One has to wonder how the broker who negotiated Handre Pollard’s insurance contract is feeling right now!
Sure there are actuarial numbers, bell curves and medians to blame, but the bottom line is that the person who brokered the deal must have come close to putting their employers out of business!
Imagine having to pick up Pollard’s SARU and Bulls salary for the next 9 to 12 months?
The injury happened during a freak training accident involving no contact, but what if Pollard had picked up the injury while playing in Japan, and then further exacerbated it while training in Pretoria?
Which set of insurers would have picked up his salary bill?
And perhaps more importantly, which doctor makes the call as to the origination of the injury?
That Hippocratic Oath is all good and well until a club salary gets in the way...
Which is why France's professional rugby players have demanded independent doctors be employed by the union rather than their clubs. This because players fears their health and careers are being put at risk. And because insurance companies have started reviewing the base of compensation paid out while a player is injured.
In a sport where salary caps get treated with disdain, and seasons are extending like tapeworms, players are worried about club doctors sometimes bowing to the hierarchy.
“Agh, he will be fine coach, it’s just a sprain” says the doc - knowing full well what the coach wants to hear about his star player. But who is to blame when it turns into a ligament rupture in minute one of the game and the player’s career is suddenly in the balance?
According to Montpellier lock Robins Tchale-Watchou, also president of the French Professional Players' Union, Provale, the number of players who have lost their professional rugby licence because of injury has almost tripled in eight years.
Hence Provale looking for a panel of independent doctors - not paid for by the clubs - to judge the seriousness of injuries and the duration for which players will be sidelined.
They are proposing a list of referring physicians who specialise in specific injuries that players can go to, to get a second opinion.
At a time when players are opting out of off-seasons, instead enjoying a little payment top-ups in Japan, it seems not only an obvious option, but one that insurers might start to demand.
With that will come higher monthly premiums for players, but perhaps unlikely to put much of a dent in the monopoly money being earned these days.
Who would pay for the independent panel of doctors? Insurers might be happy to chip in for a service like this. And governing bodies could levy a participation fee on all clubs or countries participating in the specific league or tournament they oversee.
Sadly, a high profile court case might be the only way to set a precedent.
But like our Discovery medical aid has exclusions like paragliding and kite surfing, how far away are we from insurers of players making an off season compulsory?
Tank Lanning is a former Western Province
prop, current editor of the all new www.vodacomrugby.co.zawebsite that allows you to rate the SA players, and vociferous Tweeter from
Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse
views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their
own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.