Other Sport

Semenya 'to sue IAAF, ASA'

2009-12-29 09:08
Email | Print
Suing (File)

Durban - South African 800 metre gold medallist Caster Semenya — at the centre of a storm over her sex — is set to sue the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) for R910 million and Athletics SA (ASA) for R136 million, according to unconfirmed reports.

Sports journalist Duncan Mackay, writing on the website insidethegames.biz, reported at the weekend that Semenya has enlisted the services of the firm of lawyers that fought for paralympian Oscar Pistorius to be allowed to compete in the standard Olympics.

The results of gender tests performed on Semenya were due to be announced at the end of November, but the only confirmation surrounding the case was that Semenya would keep the 800m World Championship gold medal and that more tests must be undertaken before any decision will be taken over her future career in athletics.

Gideon Sam, the president of South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (SASCOC), said they left the decisions with the IAAF and the athlete and are expecting a positive outcome.

But now, however, Semenya is suing.

The case against the IAAF relates to the association’s leak that gender tests were being performed and later letting it be known that the tests found she is intersexed.

To date the identity of the source that Australian journalist Mike Hurst used for his story that first broke the issue is not known, but the trail must lead back to the IAAF testing sub-contractors and that potentially makes the IAAF liable.

Neither the IAAF nor ASA has commented on the website report.

In September, on the recommendation of South Africa’s Sports minister, Semenya retained Greg Nott of law firm Dewey & LeBoeuf LLP to advise her on all legal matters relating to her human rights and her rights as an athlete.

However, Nott said on Monday that he did not know where the information had come from.

"We have no comment with regard to this, it is nonsense," he said.

The case against ASA will raise a number of interesting questions, not only because it is said that the federation is listed as a section 21 company, but also how this will impact on the newly appointed board members — especially with rumours that ASA debts already exceed R14 million.

 

