As a fan, I am absolutely thrilled to see
both Bismarck du Plessis and Scarra Ntubeni going head-to-head in the middle of
the scrum come Saturday afternoon for the Currie cup final.
What I am less thrilled about is the fact
that Advocate André Oosthuizen, the man who cleared Du Plessis of
stamping on Free State flank Pieter Labuschagne at a SARU judicial hearing on
Tuesday, deemed me thick enough to believe his reason for the clearance - that
it was accidental!
He might as well have sent us all dunce’s
caps at the same time...
Call it lacking in reaching a red card
threshold, or just say the yellow card was enough of a punishment, but do not
treat us like 4-year-olds with our heads stuck in the sand!
Look, I thought Ntubeni was lucky not to be
cited after his tip tackle in WP’s semi-final against the Golden Lions, and Du Plessis
certainly got the rough end of the stick in being issued a red card for his so
called illegal tackle on Dan Carter earlier in the year, so perhaps rugby karma
But let us remember this ruling the next
time Richie McCaw or Ben Franks is cleared of any wrong doing in the build up
to a game against the Boks or an SA franchise in next year’s Super Rugby. I
have very little doubt that Saturday’s game at Newlands played it’s part in
And what a game it is destined to be!
WP and the Sharks have been the stand-out
sides of the Currie Cup, with their respective semi-finals on the weekend
proving what the log points had suggested going into the weekend, that there has
been a pretty big gap between these two sides and the rest, this year.
And while WP might have made more use of
the firepower they have out wide, both games were decided by incredibly astute use
of the boot at flyhalf. The battle between Demitri Catrakilis and Pat Lambie
will be one for the ages, the former having developed hugely as a player in
keeping the under pressure Kings in many of their Super Rugby games earlier in
the year. The latter, incredibly, seemingly still in need of persuading Bok
coach Heyneke Meyer of his undoubted talent, both with ball on boot, and in
But as we all know, it is the forwards who
decide which team wins the match, with the backs in the mix just to decide by
So one can understand why the Sharks would
want to give Bok tighthead Jannie du Plessis as much time as possible to
recover from breaking a bone in his hand last week. Recovering from a broken
bone in a week? That is a big ask. And with man mountain Willem Alberts only
back from what looked to be a fairly serious neck injury incurred while playing
for the Boks, and Beast Mtawarira back after being a late withdrawal last
weekend, the men from Durban may well be relying a little heavily on the Elastoplast that keeps modern day players intact.
Remarkably, both scrums have not looked
that special recently, but in the final pool game between these two sides at
Newlands, it was the young WP pack that gave the more established Bok laden
scrum a bit of a wake-up call.
Obviously both sides will want to win
desperately, but the home side have a cause - to win it for Cape legends Jean
de Villiers and Schalk Burger, who both missed last year’s win and have never
won the Currie Cup. They are a settled side playing some excellent rugby that
now comes with more attacking intent. A game the players look more happy to
WP to take this one going away...
Tank is a former Western Province tighthead prop and editor of the recently launched free monthly digital rugby magazine called SCRUM
Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse
views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their
own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.