Rob Houwing

ICC must shoo out the mice

2008-10-29 18:42
Email | Print
Rob Houwing

Rob Houwing

I know, I know, it’s all very PC and fuzzy feel-good to talk of “expanding cricket’s frontiers” and “helping the minnows come out of the shadows”.

Why, there is even talk – in the November edition of The Wisden Cricketer (UK) -- that China could be a major force in 10 years.

Yeah, right … just like Bangladesh, around 1998, were no doubt touted to be just that themselves by 2008.

Only Bangladesh haven’t quite achieved that lofty expectation. They remain stubbornly ninth and last on the ICC Test rankings table, with a farcical, glaringly fat zero in rating points to their name. (Top-placed Australia have 138 points and even dozy, eighth-ranked West Indies 81, by way of perspective.)

In 55 Test matches since their introduction to the arena in 2000, Bangladesh have won precisely one of them, a 2005 match against a Zimbabwe team already well on the slippery slope to turmoil and virtual ruin, in line with the nation itself.

Unlike Sri Lanka who, by the ninth year of their Test existence in 1991, lost just one of their six matches against New Zealand, England and Pakistan – a compelling here-to-stay signal – Bangladesh have made no such strides. They may well have lurched backwards.

Fish out of water? I’d say it’s worse than that, and the situation doesn’t look like stabilising -- never mind improving -- with any haste, especially with several “big-name” Bangladeshis seduced by the lucre waved in front of them by one of the world’s burgeoning array of Twenty20 circuses.

The country has some tenacious (but only that) cricketers and passionate followers, and I feel for them. But the game’s global fabric has changed violently in recent months – maybe more violently than some people even realise.

A big, almost out-of-control scheduling squeeze is on and, cold truth be told, a Test series against Bangladesh has become an unviable drag, a mere statutory obligation, for every nation above them.

Ho-hum and ho-hum again

Ah, but what about when South Africa were bowled out for 170 in their first innings at Mirpur, earlier this very year? I would retort that for every short-lived Mirpur “mirage” there is also a reality-check Chittagong, where the Proteas passed 400 without loss of a wicket, just a few days on, and duly won the series 2-0 anyway. Ho-hum and ho-hum again.

And if you are going to defend Bangladesh on the flimsy grounds of sessions or hours of sporadic home Test supremacy, then you might as well venture that Holland deserve full ODI status because they beat South Africa once in a rain-reduced meeting at the fag end of a gruelling England tour, or Ireland because they upset split-personality Pakistan one eventful “we were great, they were terrible” day in the Caribbean.

Very shortly, Bangladesh will be fitted in on our shores – a la the currently-visiting Kenya -- for as short a time as is humanly possible (given that the trip isn’t going to burst any bank or buckle any turnstile). If the weather plays ball, you would not expect either Test to go much beyond three days.

And on our pacier pitches, this “international” team, ironically enough, will in all likelihood have helped less in South Africa’s preparations for Australia than another few precious, all-too-rare franchise appearances would have done instead for the Proteas regulars.

At least a stronger semblance of strength-versus-strength would have prevailed in the latter case!

No, in this climate of unseemly scramble for the Twenty20 attentions of the world’s most flamboyant cricketers and consequent, ever-gnawing marginalisation of the five-day game, there simply can be no further room for soft Test series.

Banish Bangladesh to Benoni or Darwin or Chester-le-Street, if you wish, in an insincere attempt to “promote the game in the backwaters”, but the core problem won’t go away.

All that these soulless contests -- played out before handfuls of spectators and the limited extra swelling the press-box provides -- will do is hasten the format’s demise, and paint a damaging, uncool image at a time when, really, the reverse is required.

Competitive, entertaining and highly popular



I think Bangladesh have got to go, at least from a five-day point of view, as the most feasible ICC “itinerary uncluttering” solution.

It’s regrettable, but necessary in the new world order.