Your Comments

MARY1/13/2010 11:11 AM
The ignorance and the arrogance of these southafricans political about the regulation in the IAAF is unbelievable, They think that the people outside this country lives with the ring hang at the nose, they are presumptuous but without the knowlegde will be no future for country sport. I'm sorry but I like South Africa and I don't want that the people outside think that all the South African are the same.
zwischengeschlecht.org12/29/2009 5:10 PM
funny, how almost no press agency realised that this "news" was originally posted in swedish media expressen.se more than a week ago. still hope the IAAF will be made to pay, and dearly -- else they'll obviously never learn, same as the IOC justice for caster semenya -- and for santhi soundarajan, too!
peter12/29/2009 3:00 PM
It's all smoke & mirrors. She has not got the b**** to go to litigation.
Mdu12/29/2009 2:51 PM
I am surpriced and deeply suddened at the ignorance and a display of indisginous by some who believe they are the descendents of the "pure race". Its scary that after all the previledges they have enjoyed over the decades, at the expense of the others. They have failed to acquire a simple skill of logic thinking, free of prejudice and superioty complex. Go Caster
@ Houston12/29/2009 2:17 PM
That's also just hearsay. Neither she nor her family ever said a word about her having or not having periods.. Also, are you aware that strenuous training and low body weight can influence a woman's cycle? Quite a number of professional female athletes have extremely irregular cycles.
Len van Heerden12/29/2009 2:11 PM
@Alan Ingram SA If Caster knew her sexual status (pray tell how someone growing up with a vagina in rural Limpopo would have the capacity to know what took so many experts to debate and still not come to a conclusion) why did the IAAF allow her to keep the golf medal? Surely, any proof that she knew would have resulted in her being stripped of the medal. It would be nice if people comment on what they know, and leave the rest to the experts, lest they confirm their idiocy to all and sundry
Themba12/29/2009 2:04 PM
@Alan Ingram SA And you know this for a fact, or you are letting your hatred and ignorance take charge?
Nick12/29/2009 1:54 PM
@CTheB, Sorry i meant Hermaphradite. Just one question to Caster, Did she/he ever notice the stuble, muscules etc,etc,etc and when was he/she going to ask questions?????
Alan Ingram SA12/29/2009 1:04 PM
She knew she was not a 'real woman' when she entered the athletes competition last year, as so did the ex ASA bosses and the ANC ! I hope she losses the case and does not get cent !!!! And is banned from International Athletes for ever !
CTheB12/29/2009 1:01 PM
@bekkie - there's nothing new about intersex people and Semenya, assuming the report is true (which is, as yet, unknown), is not unique. This is hardly the first time an athlete has undergone gender testing. And a transexual is a completely different thing.
Tony12/29/2009 12:52 PM
Caster must have spend a couple of hours with a low live lawyer at a braai who asked her where she is at with her career and why she is not sueing their arse of. For a 40 % cut a pro bono case against the iaaf is a no brainer. CAster is being used and abused again. This time by some bottom feeding lawyer.
chr12/29/2009 12:41 PM
Why should we support her. We were unjustly blamed by juliass and co of involvement into this circus. It transpired that it was not the fault of any white citizen so an appology for that would be in order don'y you think
Jordan12/29/2009 12:30 PM
I think this is really funny. (Pinky at the corner of her mouth, glaring at an unseen foe, "I want ONE BILLION RAND! HAHAHAHAHAHA") Disgusting!
peter12/29/2009 12:28 PM
A billion Rand ? No problem, Tiger will fund Caster after her one night stand with him. If she is a dinkum woman then I'm also playing off the ladies tees tomorrow ...
Mark12/29/2009 12:26 PM
Sue their pants off! Leaks on such a sensitive issue: UNACCEPTABLE! And if its the only way we can get competent administrators is SA ... BONUS!!!
Shame12/29/2009 12:14 PM
@Mogau Mabapa and the rest with similiar comments. Oh boy here we go again, somehow the whites are to be blamed again! Your statement, “A young girl was humiliated by the entire fiasco. While I expected that the entire country will come together and support this girl, I am still shocked that most whites SA are still negative against this girl. Where is patriotism to our whites citizens?” What a load of bullsh@t trying to pin this one on the white community, Innocent young girl, Poor girl,,where? Give me a break! Sorry Caster I cannot believe you and your family weren't aware of your condition. You took a chance and you got caught, accept it and move on.
H12/29/2009 11:39 AM
I saw this coming long time ago. Just shows how things work. Caster, You are wrong, and you know you are wrong. But want to be compensated because someone has shown you that you are wrong. I have absolutely no sympathy for Caster. You are a man!!!!!
Mike12/29/2009 11:23 AM
Ho hum................
MavericKs12/29/2009 11:11 AM
You Go Caster. I hope you milk them for even more
Uncle Pete12/29/2009 11:09 AM
See what accomodation caused. Semenya, Pistorius and ASA sagas now the exellent opportunity and good grounds to scrap separate gender or disability based competitions and sponsorships, in totality, forever!
Muis12/29/2009 11:04 AM
Just wondering: Caster should have picked up that not getting a period and breasts not growing that something is amiss... In my opinion Caster is as guilty as ASA & co.
