Yanks circumvent TV control
New York - It took Jason Legate, a Walnut Creek, California-resident, all of 10 minutes to connect his computer to a London-based server and access BBC's coverage of the Olympics on Saturday, thereby circumventing NBC's lock on coverage in the United States.
The 31-year-old system administrator said he has watched at least 12 hours of live BBC coverage [his favourite sport so far – judo] since he set up a virtual private network (VPN) connection to send all his internet traffic to a server in London.
Legate is one of many viewers who, turned off by NBC's ironclad control of access to Olympics coverage in the United States and spotty online streaming, has resorted to a workaround-sometimes legal, sometimes not-to watch the Games when and how they want on feeds from countries such as the UK and Canada. Business over users
NBC, which spent $1.18bn for the rights to broadcast the Olympics on the internet and on television in the United States, has made it impossible for people without a pricey cable or satellite subscription to watch the Olympics live in the United States. Viewers can receive a complimentary four hours of live content with a temporary pass.
Only those customers who are first "authenticated" as paying cable or satellite subscribers have access to live streaming of every Olympic event, a move that has led to an explosion of anger at the network on Twitter under the unofficial "#NBCfail" hashtag.
Other complaints included NBC streaming that didn't work and the network bombarded viewers had too much advertising.
For its regular network coverage, NBC, which is owned by cable giant Comcast, has tape-delayed some of the most popular sports for the US prime-time audience, meaning they air nearly five to six hours after they have happened.
This helps NBC maximize its return-on-investment by saving the top events for the largest audience and thereby the biggest advertising pay-off. But it has also led to event spoilers and criticism that the network was putting the interests of its business over those of its viewers.Criticism
The tape delay and some glitches in the coverage fuelled wider criticism of NBC. But NBC spokesperson Chris McCloskey, who declined to comment on the matter, pointed to the 7 million live streams, which was a record on the first day of competition. The company is making every event available live online - except the opening and closing ceremonies.
Enter a small but vocal group of tech savvy Olympics fans who are finding new ways to watch the world's biggest sports event away from their TV sets.
These fans use techniques that make it seem like their computers are located outside the United States, giving them access to streaming access to the Games held by companies other than NBC in countries such as Canada or the UK. Think of it as a sporting version of how internet users in China access banned websites by routing traffic through servers in Hong Kong in order to fool government censors.
"Because all of my internet traffic looks like it's coming from that box in England, the BBC thinks I'm located in England," Legate said of the workaround he utilises.
Like NBC in the United States, the BBC's Olympic rights only allow it to show the games to users in the UK. Boycott
Legate still pays for cable service through his local provider Astound, but said he decided to boycott NBC after he was unable to find a live broadcast of the opening ceremonies last Friday.
He was also miffed by comments made by an NBC spokesperson to the LA Times on Friday about the opening ceremony not translating well online because it is "complex" and requires context for a US audience.
"To me, it just felt like they were insulting everyone so I basically decided to boycott NBC for the duration of the games, which meant I had to find an alternative," he said.
Legate said he has set up the same connection for a friend who wanted to watch dressage, an equestrian event that she could not find on NBC.
People who are finding ways to circumvent NBC's restrictions seem to be spreading the word to friends, like New York City journalist Kate Gardiner, who sent out a public service announcement message on Twitter last weekend to urge her followers to use a service called TunnelBear.
The 26-year-old has been using the service to keep up with live swimming broadcasts even though she does not own a television.
TunnelBear is a VPN service that sends a user's internet connection to different countries, so in Gardiner's case it appears her computer is based in London. The decision to avoid NBC was easy for her since she's one of the millions of US residents without a cable subscription.
"I'm not going to buy a cable subscription to spend three weeks watching Olympics coverage. It's not going to happen," she said.
So far it is unclear whether NBC would take on the task of blocking or suing services like TunnelBear or StreamVia, a similar workaround. Typically, NBC has left it to the International Olympic Committee (IOC) to police the piracy of the games' TV rights.
NBC Sports spokesperson McCloskey said the company never comments on issues involving security.Advanced, costly
The workarounds-as well as the outrage-so far seem to be having no effect on TV rating for the Olympics. NBC has pointed to record-breaking success through the first three days of the games, with more than 36 million average viewers, including more than 40 million people watching the opening ceremony.
But while these fledgling services may seem popular on Twitter and blogs, many people could be turned off by them because they involve several steps that may be too advanced for a casual internet user and can cost money, said City University of New York journalism professor Jeff Jarvis, who has tested them out. After 500 megabytes of streaming video, users need pay for a $5 subscription on TunnelBear, for example.
"While TunnelBear is easier than some services, you've got to geek out and you've got pay," Jarvis said, adding that the number of people using these services is a fraction of those tuning into NBC.
Jarvis said people circumventing NBC don't pose a threat and they are just consumers trying to make a point.
"It says 'Hey, we can go around you,' and the lesson there is, if you think you can control communication, content and culture around borders, it is going to be become increasingly difficult," he said.