Perhaps the way ahead for them is to spiritedly put all their eggs in 20- and 50-overs baskets, aiming to become a more credible force in these formats?

It reminds me of the way Zimbabwean rugby reinvented itself, to a good degree, soon after deciding to abandon the 15-man code and focus on sevens. When I watched them play the World Cup Sevens in Hong Kong in 1997, they were competitive, entertaining and highly popular.

I’m afraid that, through necessity, Bangladesh’s Test cricket status ought to become increasingly less, rather than more assured.
I somehow hope, for the sake of the five-day game’s very survival rather than with any malicious intent, that their second Test-level safari to South Africa is also their last ...

- Rob is the Chief Writer at Sport24


Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

 

Your Comments

Bon jovie11/3/2008 2:57 PM
You didn’t call them mice when they beat us in the WC and neither when they beat the Aussies (yes it was only once but camon it was in Aus).... The only way they can do it more consistently is by playing the top teams more consistently!
Shoinik11/3/2008 4:59 AM
Rob, this column is a waste of space mate. Clearly, you have not done any research on why Bangladesh has been such underachievers e.g. their infrastructure, the quality of their first class cricket, how the senior/older player were treated, how many of them were given a long run in test matches and how many chopping and changing the selectors have done over the years. You just blatantly attacked us based on the statistics which is not expected from a 'sports editor'. Guess what? You also got a fat zero for this 'masterpiece'. We will take huge strides if Siddons is around for another year with or without the players we lost in ICL. We are a proud country. Next time, think before you use derogatory terms.
pinch_hitter11/2/2008 7:04 AM
couldnt agree with you more rob. shoo off the mice. that'll make WI the new minnow. why stop there? icc can shoo them off too. the last team will always be the mouse. they can work themselves up the order till there's only one team left. how's that? keep shooing off all the mice to globalize cricket. meanwhile keep cultivating totally meaningful and not at all commercial icl, ipl, stanford, hongkong 6, epl, champions trophy, the proposed au-nz-eng-sa t20 league - at the expense of utterly meaningless scheduled tour matches, all for the glory of cricket. rob for president.
WarWolf11/1/2008 11:12 PM
I think you guys didn't forget the WC2007. If we could hold the nerve then last month NZ had to go back to their country by loosing both ODI and Test Series. Ha ha ha. Funny article. Yet thanks. I got some thing to laugh at, been passing boring time.
Anonymous User11/1/2008 11:09 PM
I see this a moronic article. What is the condition of your so-called elite team NZ?
shartaz11/1/2008 10:58 PM
Its a shame to see that the apartheid movement didn't completely wipe out bigotry and prejuidice from south africa. Thanks for keeping it alive Rob. By the way I hope to see your column when we beat south africa. The problem isn't Bangladesh, the problem is fat headed weeds like you and Ian Chappel, eliminating you 'weeds' would do cricket more good then eliminating bangladesh.
Judas11/1/2008 8:49 PM
It is of course due to Jagmohan Dalmiya and the most pathetic board in the world, the BCCI, that this sordid mess has been created in the first place. I can see the future now: SCORES: B'desh 107 all out, SA 487/2 declared (70 overs), B'desh 179 all out. POST MATCH: B'desh captain (whatever the chap's name is) - We were outplayed but this is a learning experience for all of us, blah, blah, blah. Graeme Smith - They have some good players, in a few years they should be a strong force in test cricket (right!), blah, blah, blah. SA will get better practice against the Natal schoolboys XI for the Australian tour...but wait...they're going to be thrashed senseless by the Aussies as usual anyway...so, bring on Bangladesh!
Bondhu11/1/2008 8:23 AM
The Mice will trap the cat now
Pubudu10/31/2008 11:34 PM