Houston12/29/2009 10:52 AM
@Sasha, if you are a woman and have not had a period by the time you are 18 then you know something is wrong, and your family should know - to say you are not aware that you are "intersexed" is not true - you may not know the name for it, but you know something is wrong. Look at julius, we do not know what the name for the disease is that he has, but we know something is wrong with him ;-)
BearGrills12/29/2009 10:38 AM
Can we please leave this poor little boy alone.
Rob12/29/2009 10:35 AM
I need to start running again!
Peter G12/29/2009 10:34 AM
Following facts have been ignored by most media. Semenya improved her time by over 16.5 seconds in a year. How? No out of season testing of any sorts has been done on any athlete in Africa including SA prior to the World Champs in Berlin in 2009. Rumours of Dr. Freitag former DDR doping specialist doing work with ASA's athletes have been doing the rounds, although always denied. (Remember Rule 1 of effective journalism: The louder the denials, you are closer to the truth) Can some journalist who is prepared to do some work go and expose this whole can of worms without the country crying racism, sexism etc. and put an end to all this speculation.
robyn12/29/2009 10:34 AM
You go girl! Nail their ass*s to the wall. You deserve every cent.
Reason12/29/2009 10:32 AM
Come on people... this is not about an intrusion into somebody's rights, it's only about GREED OF MONEY!!!. Semenya and her (his) team knew full well that everything was not quite kosher "down south" and sooner or later the truth will come out. Now that the inevitable has happened, she and her greedy lawyers wants to sue everybody involved. I hope she (he) fail miserably in this legal venture. Typical African, always blame somebody else. Eish!
shawn12/29/2009 10:27 AM
Ok, so he lies about being a man/woman in the first place, then he freaks out when the world caught him out, blady cheat, he should be shot!
Batho pele12/29/2009 10:26 AM
Sisi, thank God u got to keep the medal and the price, wish u all de best, we behind you all de way, ....peace..luv u
Mogau Mabapa12/29/2009 10:24 AM
A young girl was humiliated by the entire fiasco. IAAF and ASA failed to protect her dignity. For IAAF to allow the media leak to australian puppets it leaves much to be desired. Money will not redeem Semenya's dignity but it will teach both organisation a lesson to that respecting human rights of a person. While I expected that the entire country will come together and support this girl, I am still shocked that most whites SA are still negative against this girl. Where is patriotism to our whites citizens? Is this rainbow nation Mandela preached? Or they demonstrate what former President Thabo Mbeki said about a divided nation? What is it exactly?
sipho12/29/2009 10:23 AM
Wait a minute. What about the women athletes who lost against Semenya beacuse she has more balls (inside or outside), more testosterone or whatever else. Maybe the losers should also sue Semenya, Chinene and the whole bunch of liers. This will be an allmighty court case, the lawyers will cash in, the gutter press wil have a ball and after that Semenya will not be able to find a hole far enough to hide away. All this in the protection of HUMAN RIGHTS??
Mogau Mabapa12/29/2009 10:23 AM
A young girl was humiliated by the entire fiasco. IAAF and ASA failed to protect her dignity. For IAAF to allow the media leak to australian puppets it leaves much to be desired. Money will not redeem Semenya's dignity but it will teach both organisation a lesson to that respecting human rights of a person. While I expected that the entire country will come together and support this girl, I am still shocked that most whites SA are still negative against this girl. Where is patriotism to our whites citizens? Is this rainbow nation Mandela preached? Or they demonstrate what former President Thabo Mbeki said about a divided nation? What is it exactly?
bekkie12/29/2009 10:21 AM
Is Semenya a guy or a girl. I am led to believe that Semenya is both, that means Semenya is a new sub species of the human race called a trans sexual. That means Semenya can compete against women or men in compettions. When Semenya feels like winning Semenya can run against the girls and win. When Semenya feels like loosing Semenya can run against the men. I think to sue is wrong because here is a different being, that confused the federations and they did not know how to respond to the unique situation. Why does Semenya not ask the IAAF to create a new heat for this new breed of humans. This is evolution after all!!!
Alpha Mike Foxtrot12/29/2009 10:20 AM
So who will be counter-sueing Semenya for being a lie and a cheat?
Allan12/29/2009 10:18 AM
In it for the money. What will the legal team get financially out of the deal should they win their case? Surely the IAAF and ASA should sue her for non disclosure of the truth when she ran in Berlin. Especially after she had just had tests carried out in SA prior to the event. One must remember when one points a figure at someone that there are always 3 pointing back at you. Even a political figure head was heard to state "..he is a woman.." on national TV.
Melaine12/29/2009 10:18 AM
Oh please! She is an It. Not woman and not man. In fact it is more a man than it is a woman. What does she have to sue about? She should have known that she will be tested. Or did this sudden decision to sue come from an outside source that said: "Hi you we ca make a few quick bucks!!"
