:33 PM
I dont like PdV but stop the naging. Let him do his job. I also do not agree with his team. Bismarck & Pierre on the bench? PvD said to give some of our other players a chance. Lets give them a chance and see if the depth in our rugby is as good as we think. We have exellent players in SA rugby. I do question some of the refs and linesman. Lets leave the moaning to the Gavin's and the political hooligans. Enjoy the GAME!!!!
Andy P7/3/2009 5:08 PM
Despite your coach,I'm sure the Protea and the Lions will have a great game.
Benny7/3/2009 5:01 PM
Jody - kindly say that again but this time in english please so'd I can understand?
Magnus7/3/2009 4:55 PM
Lekka team...lets run them down BOKKE!
Marius7/3/2009 4:29 PM
Gavin, your comments are now becomming worse than PdV's. Please don't write about the Tri - Nations because you will get it wrong. Give this side a chanche, they deserve one. Go whatch ballet, you seem to know more about that!!!!!!!!!!
Norbert7/3/2009 4:17 PM
LOL! .. I actually am waiting for the Post Match Conference, and I am sure PDV is waiting for that Post Match Conference too. Let it be known to all that when we beat the B&IL on Saturday it will be the first time in the history of the Springboks that we have won a "white-wash" series against them, and then all these Journo's and whingers will hopefully keep their mouths shut. No coach has delivered a B&IL series white wash yet .. PDV for all his faults might actually be the first ... LOL!
Beefcake7/3/2009 4:14 PM
Unfortunately there are no other locks available due to injury and a ban so we are stuck with Muller and Sykes as a replacement. they are cr@p!!!! Akona should have got in before Odwa. Deon Carstens is also a joke. The Bulls combination is going to kick @ss. Anyone who disagrees with the comment about the bulls combination obviously does'nt support a team that has won the super 14 (and yes they won it twice)
Allan7/3/2009 4:10 PM
Gavin Rich is a real pr&%k. He should be redeployed to Die Son. Wonder what he will write next week when we beat the Lions without the senior players. Peter de Villiers you are a genius. Expand the depth - it can only pay off going forward. Good luck. Go Bokke.
Tulani7/3/2009 3:57 PM
Hey Sipho....who is Sipho? You better go and check on your HIV status bru! You might not see the next soccer world cup! Your brain is rotting...Jody did not made any comment to justify your remark! Sorry Jody!
AnotheRicHack7/3/2009 3:51 PM
yawn....spelling mistake: "Danie Rossouw would have ben the man" Nitpicking, no real benefit in it,is there gavin?
@TREVOR JOOSTE7/3/2009 3:25 PM
TREVOR MOET NOU NIE N POEPOL VAN JOUSELF MAAK NIE EN LEES EERS OUBOET OF O JA JY KAN MOS NIE LEES NIE HA HA HA !!!!
Fikile7/3/2009 3:14 PM
Boks win series 3-0. Coach get fired after series for comment I am what i am and a don't give a d&**. and for blaming god for his short comings.
Shakes7/3/2009 3:13 PM
Gavin Rich has no good word for PDV or players of colour. The series is in the bag and this is the only opportunity to give most squad players a chance ahead of the tri-nations. Depth in the squad is essential and unlike Gavin Rich, PDV thinks further than his nose.
Glen7/3/2009 3:12 PM
Reason why I don't follow or support Gavin Rich in any way. You can start by assessing his predictions in super 14 matches to see that he is an overrated Journalist who gets too emotional when writing about people he does not support. If this team beats the B&I Lions on Saturday, then what Gavin? News24 should ban this dude!
TB7/3/2009 3:08 PM
They are going to stuff us up with this team. Pathetic reasoning. The combinations are TOTALLY wrong. Bookies 3 - Public 0.
Dingbat7/3/2009 3:06 PM
This Bok team is good enough to send the BIL on their way. The class and experience on the Bok bench is an excellent backup and should add the final nail in their coffin, given entry to the game at the right stage.
Hooligan7/3/2009 3:01 PM
I cant wait for the day that PvD choke one of the journalist at a media briefing.I wonder what the headline will be......Div,s breathtaking moment????
Riaan7/3/2009 2:56 PM
Why does this not surprise me? Gavin Rich, you useless hack, your true agenda has long been exposed, and that is to attack PdV non-stop and get him fired. I seem to remember that you said in a column on Supersport earlier this year that a win in the Lions series was non-negotiable, and that it was the biggest thing this year. Well, no that PdV has delivered, you neatly shift the goal-posts, huh? Now the Lions are crap and the Trinations is the real test. And so on and so on ad infinitum. I guess if PdV wins the World Cup in 2011, it will be because of Jake's team and the poor opposition, right? Gavin Rich, why don't you find another occupation, because you really have been exposed as a fraud masquerading as a journalist!
Tim7/3/2009 2:55 PM
http://sportblogs.24.com/ViewBlog.aspx?blogid=5c9c7c8d-f6eb-4343-a5c0-b96758f5fa84 Please go and read this Gavin for a true account of the game tomorrow...
@Jody Watson7/3/2009 2:54 PM
PdV did NOT say he is giving the Lions a chance, If you read the article it is actually a play of words by Gavin Rich, the Author, implying that PdV Might give the BIL a chance by giving Nokwe, Chilli, Ndungane and Kanko a chance to play.
Jbone7/3/2009 2:52 PM
Hear Hear Tim, anything that sells! They need to find something else, as far as I'm concerned, as long as we win, I'm happy. Still, I would have picked pretty much the same team, except for the wings and hooker. Habana and Pietersen have been amazing! BOKKE!!!!!!! 3-0
trevor jooste7/3/2009 2:51 PM
This man is an idiot he needs to go what must the players think when he makes such stupid statement he is useless he so lucky he got all that talent around him that makes him look good
@Jody Watson7/3/2009 2:51 PM
