Tank Lanning

'Yes 9' makes scrum unfair

2013-09-26 09:53
Sport24 columnist Tank Lanning (File)
The new scrum call has not completely eradicated resets, but there certainly seem to be far fewer. We still see some properly strange/inept penalties based on binds and collapsing, but I think that will always be the case given the subjective interpretation of the laws by different referees.

The straight feed from the scrumhalf makes it a fairer contest and keeps packs higher as hookers now have to actually hook, which allows the opposition the chance to do the same - hence the previously seldom seen tighthead making a reappearance.

It is without doubt a safer place for front rows given the reduced hit and pre bind (my neck injury came from the packs not engaging at the same time and my head smashing into the opposition thigh), so all in all, I like the look of the new scrum.

My biggest concern is this “Yes 9” call from the ref that signals to the scrumhalf that the ball must be put in.

Apart from robbing the attacking side of the element of surprise, are we not meant to be absolving the referee of some of the responsibilities around the scrum?

The new engagement process and straight feed sees a return to the good old days when scrumming was about power, strength and technique, but also timing. Hence the hooker tapping the loosehead’s back when he was ready for the ball to come in. Part of the technique, and something we practiced for hours using various calls, was to get the little shove from all but the hooker, whose job is obviously to hook the ball back, timed to happen just as the ball was fed into the scrum.

Now it is the ref who is calling the scrum feed with this “Yes 9” call, and that is why we see the scrumhalf tapping the hooker’s arm just before the scrum feed, so at least he knows when the ball is coming in, and can strike for it.

But in making it the ref’s call as to when the scrum is fed, there are two important ramifications.

One – the attacking side loses the element of surprise as they no longer decide the timing of the feed, and two – it gives the opposition an unfair advantage as they know exactly when the ball is going to be fed into the scrum, and with 8 men who can shove, as opposed to the other side’s 7, they will have more power.

It is a bit like telling the hooker where and when to throw the ball into the lineout.

Teams earn the right to feed the scrum and lineout, and while you want the opposition to be able to contest the ball, there has to be some advantage in earning that right.

Yes the referee probably has to make a call as to whether the scrum is stable enough, but let’s move away from the referee deciding exactly when the ball should go in...

One man who will not have to worry about the scrum feed at Newlands on Saturday is professional Bok bag carrier, Lourens Adriaanse, who again misses out on even a spot on the bench. Tighthead props are scarce, and life after Jannie du Plessis looks uncertain at best. Yes Adriaanse is gaining valuable experience by spending time with the Boks, but against a weak Australian scrum, in South Africa, would it not have been a perfect opportunity to have a look at him in a Test environment? Instead French-based Gurthro Steenkamp gets yet another trot off the wood, despite us having loosehead props growing on trees here in SA.

Bold call to put Bismarck du Plessis on the bench. He is probably the best player in the world right now. Rotation works for some teams and players, but not others. Heyneke Meyer has got a lot right recently... Let’s hope this is another good call from the coach. Crouch, bind, engage...

Tank is a former Western Province tighthead prop and editor of the recently launched free monthly digital rugby magazine called SCRUM

Disclaimer:
Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

NEXT ON SPORT24X

A Bok opportunity lost?

2014-10-30 09:00

 

Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
25 comments
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining
Live Video Streaming
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

 

10 facts about swimming you didn't know

This will make you want to jump right into the pool.

 
 

Where were you when you last felt alive?

Snors with a cause - creating awareness of male health
Inspiring: Rock climbing with just one leg
Watch! Skateboarders racing cyclists
Exciting new zipline for Cape Town!
 
 
Men
Women
Love 2 Meet
Featured

Got something you'd like to get off your chest? Got a burning desire to air an opinion? If so, be sure to sign-up on Sport24's FORUM!

Latest blogs
Vote

The Currie Cup is a thing of the past and attention now turns to the Springboks' end of year tour where they will play Ireland, England, Italy and Wales. How many Test will Heyneke Meyer's men win?

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

Newsletters Sign up for the Morning Glory, Super 15 and Soccer newsletters

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

Forum Have your Say on Sport24's brand new Forum!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

iPhone Latest Sport24 news on your iPhone

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

 
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.