Makodumetja12/29/2009 10:17 AM
everything has time this is your time let them pay for thier conduct IAAF and ASA both are as quilty as charged.
CTheB12/29/2009 10:16 AM
@Nick - transvestite and intersexed are totally different things. If Semenya is intersexed it's not possible to be a transvestite as well.
Richard12/29/2009 10:12 AM
This is the country's money. I agree she deserves a payout of some kind because of their behaviour, but 1bn? That's money that could be put to much better use helping other athletes in the country.
Mandla`12/29/2009 10:11 AM
I think Semenya is on a right track. If she win all the claim that will settle all the dust and clear her future in her sport.
Get real12/29/2009 10:08 AM
I wonder who is behind all this, A biilion ,ASA must pay it all .
Tim12/29/2009 10:06 AM
So... can Chuene finally be fired??? Why is he still suspended with pay?
Sasha12/29/2009 10:03 AM
To all the crazies saying "she's just as liable for participating in the deception" - where on earth do you get the idea that she was part of anything? Being intersex is not exactly something you discover in the bath. She didn't do anything wrong - it's been stated over and over again that she was not informed of any of the issues, and she was deceived about the nature of the tests performed on her before Berlin. She deserves compensation, and she definitely deserves to be treated with more respect than has been shown by some bigoted idiots here.
tom12/29/2009 10:03 AM
It is a disgrace that she was put into this situation in the first place. Any normal person can see she is not a woman, or a man either. The idiots that were in charge of ASA should pay her for her humiliation, it reeks of an 18th century circus act. The same condemnation that gets meted out to Saartlie Baartmans handlers should be bestowed upon the ASA officials. It was a chance they took that backfired and the only one that was damaged was Caster.
JUST A THOUGHT12/29/2009 10:01 AM
I do think she is owed an apology and compensation, whether more than $2mill is what its worth, I don't think so? I think if I were to sue, it would be more to have rules and standards changed in the sport. A court case will only harm the weak sport of Athletics in South Africa and end any hope of future stars. Caster will do her self proud if She stood taller than the issue and gave back to the sport and showed all she wants is to run. Now the money issue is just greed! Lets try move on with a new board and more inclusion of runners on the board so the sport goes the right way!
Ebbe12/29/2009 10:00 AM
What a boytjie. I like your style and your determination. Make sure you get the best deal as the rest don't really care about you they only see the $$. All SA will back you.
lanito12/29/2009 9:59 AM
all of you guys are idiots, this report is unconfirmed, so lets rather wait for confirm report before you can share you idiotic opinion
JUST A THOUGHT12/29/2009 9:57 AM
I do think she is owed an apology and compensation, whether more than $2mill is what its worth, I don't think so? I think if I were to sue, it would be more to have rules and standards changed in the sport. A court case will only harm the weak sport of Athletics in South Africa and end any hope of future stars. Caster will do her self proud if She stood taller than the issue and gave back to the sport and showed all she wants is to run. Now the money issue is just greed! Lets try move on with a new board and more inclusion of runners on the board so the sport goes the right way!
JOHANN12/29/2009 9:56 AM
YOU ARE ALL IDIOTS.DID SHE PROVE SHE IS A FEMALE?
To the point12/29/2009 9:55 AM
Are we insane to think that she deserves a Billion for what she went through? In spite of all the blunders Caster has been very aware of many facts in the process. She is not without fault in the whole process. I agree with those who see the lawyers here trying to make a buck on the back of the situation. I would like to know what she is sueing for (emotional damage worth R 1 Billion, come on)? To say she deserves every sent is rubbish. There are people in this country going through psycological trauma, defermation of character and the like who have received nothing in the process, not a house or a gold medal and rememeber that Caster has received more positive support from most than negative. If she goes ahead with this, I will be greatly disappointed in her.
Houston12/29/2009 9:51 AM
well they all deserve each other, and semenya is as liable as the rest - what does (s)he think, everything is ok in a professional sport if I am not even sure what sex I am - really, grow up the whole lot of them, including semenyas family
Kevin Williams12/29/2009 9:51 AM
This woman has been so humiliated..I hope she get's what she's suiing for and more...Good luck Senenya.
CTheB12/29/2009 9:48 AM
While I think she's entitled to some sort of compensation (though only from the IAAF if it can be proved that the leak did come from within the IAAF and that they're liable. ASA, well, there seems to be no question of their guilt...). However, to be suing for close to R1b makes no sense. I'd love to know how the lawyers are justifying that one.
Philip Theron12/29/2009 9:44 AM
It was only a matter of time for this to happen. Semenya is well within her rights to sue for all the trauma that she was put through. Lies and deception especially on the part of the ASA has finally caught up with them. It will be interesting to read how this whole debacle will shake out in the end. Go for it Caster.
