Court rules on rugby injuries

2012-09-27 14:55
Ryand Hattingh (AP)
Bloemfontein - A flagrant contravention of rugby rules that resulted in a serious injury could attract legal liability, the Supreme Court of Appeal ruled on Thursday.

The SCA dismissed an appeal by Alex Roux against an order of the Western Cape High Court, which declared he was legally liable for the neck injury of an opponent.

Ryand Hattingh’s neck was broken during a rugby match between the first teams of Labori High School and Stellenbosch High School in 2005.

Evidence in court found Hattingh, playing hooker, had complained about Roux’s scrumming manner prior to the conduct that resulted in the injuries.

As the forwards were forming a scrum, Roux had shouted the word "jack-knife" and then blocked the channel into which Hattingh’s head was meant to go.

Because of this, Hattingh’s head was forced downwards and his neck was broken.

The hooker who replaced Hattingh also complained about similar conduct against Roux.

Roux had denied any wrongdoing.

The high court accepted the evidence of Hattingh and rejected that of Roux.

It had found Roux had acted intentionally when he first shouted "jack-knife" before blocking Hattingh’s channel, and his conduct was wrongful.

The high court held Roux’s actions were planned and deliberate, extremely dangerous and in serious violation of the rules of the game.

Roux appealed to the SCA.

The unanimous judgment of five judges' found the high court’s factual findings could not be faulted and the conclusion that Roux had acted deliberately was faultless.

Roux’s conduct was indeed wrongful, and the SCA held it was so.

The judges found the "jack-knife" manoeuvre executed by Roux was in contravention of the rules as well as contrary to the spirit and conventions of the game.

The judges held Roux must have foreseen that the manoeuvre was likely to cause injury to Hattingh but proceeded to execute it nonetheless.

The SCA concluded that all the injuries were caused by Roux and dismissed an expert’s suggestion to the contrary.

The court considered the legal principles which would apply to wrongful claims arising from injuries suffered in a game such as rugby.

The judges found only conduct that constitutes a flagrant contravention of the rules of rugby and which was aimed at causing serious injury, or which was accompanied by a full awareness that serious injury may ensue, would be regarded as wrongful.

It would therefore attract legal liability for the resulting harm, the judgment held.

Read more on:    rugby


Read News24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
Live Video Streaming
  • Blitz
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @00:00
  • SS1
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @01:00
  • SS2
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @02:00
  • SS3
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @03:00
Video Highlights
Sport Talk


Quiz: Test your Rio Olympics memory!

Think you know what went on at the Rio Olympics? Prove it by tackling Sport24's ridiculously impossible yet highly addictive post-Games quiz!


Rio Olympics

GALLERY: SA's Rio Olympic medallists
As it happened: Rio Olympics - Day 17
Selecting 6 numbers turned Britain into Olympic superpower
Caster cranks up the heat in Rio semi
Love 2 Meet
Sport24 on Twitter

Follow Sport24 news on Twitter


Follow all the action from the 2016 Rio Olympics. The highs, the lows, the tears, the smiles as the world's greatest athletes compete for gold, silver and bronze.

Latest blogs

The Kings will play this year's Currie Cup in the "B" First Division. How will this impact their Super Rugby participation next year?

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.