Rob Houwing

Bouch v Haddin: gloves off!

2008-12-10 08:26
Email | Print
Sport24 chief writer Rob Houwing (File)

Rob Houwing

I was on the point of saying how Mark Boucher had hammered in an important personal stake for the seismic trip Down Under by registering his slightly overdue fifth Test century against Bangladesh a few days ago.

But then his direct rival with the wicketkeeping gloves and in the Australian lower middle-order, Brad Haddin, promptly went and did likewise - in his case a maiden ton - against New Zealand in Adelaide.

Perhaps it was a strong mutual signal, nevertheless, that in an expected tightly-contested series both glovemen realise that the winner of their own “weight of contribution to the cause” duel may just influence the overall outcome.

Yes, it is no coincidence that both players cranked up their batting output a notch or two in separate Tests immediately preceding the first between the two traditional juggernauts at the WACA in Perth from December 17.

There is a pretty good chance, unless Australia opt to go without a specialist spinner and play both all-rounders in Andrew Symonds and Shane Watson, that as much as they battle it out for summer mastery of their proven trades behind the stumps, Boucher and Haddin will also occupy the respective No 7 batting spots for their countries (Haddin would doubtless bat at eight in the alternative scenario outlined above).

Whichever slots they occupy, both players act as important buffers between the batting cream and the tail of the order.

This may, I fear, be especially so in the South African case: our tail is the fluffier one, for all the wrong reasons, which only adds to the pressure on Boucher to come to the run-scoring and maybe sometimes strike-farming party in Australia.

Physically resurgent

A glaring reminder of this was served up even against the weak Bangladeshis at Bloemfontein and Centurion, where the Proteas Nos 8-11 managed a less-than-regal total of 15 runs between them over two innings at a piffling average of 2.14.

Bowlers like a seemingly emotionally and physically resurgent Brett Lee and left-arm slingshot Mitchell Johnson are particularly good at mowing down suspect lower orders and will have taken gleeful note, you can be sure, that the days of Kluseners, Pollocks and Symcoxes among the bottom-end Proteas batsmen are long gone.

Just imagine how irresistible the current South African batting order would be if it was backed up by the strength of yesteryear (Allan Donald apart, perhaps) at the rear end.

It is fortunate, then, that Boucher traditionally thrives on such pressure and responsibility.

He knows there is not much below him in the way of truly stout resistance and already once, famously and crucially, this year he has shielded the brittle tail from possible team calamity: his undefeated innings of 45 in a sixth-wicket stand of 112 with chief messiah Graeme Smith was priceless in sealing the series victory over England at Edgbaston.

His batting record both against Australia overall and in that country specifically in Tests is not special, falling some way below his overall average of 30.43, but he remains very much “one for a crisis” and the fluency and shot-selection in his 117 against Bangladesh was a decent sign for Down Under.

There are people who have been saying he has not made enough meaty scores of late and it is true that his Centurion ton was his first since January 2004. But statistics do not conclusively prove he has been in batting decline: his average has always tended to hover around the respectable 30 mark.

Excusable blemish

Haddin is an interesting case. He is only about a year behind Boucher in age terms, so is an experienced first-class campaigner, but had to wait in the international wings for years because of the revered presence for the Baggy Greens of one Adam Gilchrist.

It explains to a good degree why the South African - despite the odd excusable blemish, still massively dependable generally as SA ‘keeper - is so far ahead in Test cap terms: 120 plays nine!

Suddenly, though, Haddin has exploded into life as a Test batting factor at an ominously opportune juncture - his weighty 169 against the Kiwis at Adelaide was also his first score over 50 in his ninth Test.

Leading cricket scribe Peter Roebuck, writing in the Sydney Morning Herald, described Haddin as a “different man” in Adelaide.

“He had been waiting in the wings almost as long as Prince Charles … shrugging off the albatross on his shoulder, a bird going by the name of Gilchrist, he decided to have a crack.

“With players of this sort, instinctive and combative, inhibition does not work. Hesitancy is their downfall. Hereafter Haddin will be seen in his true colours.”