PRO-CASTER SEMENYA12/29/2009 9:42 AM
It is high time this took place. She has been humiliated and her dignity tarnished. It is most desrving of IAAF to be sued. This will curb the unfair treatment that other athletes have suffered in the hands of international bodies such as IAAF. Take them to the cleaners Caster. We are behind you all the way. You are Human after All. It was inhmuane the way your case was handled. IAAF desrves the wrath that is to follow. South Africans will follow this case with great interest. Even they choose to settle out of court then it still fine. They will pay that is the inevitable. Continue with sports and athletic, you will inspire more young children to be brave in their participation in sports. God has Blessed You with a talent which nobody can take away from you. Keep Hope Alive!!!!
TC12/29/2009 9:40 AM
Caster, go for it. What they did to you and to SA is unforgivable and a disgrace. We must stop accepting the cr@p that these people do to us and to this coutry.
Leey12/29/2009 9:38 AM
Way to go Caster. The poor girl has been humiliated for way too long.
Vince12/29/2009 9:38 AM
Wow! This chick's got balls!
Jack Daniels12/29/2009 9:36 AM
That's the stuff go after them especially ASA they are ultimately responcible for this whole mess.
Maverick12/29/2009 9:34 AM
She is conveniently hiding behind a smokescreen of controversy. She should have known that some or other time the truth is going to surface and she should have expected this to happen. The people who encouraged her to continue with this lie are also accountable. The IAAF are the true victims of this deception.
Go for it!12/29/2009 9:34 AM
You go for it Caster! From the start, they way they treated you made us nauseous. I am so proud of you for taking this step. No person has to endure what you have endured so far. I have the utmost respect for you, that you are able to continue with your life and career the way you have, despite ASA. All the best. Our hearts and thoughts are behind you.
Phil12/29/2009 9:33 AM
Honestly who cares!!!
eugene12/29/2009 9:31 AM
That has got to be the best news out of this whole saga. I hope she gets every penny out of these buggers. Specially ASA for their poor handling of this issue.
Nick12/29/2009 9:31 AM
This is typical of lawyers, trying to make a quick buck, of something that is TRUE. Caster is a Transvestite/Inersexed, she should have never taken part in the Womens event, even HE know that. Human Rights - is it your RIGHT to CHEAT against Women, surely the women who ran against Caster have a better claim here. They might never ever recover from the whipping they got from Caster. I hope this never gets to trail, and GREG NOTT sees his arse, along with Dewey & LeBoeuf LLP.
jacques12/29/2009 9:31 AM
Jou eie honde byt die seerste!
Donovan12/29/2009 9:30 AM
I would really like someone to explain this to me, let’s ignore the fact that cheating took place. It seems the whole matter is about the violation of human rights, so then when athletes are randomly tested for performance enhancing drugs, this is also a violation of there rights. I am curious to find out just how the amount of R1 Billion was arrived, I say the international athletics should fight this legal battle to the very end.
Gboy12/29/2009 9:28 AM
Yes, to fund Malema in over throwing the world
OomDok12/29/2009 9:27 AM
1.46 billion smackers; this is better than being Tiger Woods! Wonder how much the lawyers cut is. This is ridiculous.
Kingsley12/29/2009 9:23 AM
its about time someone paid for this.... go gal.
Tatolo12/29/2009 9:22 AM
You go gal....Show them
Larry12/29/2009 9:19 AM
I can see a case against ASA, but can not see any case, or chance of winning against the IAAF. But as in everything, its the money that dictates. After this case, I can see Semenya sueing the Lawyers for the further humiliation that they will most definitely have talked Semenya into.
THE MAN12/29/2009 9:17 AM
thats it my girl go an sue the iaaf for almost 1 billion rand you derserve every penny, but relax a little on ASA they were trying to protect you and had your best interest at heart so maybe only sue them for 1 million. Never the less you are our gold medal star of the decade our woman of the decade you will always be south africas golden girl and i know each and every south african loves you and will be behind you.Tshepo with an O
Your Name
*
Email
*
Comment
*
 
Please enter the text below:

*
 
 

Tyson hates my guts - Bolt

Victoria Azarenka collapses

Roger Federer chocolate ad

 Front Row Grunt - Tank's blog

It's monstrous! It's the Leopards vs Pumas!

Featured Blog

John Mitchell, a world class, former All Black coach, has been released from his contract by the Western Force to coach the Lions. If there's one coach that can restore the Lion's roar it is John Mitchell, so says Lobo...

Latest blogs

Sharks to show their true colors 9/3/2010 9:23:45 AM

Playing the game for a good cause 9/3/2010 9:10:49 AM

Amazed Angry Gutted 9/3/2010 8:06:50 AM

Vote

Do SA Paralympian stars Oscar Pistorius and Natalie du Toit get sufficient recognition?

Who is your Hero?

Nominate your hero and win R10 000!

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Newsletters Sign up for Sport24's Morning Glory newsletter

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

iPhone Latest Sport24 news on your iPhone

Free email Get a free 24.com e-mail account and stay in touch

TV schedule Plan your couch time with our searchable sport TV guide

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.