I completely agree. We should go back to the good old days. Australia, England, South Africa and New Zealand. Keep the Windies as the token black team. We should also go back to kicking blacks out of our (SA) sports teams! How dare the subcontinental *natives* try and undermine the power that WE once held! How dare they! (Sarcasm btw, hope you get the point - for 40 - 50 years the subcontinent was treated as second class, most people just cant handle that the times they are a changin'. - look at NZ record in their first 40 years of test cricket)
jaber10/31/2008 11:29 PM
aww what a shame u cant do anything about it was a nice speech but nobody cares about your views go bangladesh
Green Tea10/31/2008 11:16 PM
It is true Bangladesh placed 9th position in the ICC Test rankings. And as a test playing nation Bangladesh should play better cricket. You have presented some statistics but you must admit that Bangladesh makes lots of improvement from 1998 to 2008 in ODIs. The Test statistics for Bangladesh is not good. But I cannot understand why you are so eager to strip the test status of Bangladesh. If you want to tell us that most elite Test playing countries have no time to play some cricket against Bangladesh. They can spend their time by playing Stanford 20/20 or IPL and earn more money and glamour. Against Bangladesh there is no glamour. This is so true. If an elite Test playing country looses a match against Bangladesh, I can imagine their embarrassments. And I do not understand why you are so sympathetic for them. In your article you have repeatedly mentioned "the new world order". And to save the new world order for the purity of the game the maiden (Bangladesh) must be sacrificed. This is a totally facile remark. I am personally very much surprised by this logic. How it is possible such a big problem ("the new world order" jointly created by Modi and Stanford) has such a simple solution? I am shocked that you want this unholy "the new world order" should rule over cricket. The Cricket spirit lies in Country vs Country not a club vs club. As a sports editor you should promote that thing but unfortunately you lost the rudder and suddenly you discover the land of "the new world order". As a sports editor you should promote cricket. You should not write an article to banish a country from Test arena for the sake of "the new world order". You should personally apologies to call Bangladesh team a “mice”.
markC10/31/2008 9:57 PM
Ahh!! I love how some people mentions about the support of BCCI. I dont see when BCCI is wrecking the game through IPL-ICL controversy, None of you making a single sound. Or is it because IPL benefits your players, not the BCCI's support for Bangladesh Cricket. And btw, BCCI has not even invited Bangladesh to play in India. Jagmohon Dalmiya might have thought of bangladesh, but the current administration doesnot give a damn about Bangladesh. ICL saga is very clear example of that. BCB was forced to BAN ICL players, so that BCCI could prove a point. If you want to talk about muscle flexing by BCCI talk about ICL, not the test status of bangladesh!!
Gopal Bhar10/31/2008 9:36 PM
I am a Bangladeshi and I absolutely agree with everything you said about our team.....and the sad thing is at the end of the of day we still kick your @$$ in the WC and speed up the euthanasia thereby crumbling your dreams to win the World Cup. Tsk....tsk......tsk.
bujhee kom10/31/2008 9:25 PM
"Only Bangladesh haven’t quite achieved that lofty expectation. They remain stubbornly ninth and last on the ICC Test rankings table, with a farcical, glaringly fat zero in rating points to their name." bobby boy, ahve you taken a look at yourself on the mirror today, this morning? you need to lose some major fat yourself! looking like a skinned hog! yeah, go back to pork breakfast and we are coming to safa and the these we will leave your fat behind bleeding.... "Fish out of water? I’d say it’s worse than that, and the situation doesn’t look like stabilising -- never mind improving -- with any haste, especially with several “big-name” Bangladeshis seduced by the lucre waved in front of them by one of the world’s burgeoning array of Twenty20 circuses." what a joke....bobby boy you don't know jack about BD cricket.... get ready with your preperation-h... "The country has some tenacious (but only that) cricketers and passionate followers, and I feel for them." no need to feel for anybody...just feel your cholesterol and fat and waite for your heart attack! peace and happy porking porky...