PdV did NOT say he is giving the Lions a chance, If you read the article it is actually a play of words by Gavin Rich, the Author, implying that PdV Might give the BIL a chance by giving Nokwe, Chilli, Ndungane and Kanko a chance to play.
Mike7/3/2009 2:47 PM
@Jody. Maybe you should take the time to read the article before opening your mouth?
Sipho7/3/2009 2:46 PM
Jody Watson nobody give a rats ass what you are thinking. Keep your thougts to yourself ,that way the world wont know you such a box(translate to afrikaans)
Bren7/3/2009 2:45 PM
I agree that Jean De Viliers should not be discarded that would be stupidity but he is not on his best form at the moment and he had allot of pressure dealing with a totally out of form injured Jacobs. So to judge him harshly would be wrong. He is still a great player in my books. The scum makes me a little nervous but they are not a bad pack this is a good selection more balanced but we will see tomorrow if there are cracks
Met Uysh!7/3/2009 2:41 PM
Gavin Rich is being harsh on PdV here. Giving the BIL a chance?? Look, we all agree with WO, JF, MS, and ZK replacements. Johan Muller is a forced replacement as is Brussouw. The only unforced changes are Chilli, Nokwe, Ndungane and Kanko. None of them are slouches and save for CHilli, IMO they all deserve a chance. There is ample backup on the bench should some of these guys do not perform, so I don;t believe PdV is giving the Lions a chance here. Nokwe has shown against Aus what he can do and returns to Ellis park where he scored 4 tries or was it 5? And Fourie takes most kicks anyways, last week is proof, JP and Bryan barely had to field any kicks. Maybe Gavin is being way too pesimistic and over critical.
Nuts7/3/2009 2:39 PM
I will always remember Sheridan as the ball grabber...Nutty Professor
Priester7/3/2009 2:37 PM
What an excellent team! Bakkies, we will miss you!! Go Bokke!!
Chris M7/3/2009 2:37 PM
Jeez, but you can complain! It seems the coach is damned if he does and damned if he does not. Everybody on these forums complained about the BIL-journo's wingeing and being negative, but you SA-journalists are even worse. You have decided the coach is an idiot (he made it easy for you in the media) and you will try everything to just keep going at him. If he apologizes for mistakes you do not nobly accept - you attack even further. What was he supposed to do? Pick a concussed Danie Rossouw so you could get at him for that - or should Sykes have moved into the starting line-up? The mostly Sharks tight-five scrummed the Bulls in the S14. The coach even said earlier this year that he felt sorry for guys like Johan Muller that they did not make the team. This is getting way to much for me - and I guess if the Boks win on Saturday it wil be with Jake White's rugby again?
Tim7/3/2009 2:32 PM
OMG what a load of crap. Most of the scrums were uncontested because the BIL props were injured and you say we went backwards most of the time. This is sensationalist journalism and belongs in a tabloid. Its almost as though you questioning Brussouw in the squad. If anything its our back three that is the weak point in the tema because of their lack of experience. Utter rubbish this. Oh you forgot to mention Vickery against Beast...
Phil7/3/2009 2:31 PM
I think, one of the best starting backlines (9 - 14) Div has chosen thus far! Finally Jacques Fourie gets what he deserves and excellent that Jongi, Odwa and Zane are out there for the start of the match!
Danie7/3/2009 2:29 PM
Good team, Just wish they sticked with Habana and Peterson on the wings!!!! We can do it!!!!! Let's get behind our boys and hope they crush those northen hemisphere Balerina's!!!!!!! GO BOKKE!!!!!!!!!!!
Cgris S7/3/2009 2:26 PM
Eisch!! Peter, why don't you learn?. There are highly paid Public Relations officials on the Sprongbok payroll. Let them do the talking!!!
Journo7/3/2009 2:22 PM
This is one pathetic article....Bla Bla Bla ,blaming the coach..I am sure people have had enough hearing about PdV,s incompetence/stupidity..Good. Please write about something else.For heaven sake.SA actually welcomes the selection of this team ,many believe these guys should have been in the first team...
ken7/3/2009 2:21 PM
What is Peter de Villiers making excuses for losing the third test already?
Jody Watson7/3/2009 2:21 PM
I do not think it shoul be any coaches right or duty to say that by choosing a team and he is giving the opponents a chance to win the game. Any team representing a country should be chosen to win a game and any touhhts about loosing should not be mentioned. The Springboks do have one week link and it is their coach Pieter de Villiers
Your Name
*
Email
*
Comment
*
 
Please enter the text below:

*
 
 

The lighter side of Francois Hougaard

Best goal celebration ever?

Best penalty ever?

 Front Row Grunt - Tank's blog

Info on the op Bismarck is recovering from

Featured Blog

Lobo salutes Muttiah Muralidaran's genius. He developed the doosra into an art form and terrorised batsmen with his cunning and his wily ways. Although his career was overshadowed by the "chucking" controversy, no-one will ever beat his mark of 800 Test wickets.

Latest blogs

Overhaul in Formula 1 7/29/2010 3:47:49 PM

Knowledge Musona is SA's Jet Club Rookie of the Year. 7/29/2010 3:44:19 PM

Currie cup predictions 7/29/2010 3:17:15 PM

Vote

What will be your lasting memory of the 2009 British and Irish Lions' tour of South Africa?

Who is your Hero?

Nominate your hero and win R10 000!

RSS Feeds

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

Mobile

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

Free Email

Free Email Get a free 24.com e-mail account and stay in touch

Blogs

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

TV

TV schedule Plan your couch time with our searchable sport TV guide