Paralympics 2012

Oscar complaint weak - prof

2012-09-03 22:36
Oscar Pistorius (File)

London - Oscar Pistorius was not beaten because his opponent's blades were longer, a professor of sports engineering told Reuters on Monday.

The South African, dubbed the "Blade Runner", was upset by Brazil's Alan Oliveira in the final of the Paralympic men's 200m and prompted controversy when he used a post-race interview to question the legitimacy of his defeat. 

Pistorius suggested that his opponent's prosthetics had artificially lengthened his stride, giving him an unfair advantage.

According to Professor Steve Haake of Sheffield Hallam University, however, stride length and the size of his prosthetics were not the deciding factors in the result.

"The practical outcome of larger blades is a greater stride length, assuming you turn over your legs at the same rate," Haake told Reuters in a telephone interview. "But to do that, the mass of the legs needs to be smaller. It is called the conservation of angular momentum.

"Imagine the experiment when you spin someone round on an office chair with their arms outstretched. If they bring their arms in, they speed up. It is the same effect with athletes' prosthetics. When the mass is closer to the centre they are easier to spin.

"Just making the legs longer, therefore, doesn't necessarily make Oliveira quicker... In any case, if you look at Oliveira, he actually took more strides, which means a shorter stride length. It was that that won him the race."

Haake also questioned whether Pistorius, who runs against able-bodied athletes and competed in last month's Olympics, had damaged his argument that his prosthetics do not give him an advantage.

"I think he was saying the rules are wrong, that having the scope to lengthen the legs is not fair," Haake said.

"In doing this he has opened a can of worms. If he is saying, 'If you lengthen your legs you are at an advantage', then he blows his argument out of the water that he gains no advantage over able-bodied athletes by using prosthetics.

"He is in a difficult place and can't have it both ways."

Professor Andy Miah, of the University of the West of Scotland, is another who questions whether Pistorius is treading on awkward philosophical ground.

"It would be a mistake to say that Oscar has been beaten at his own game, but critics have drawn parallels to his concern about Oliveira with arguments against Oscar's participation within the Olympic Games," he said on his personal website (www.andymiah.net).

"The IPC (International Paralympic Committee) have said that Oliveira's legs are within the rules, but here we have another debate about what the rules should be in the first place...

"The big question emerging from the race last night is whether the Paralympic rules within the T43 200m race need to be tighter.

"It's normal that a past winner should face young challengers and that they should eventually dethrone the champion. However, this looks like an unusual win and the concerns have been raised by other Paralympians about athletes adjusting their blade dimensions.

"If Oliveira's prosthetic legs are bigger and better and legal, then Pistorius really ought to get some. If his body height precludes this and the only reason why Oliveira has longer blades is that he is taller, then Pistorius has been beaten by a more biologically privileged athlete."

NEXT ON SPORT24X

Team SA results: Day Eight

2014-07-31 13:11

 

Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
64 comments
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining
Live Video Streaming
  • SS3
    Thu, 31 Jul 2014 @04:00
  • SS4
    Thu, 31 Jul 2014 @05:00
  • SS5
    Thu, 31 Jul 2014 @05:59
  • SS7
    Thu, 31 Jul 2014 @06:00
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

Vote

Do South Africa's Olympians and Paralympians deserve equal monetary rewards for winning gold, silver and bronze medals in London?

 
 
Featured Blog

Dave ask if you would like to meet your local sports heroes and stand the chance to win prizes to the value of over R40 000.

Latest blogs
 

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Newsletters Sign up for the Morning Glory, Super 15 and Soccer newsletters

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

iPhone Latest Sport24 news on your iPhone

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

TV schedule Plan your couch time with our searchable sport TV guide

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

 
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.