Haddin v Boucher … another intriguing skirmish, then, in a fascinating, looming collective “war”.

Here’s a helpful little tale of the wicketkeepers’ tape for Sport24 readers:

MARK VERDON BOUCHER BRADLEY JAMES HADDIN
Age: 32 (on Dec 3) Age: 31
Tests: 120 (13 v Australia) Tests: 9 (0 v SA)
ODIs: 272 ODIs: 33
Test runs: 4504 at 30.43 Test runs: 508 at 36.28
Test centuries: 5 Test centuries: 1
HS: 125 HS: 169
Test runs v Australia: 575 at 25.00 Test runs v SA: 0
Test runs in Australia: 305 at 23.46 Test runs in Australia: 194 at 64.66
Test catches: 437 Test catches: 34
Test stumpings: 20 Test stumpings: 0
  

Rob is Sport24's chief writer.

Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.             

 

Your Comments

Michael12/3/2008 12:16 PM
Also second Granville, I found the column in places a bit verbose and hard to follow. Really had to force myself to understand what you where trying to say. Otherwise a great point and I will be specifically comparing the two's contributions in the upcoming series.
Lance12/3/2008 11:50 AM
I agree with Granville, this is not easy reading, and does not do much for relaxation during your lunch break.
Anonymous User12/3/2008 11:20 AM
BigBoer. what are you talking about Steyn bieng unreliable in England? The bloke played half the series, and was injured..has the best strike rate in world cricket.. Ntini is bowling nicely around the wicket to lefties..Fair on Morkel, but i feel sooner than later he'll explod in a big series..It'll be a close thing i feel
Denzil12/3/2008 10:50 AM
Rob..whilst the Haddin vs Boucher clash should be interesting the deciding factor between the two teams I believe will be in the bowling department.And worse still is the fact that the South African bowlers will have to play at their "peak" ALL THE TIME to nullify the Ozzie batsmen as they do appear to have a better batting line up. Have they got it in them? Onlt time will tell!!
Granville12/3/2008 10:32 AM
I am a big fan of your cricket writng. Don't get me wrong, but of late your columns have been a bit verbose. Not very easy reading. I however like your opinion on the game. Very sensible.
Steadfast12/3/2008 10:24 AM
Boucher is a very safe bet and loves a battle. He will need a very special effort to give us more than his average of past. The Aussies have an excellent tail clean up. Where SA suffer is to finish off the tail - just look at Bangledesh. Haddin is an unknown quality and we know from the past that the Aussies dont pick average. With our bowlers record on tail clean up Haddin should be able to post good scores. The difference between the two is in the quality of the bowlers in the tail clean up. Not that one player is better than the other on paper yet.
BigBoer12/3/2008 10:17 AM
Forget Boucher I'm sure he'll do well. I'm worried about our attack. Steyn and Morkel proved in England that they are not reliable. Morkel in particular is very wayward. Right now they are not good replacements for Donald and Pollock and will need to prove me wrong in Australia - probably the toughest tour there is.
Your Name
*
Email
*
Comment
*
 
Please enter the text below:

*
 
 
Columns by this Writer
Sofa, so good...
Commentator or coach? Rob Houwing wonders how long former Proteas speedster Allan Donald will remain in limbo …
Snare Sehwag... or else
Rob Houwing says Virender Sehwag’s relish for South African bowling shapes as a major Test series obstacle.
Featured Blog

Nary a ball had been kicked in anger in the Super 14, but years of woe haven't dampened Huge Dude's spirit. 'This is their year', he says, the year when the Lions will go forth and conquer, and crush all foes beneath them to a bloody pulp! Take note, fair-weather fans, we have a true supporter in our midst!

Latest blogs

Bulls looking a tad pale? 2/9/2010 3:32:15 PM

Buy World cup tickets!!! The world is laughing... 2/9/2010 3:26:16 PM

Brilliant win! 2/9/2010 2:51:16 PM

Blueworld

Check your mate!

RSS Feeds

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

Mobile

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

Free Email

Free Email Get a free 24.com e-mail account and stay in touch

Blogs

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

TV

TV schedule Plan your couch time with our searchable sport TV guide