Rob Houwing

Rugby's points not the issue

2012-02-08 11:29
Sport24 chief writer Rob Houwing (File)
Rob Houwing

I popped up to the Green Mile this week to watch defending champions UCT’s first Varsity Cup match of the season against Shimlas, at least partly motivated by a desire to observe for myself the experimental new points-scoring system.

Just for those who do not already know, the competition, with the blessing of the International Rugby Board, is trialling a new scoring method which may - or, just as pertinently, may not - aid the cause of “attacking” rugby.

The Varsity Cup, as a growing but still fledgling entity, is a perfect, progressive vehicle for trying out new things in the game, so in principle I have no objection to the 2012 decision to award three points for a conversion, and reduce the value of penalties and dropped goals to two points.

As it turned out on the evening in question, the new formula barely got an opportunity to be properly tested; it needed a well-balanced contest for that.

Instead a fumbling, bumbling and outmuscled UCT were thumped by a surprising margin of 38-10 (four tries to two). The only difference under the old system would have been the Free Staters winning 37-10 ... ja well no fine and all that.

More of a talking point afterwards, I’d suggest, was the astonishing points swing from the last time these teams met, in the semi-finals last season when the Capetonians won 57-20 at the same venue: it meant a seismic shift of 65 points!

So yes, the merits and demerits of the altered values in certain scoring methods may better be evidenced in some ding-dong fixtures as the competition progresses.

But I nevertheless have an early hunch that they are trying to fix something which ... well, ain’t really broke.

For me the last, universal “correction” in rugby scoring - changing the value of a try from four to five points in 1992 - got the balance in the game right and further fiddling isn’t necessary.

I still believe that the penalty should remain of three-point value, and not two, because far from encouraging positive play you might find that a team which is, say, eight points to the good midway through a reasonably tight contest in other respects and with bonus points not at stake, may be more prepared to sit back and offend in penalty terms - knowing that it would take more than four unanswered pots at goal for the opponents to nose ahead.

As things stand, there is still strong sense - outside of the Varsity Cup, of course - to going all out to avoid concession of penalties when under the cosh, given their reasonably good value in points terms, which in its own way is aiding a constructive approach.

I have a slightly more flexible view on the “drop”: like it or not, there are a few juggernaut rugby union countries, including Australia and New Zealand, where crowds increasingly heckle use of it as a scoring method when a full line of attackers beckons invitingly outside the man (usually the flyhalf, of course) giving it an indulgent stab.

Personally, I still see a certain art form in either landing a snap dropped goal under acute pressure from charging defenders, or banging one over from a spectacular, wind-assisted 55 metres a la Frans Steyn!

I’d keep its value at three ... but perhaps would be less distraught on that front if the IRB did change it worldwide to two.

Rugby’s modern-day bugbears, I suspect, lie in different areas to the value of its points.

The breakdown remains an absolute minefield, too open to subjective officiating, and scrummaging, once a mighty cornerstone of the game, has been reduced to a near-farce far too often.

Scrums are taking an eternity to be set, in the first place, because of the cumbersome, mandatory four-pronged pre-orders involved, collapses chew up time as well and it has become increasingly more fashionable for penalties to scupper the process entirely on the grounds of “early engagement” and the like. 

In broad terms, referees are being seen and heard way too much, which does nothing to benefit viewing pleasure.

These, then, are arguably greater challenges for rugby.

Oh yes, and before I forget: the Springboks would still have been squeezed out in that gut-wrenching 2011 World Cup quarter-final against Australia under the “Varsity Cup” method: the only difference is that it would have been by 9-6 on the scoreboard rather than 11-9.

At the risk of crying once again over spilled milk, the questionable interpretations of a certain whistle-man that day were wholly more influential in the outcome, and somehow symbolic of the game’s greater flaws  in these times ...

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: @RobHouwing

Rob is Sport24's chief writer

Disclaimer: Sport24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on Sport24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Sport24.

Read more on:    varsity cup  |  rob houwing
NEXT ON SPORT24X

Who's in favour with Shakes

2014-12-19 09:54

 

Read News24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
8 comments
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining
Live Video Streaming
  • Blitz
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @00:00
  • SS1
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @01:00
  • SS2
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @02:00
  • SS3
    Mon, 24 Nov 2014 @03:00
Video Highlights
Sport Talk

Live scoring

 

Joburg hot spots for cocktails, craft beer, tapas and wine!

It’s the season to be jolly – so we’ve rounded up some new Joburg hot spots!

 
 

I love summer.24

Christmas lingerie to make this festive season the best one ever!
13 things you might not know about Disneyland
The craziest deaths of 2014
How to make this a sensual, sexy summer!
 
 
/Sport
Men
Women
Love 2 Meet
English Premiership flutter

Take Sport24's "expert" tips at your peril...

Featured

Got something you'd like to get off your chest? Got a burning desire to air an opinion? If so, be sure to sign-up on Sport24's FORUM!

Latest blogs
Vote

The five candidates for SA Player of the Year have been revealed. Who gets your vote?

Twitter Follow Sport24 on Twitter

Facebook "Like" Sport24's Facebook page

Newsletters Sign up for the Morning Glory, Super 15 and Soccer newsletters

WIN Enter and win with Sport24!

Mobile Sport24 on your mobile phone - WAP, alerts, downloads, services

Forum Have your Say on Sport24's brand new Forum!

BlackBerry Stay in the loop on your BlackBerry

iPhone Latest Sport24 news on your iPhone

RSS Feeds Sport news delivered really simply.

Blogs Yes your opinion counts. Get it out there

 
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.