Anonymous User10/31/2008 8:23 PM
Hi Rob I was trying to find stats of ZA team in early 90s, but couldn't. Why is that?
Djoker10/31/2008 11:06 AM
It is all relative, Rob. In Australia we have as much respect for South Africa as you have for Bangladesh there. What was the result when we played home and away a couple of years back - 5 - nil or 6 - nil ?
Anonymous User10/31/2008 10:33 AM
Why are you calling them Bangis. I guess somethings never change
PJ10/31/2008 10:21 AM
What the ICC should do is this: Make various leagues for the international test game, ie: a Elite League, where the top 8 countries in the world play, 1st Division(or whatever u wanna call it) where Bangladesh, Scotland, Ireland, Canada, or whoever the next 10-12 countries in International cricket are, then 2nd Division, 3rd division, you basically get my drift. Make all of them play each other in tests over a 2/3 year span, then whoever places bottom of the log, get sent to a lower division, or whoever wins the 1st, 2nd or 3rd division get promoted to a higher league.
Sam10/31/2008 6:54 AM
If those so called "bangis" are a waste of space thne the Afrikaaners who lost to them in the one-day world cup should be dropped to the B list of one day fixers where they hopefully will NOT choke or "fix" in games against Scotland, Kenya, Zimbabwe and Uganda.
Warnesie10/31/2008 6:26 AM
Couldn't agree more Rob. Zimbabwe should also be wiped from the list. The only reason Bangladesh (and also Zimbabwe) are still ICC members is their undying support for the BCCI. Bangladesh and Zimbabwe should be relegated to the second tier and made the equivalent of a state/county/provincial side. Every three years, they each play a series of unofficial "Tests" again the bottom three ranked Test teams, each series of three "Tests". The best ranked three teams remain or advance into Tier 1 and the bottom two teams remain or are relegated to Tier 2. Simple. Unfortunatley the BCCI loses two taken-for-granted votes and the respective boards lose millions of US dollars in cash. I wonder where that money goes, especially in Zimbabwe? I'm an Aussie and I long for the "old time" tours to return - the touring team played a couple of four day games prior to the first Test, then a few other four day games during the rest of the tour. South Africa and Australia in England, England or South Africa in Australia and so on would all benefit from this type of tour. Alas, our sports' administrators appetite for the almighty dollar has kyboshed this type of tour and ultimately (once again) it is the supporter who gets the raw end.
Martin10/29/2008 6:42 PM
Sad, but unforunately, true. Is there not an ICC "B" section where the likes of Scotland, Ireland, Holland, Canada and the likes comepete. Let the Bangladeshis go and do thier learning their instead of inflating the averages of the players of stronger nations!
Henry10/29/2008 5:49 PM
Here here Rob. Absolute waste of space those Bangis. Thanks for having the guts to come out and say it
Your Name
*
Email
*
Comment
*
 
Please enter the text below:

*
 
 
Columns by this Writer
Sofa, so good...
Rob Houwing suggests we’ll all be dangerously punch-drunk after many looming weeks of Twenty20 cricket on TV …
French to catch Boks cold?
Rob Houwing hopes the Springboks aren’t under-estimating the importance of their one-off Test against France at Newlands.
Featured Blog

We all know that FIFA are the head honchos of the beautiful game. They set out laws that govern the sport and we are supposed to fall in line and follow. Now I agree that there must be rules in place for everyone to follow but what I don’t get, is how FIFA are currently strutting around like they own South Africa, says Mr Controversy.

Latest blogs

Bulls wake up 3/19/2010 11:44:28 PM

Steve Walsh's tattoo 3/19/2010 11:43:37 PM

IncrediBULL Character 3/19/2010 11:22:02 PM

Who is your hero?

Nominate your hero and win R 10 000!

RSS Feeds

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

Mobile

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

Free Email

Free Email Get a free 24.com e-mail account and stay in touch

Blogs

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

TV

TV schedule Plan your couch time with our searchable sport TV guide