Share

Has Duminy done enough to keep his place?

Cape Town - The ongoing Test between South Africa and New Zealand is a crucially important one - not just for the Proteas but for South African sport. 

The Proteas have slipped to No 7 in the Test rankings, ahead of only the West Indies, Bangladesh and Zimbabwe. 

It is no place for a team that, under the guidance of Graeme Smith, dominated the world stage in the longer format for so long. 

Looking at the individual talent still on offer in this side - AB de Villiers (currently injured), Hashim Amla, Quinton de Kock, Dale Steyn, Kagiso Rabada, Vernon Philander - it is a tough pill to swallow for a public that has come to expect so much more. 

For that reason alone, a series win over the Black Caps (even if it is effectively in the form of a one-off Test) is important. 

When one factors in the struggles of the Springboks at the moment as well as the fact that Bafana Bafana take on Mauritania in a 'dead-rubber' 2017 Afcon qualifier on Friday, it becomes clear that South African sport needs a lift. 

But while this Test, which the Proteas will surely win, is of major significance in terms of the general mood accompanying our 'big three' sporting codes, it has also been a telling occasion for a couple of individuals in this team.

A few batsmen have gone about their business at Centurion with the spotlight firmly on them ... JP Duminy, Faf du Plessis and Stiaan van Zyl in particular. 

With De Villiers and Dean Elgar out injured, and expected to return for the three-match series in Australia in November, there will certainly be some changes to the top order. 

The easiest of those to predict is Van Zyl - 35 and 5 in Pretoria - dropping out for De Villiers.

The classy left-hander has had a tough time, not passing 50 once in 16 attempts since a century on Test debut back in December 2014. 

But the return of Elgar makes things a little more complicated. 

Du Plessis, dropped from the side for the 4th Test against England early this year, has returned to remind the selectors of his ability with a quality century. 

That first innings marathon knock of 112* will surely be enough to cement his place in the starting XI for the first Test against the Aussies in Perth. 

Now, if Elgar is to return alongside Stephen Cook at the top of the order then De Kock will have to drop back down, possibly to No 7. 

That would mean that one of Amla, Duminy, Du Plessis or Themba Bavuma would have to make way. 

With Bavuma's international career just taking off, and with Amla and now Du Plessis practically undroppable, the future does not look bright for Duminy despite his resilient 88 in the first dig at Centurion. 

It was an innings that showcased Duminy's natural ability and versatility as he was promoted to the all-important No 4 position. He was streaky at times, but played some delightful strokes - his straight drive particularly impressive - on his way to his best Test score in 16 attempts. 

There has never been any doubt over Duminy's raw talent and it is rather his temperament in the longer format that comes into question. 

Unfortunately for Duminy, he was dismissed without scoring in the second innings, though the importance of that knock was almost completely extinguished by the dominance of the Proteas in the match. 

One way of keeping Duminy in the setup would be to continue with De Kock at the top of the order, meaning that Elgar would miss out. 

But that is unlikely for two reasons. 

Firstly, Elgar probably doesn't deserve to be left out after having been one of the grittier performers against England this past summer. 

Secondly, having your wicket-keeper open the batting in Test cricket is not ideal. 

It may seem an attractive option given how effortlessly De Kock succeeded in Pretoria, but it is surely not something Proteas management will consider long-term, especially with South Africa facing the prospect of long, physically demanding stints in the field in Australia. 

So, the Proteas top order may look like this in Aussie: Cook, Elgar, Amla, De Villiers, Du Plessis, Bavuma, De Kock. 

It might be harsh on Duminy should he miss out after having thrived under pressure and out of position at Centurion, but a look at the past couple of years suggests that he has not nearly cashed in on his many opportunities.

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Join News24 today
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Voting Booth
How much would you be prepared to pay for a ticket to watch the Springboks play against the All Blacks at Ellis Park or Cape Town Stadium this year?
Please select an option Oops! Something went wrong, please try again later.
Results
R0 - R200
32% - 1839 votes
R200 - R500
32% - 1806 votes
R500 - R800
19% - 1100 votes
R800 - R1500
8% - 468 votes
R1500 - R2500
3% - 193 votes
I'd pay anything! It's the Boks v All Blacks!
5% - 258 votes
Vote
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.

LEARN MORE