ArthurTurner

The good and bad of the IPL

2009-05-25 10:52
Email | Print
Sport24 columnist Arthur Turner (File)

Arthur Turner

The Indian Premier League in South Africa was a massive success and was embraced by the South African public. In fact the tournament was probably better supported than the 2003 Cricket World Cup. I am sure the local support far exceeded the expectations of the organisers. It certainly surprised me.

It is estimated that in the region of 15 000 Indians traveled to South Africa to support their teams. The IPL reserved 25 000 tickets for the two semi-finals and the final before they went on sale. These three matches were sold out halfway through the tournament.

The IPL enjoyed massive support from the Asian community in South Africa and it was wonderful to see how they embraced the teams. The Asian community world wide once again showed their great love for the game of cricket.

It will be interesting to see if the IPL brings the tournament or a segment back to South Africa in the future. There is certainly a case to be made for this decision as it would make sense to build on the legacy that has been left behind from the 2009 tournament. However, this decision will be driven by commercial realities and the fact that it is an Indian domestic competition.

The IPL needs to be careful that it does not become over commercialised, the strategic break is the best example of this. As I wrote in an earlier column the strategic break has no benefit from a cricketing point of view or for the spectators at the ground or the television audience. Fortunately, it will not be implemented for the ICC World Twenty20 in England.

The entertainment aspects at matches needs to be controlled to ensure that cricket does not become a by-product of the IPL. The game needs to remain the focus and matches must not become a Bollywood extravaganza. Twenty-over cricket is a very strong product like soccer and rugby and does not need to be marketed artificially.

Scheduling problems

The IPL and the International Cricket Council needs to agree a moratorium on international cricket while the IPL is being played. The early departure of the players like Kevin Pietersen and Chris Gayle to play in a meaningless Test series is in nobody's interest. The ICC needs the member countries to buy into this concept in the interests of the players' earning capacity from the IPL and to avoid future scheduling problems.

The international players' performances dominated each team. Currently each franchise is allowed to contract a maximum of 10 foreign players per tournament but only four are allowed to play. They should consider allowing five foreign players on the field at any given time. This will further enhance the standard and also ensure that the highly paid foreign players are better utilised. The foreign players together with the Indian national players is what makes the IPL marketable.

The IPL also needs to put in place a ruling that franchises can only contract players who have played international limited overs cricket. This will ensure that only the best players in the world are contracted.

The standard of certain aspects of the cricket were disappointing, especially the fielding and catching. These disciplines of the IPL game have not improved since the last tournament. Also, the 'death bowling' was poor at times with many bowlers missing their lengths by big margins.

South Africa staged a very successful tournament at short notice and has once again proved to the world that the country has the capacity, infrastructure and passion to host major global events.   

Arthur is a former cricket administrator and current player agent.

Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

 

Your Comments

Fandash6/2/2009 8:29 PM
Arthur when are you going to stop putting your foot in it. The only reason you want only international players in the IPL is that you are hoping for a bigger cut in agents fees from SA players that may be bought. The strategic break was for commercial reasons only and the organisers stated this. I suggest you join a weight loss program and spend your time there instead of spewing forth garbage on this site. You just don't get it do you.
Jimbo5/26/2009 8:47 AM
The dancing tarts are the only reason I watch IPL!
Cricket is fun5/25/2009 11:26 PM
Come on, Anonymous. So dramatic :-) SA in India? SA in England? Aus in India? SA in Aus? etc. I even enjoyed England in WIndies a bit. Cricket is getting better. I prefer my international cricket served up with red ball over 5 days, but I'll take it all spiced up over 20 overs. It's only a game and the dancing girls won't distract you if you don't let them.
Anonymous User5/25/2009 8:14 PM
OK, lets be honest. Twenty20 is not really cricket. Timeouts,dancers, dunktanks, fireworks, heart rate monitors, you name it. Its a spectators circus and for that reason it was a great success. It can never become over commercialised. Unfortunately Twenty20 is already a byproduct of limited overs cricket which in turn is a byproduct of cricket. We are in the process of killing cricket and making a massive success of it!!!
Trippagon5/25/2009 7:22 PM
I'm trying to understand the rationale behind your opinion that "The IPL also needs to put in place a ruling that franchises can only contract players who have played international limited overs cricket." Dirk Nannes hasn't played a lot of domestic cricket in Australia, let alone international cricket. And guess who he kept out of the side throughout the 15 games Delhi Daredevils played? Thats right. Glenn Mcgrath. And he was instrumental in DD's phenomenal success in IPL2. Or take Shaun Marsh and David Hussey for that matter. They made it to their national squads on the strength of their performance in IPL1. Arent you missing the point here? Isnt this tournament meant to discover hidden gems, not just Indians at that, and give them a platform to express themselves?
jan5/25/2009 6:08 PM
only those who have played ltd overs? are you serious? serious talent can be unearthed by exposure to the IPL as a conduit FOR international selection, not the other way around. BTW- the more entertainment the better, ever seen an american football game with countless breaks and entertainment specials. You are writing out of a different era, a very narrow-minded article. Disappointing.
Anonymous User5/25/2009 4:45 PM
But you said at the beginning that nobody will be interested and everybody disagreed with you
uno5/25/2009 2:45 PM
thanks the ipl is a thing of the past, i had enough of ravi shastri end of the over comment "45/4". hopefully he wont be commentating in the upcoming world cup in england.
Lily White5/25/2009 11:03 AM
Arthur what are you talking about? 'The IPL also needs to put in place a ruling that franchises can only contract players who have played international limited overs cricket.' Why? What do you care what players they contract? As you said, it's an Indian domestic competition. They can do as they please. And so can you. If you dont like it dont watch it. The strategic timeout is advertising genius. Afterall, cricket is a game of breaks. Tea, lunch, supper, breakfast.... Absolutely brilliant to have an ad break for one of the most successful sport tv ventures in recent times. And as you may have noticed, the bowling team tends to get a wicket or two after this break... Nuff said, not like it will get through to you anyway.
Your Name
*
Email
*
Comment
*
 
Please enter the text below:

*
 
 
Columns by this Writer
Proteas: Next stop India
After squaring their Test series against England in ruthless fashion, the SA's next assignment is winning in India, writes Arthur Turner.
We need a real opener
The experiment of opening with Ashwell Prince has been a failure writes Arthur Turner, and the time for change has come.
Featured Blog

250 million quid. That's what Real Madrid paid out last year to get their hands on Ronaldo, Kaka and Karim Benzema, all in the hopes of getting to the Champions League final. But it was not to be as they were dumped from the competition by Lyon. Meanwhile, at Ron's old club, a Rooney masterclass sends Man U through to the quarterfinals. REM is loving it...

Blueworld

Check your mate!

RSS Feeds

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

Mobile

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

Free Email

Free Email Get a free 24.com e-mail account and stay in touch

Blogs

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

TV

TV schedule Plan your couch time with our searchable sport TV guide